I want a mate for my 100-400is

  • Thread starter Thread starter den
  • Start date Start date

den

Messages
9,608
Name
Dennis
Edit My Images
No
Hi, i have up to £1000 burning a hole in my pocket and i am looking to compliment my 100-400 , nearly all my photos are wildlife and the 100-400 is great as a multipurpose lens i am finding it's not the best /or me for BIF , i have been looking at the 400mm 5.6 and the 300mm f4 IS . Or maybe just a bit more practise with the 100-400 . Now i know the 400 5.6 is not IS but i have heard it can be a lot quicker to pick up than my 100-400 . I also do not mind carrying two lenses around . I think it's that wonderful kestrel shot that as prompted me to look at the 400 5.6 as i believe that member used that set up ,not saying i can get a shot that good but it just shows that its capable . what would be the best option for my money.Thanks
 
For BIF the 400 F5.6 is king - I had one and the autofocus is superb. Oh, and it is damn sharp too.

Just out of interest, how many shots with the 100-400mm are in the 300-400mm range? I found having a 300mm F4, 1.4x and 400mm F5.6 was an excellent two lens combo.
 
Hi Dennis

Can't help with the 400mm, but I have the 300 F4 IS and really like it, quick to pick up as well. The IS is a litle noisy on it, but not excessively and I believe it works well with a 1.4 TC ...


I found having a 300mm F4, 1.4x and 400mm F5.6 was an excellent two lens combo.

Hi Richard,

How did you find the 300 handled with the 1.4TC on - did you notice a drop off in AF speed and what about picture quality ?

Cheers
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the quick replies . i have seen a few reviews on BIF shots with the 400mm ,mainly American reviews were in most cases light as not been a issue and the 400mm wins every time,i have thought of the 300mm with a 1x4but i dont want to dismiss my 100-400 and i think if i get the 300mm with a 1x4 i may not use my 100-400 and it does have it's uses .Looks like i will go for the 400mm , am i correct in saying age of the lens is not going to be a issue with the 400mm.
 
Hi Dennis

Hi Richard,

How did you find the 300 handled with the 1.4TC on - did you notice a drop off in AF speed and what about picture quality ?

Cheers

Image quality, no percievable drop IMO

AF speed, well the drop there was one of the main reasons I added a 400mm to my bag. It retained accuracy, but was definately slower.
 
RichardtheSane said:
Image quality, no percievable drop IMO

AF speed, well the drop there was one of the main reasons I added a 400mm to my bag. It retained accuracy, but was definately slower.

Cheers Richard.

Was aware of the slower AF, but no noticeable difference in quality is good to know
 
The 400/5.6 is a cracking BIF lens Den, not only is is lightweight and mega fast AF but it is also pin sharp wide open which helps a lot when trying to get good shutter speeds. I reckon the 400/5.6 is right up there with the big super teles as far as IQ goes albeit it is slower at f5.6 and does not have I.S. (until recently I had a Canon 300/2.8 IS lens which was stunning so I can compare). With the 400/5.6 I do not miss I.S. one bit, it is just a case of altering your shooting style to get the right shutter speeds (not that you want I.S for BIF).
 
I sold a 400mm this week as I've just bought a 300mm F4 IS.
The 400mm is probably the best value L lens (IMHO), it's tack sharp and AF is lightening fast.
It's only drawback for me was lack of IS but as Roy says, if can change your shooting style its not a problem. Sadly I couldn't do that.
The 300mm is also very sharp and takes my Kenko 1.4X TC without problems.
AF is a bit slower but the sharpness remains. It's the IS that makes it a winner in my book.

The 400mm is king for BIF but I recently went to Gigrin Farm and only had my 100-400.
I'm not that happy with this lens especially at full stretch and wide open but it's probably my lack of skill (settings etc) that make me unhappy with it.
When I use sensible settings it's a good lens.
I was very happy with the BIF I got at Gigrin.
I wouldn't normally show examples in threads like this but this shot was taken with the 300 + the 1.4 TC:



wide open and at 250th which is a speed I could never have used hand-held with the 400mm.
 
Back
Top