"If you're shooting weddings you should always use flash"

Messages
410
Name
Andy Reed
Edit My Images
No
I attended a seminar yesterday on Canon flash. The lecturer began with this quote and I’m really struggling to believe it. I’ve always seen flash as a solution to one of two problems and actually quite a last resort. Either:

1) Not enough natural light to illuminate a scene given the limits of my equipment and within the desired DOF and shutter speed.
2) Combating really harsh backlighting or cross-lighting.

However the expectation that you would always use flash? I accept that when shooting outdoors in particular fill-flash does lift the unsightly shadows especially around the eyes. During yesterdays seminar we were encouraged to use flash in a number of challenging scenes and as I went along I took shots using ambient light only under the same conditions. I have to admit I’m unconvinced in the majority of cases. My non-flash shots have nicer skin tones and simply look more natural. They have shadow but in my mind the equivalent flash shots look quite fake.

Having observed many wedding photographers in action over the years I have to admit the majority do seem to have a flash permanently glued to their cameras. But is this the norm or is it a hang-up from experienced film photographers who are uncomfortable about pushing their ISO?

What is the consensus among pro wedding photographers? Do you constantly use flash or just keep it for special cases when the going gets really tough?

Andy.
 
i would guess it may be to counteract changing conditions. a lot of people seem to have cameras at weddings and they will continually flash, if using ambient light it will affect your shot, whereas the flashguns would be too powerful for the p&s flash to make any difference:shrug:

each to there own though i guess
 
What is the consensus among pro wedding photographers? Do you constantly use flash or just keep it for special cases when the going gets really tough?

Andy.

It really depends on what kind of result you want to achieve, is the ambient light good enough? do you wish to blend available light with a kicker or do you wish to fight the available light right out of the picture and enforce your own?

All can produce beautiful results.

On camera flash is not something I am fond of and will only use it in the most dire of circumstances.

To say that flash must be used at all times is ridiculous, to say that any particular method must be used at all times is equally as stupid.

There are many different ways to skin a cat.
 
The lecturer wasn't a Canon Flash salesman by any chance was he? :D
 
All can produce beautiful results.
Maybe thats what I'm missing. Its really easy to pick out unflattering on-camera flash shots. If it could be done to a standard where you wouldn't know flash had been used I'd be more ready to accept it. This seminar didn't convince me of that.

That's me stuffed then. I rarely use it.
:)

I think they are saying that so you buy flashguns :)
Admittedly they were associated with Canon so there was an element of equipment sales pitch. However the session was more about the proper use of the euipment rather than a sales demo.

Asking the lecturer whether he would be happy with the results I had achieved he said yes, he would see them as being perfectly acceptable to a client. Personally I wouldn't have the nerve to sell them. They were ugly shots.

Andy.
 
Flash done well can be stunning. They way I shoot uses available light but I always have 2 SB900's with me.
 
I really like natural light but I'm starting to experiment more with (speedlight) off-camera flash and, in some circumstances, I think it provides a nice punch to an image. I shot this from a wedding last year and it's one of my favourites (after pics of the bride and groom of course)!

pix9.jpg


The flash was onboard with a Lightsphere diffuser.
 
From a general pov, rather than a wedding tog, I would pretty much agree with what has already been said. Having the flash always handy is useful, and used correctly can indeed counteract harsh shadows sometimes created by ambient light without giving a fake overblown look, but 'always' use? No, I don't think so.
 
A few years back when I used to do weddings and shoot on 'film' I would have the flashgun turned on for the majority on the time, but would set the ASA on the flashgun perhaps double to the film speed that was loaded in the camera. The meter on the camera (or a weston light meter) would give the correct exposure for the available light, and the flash provided just enough light to add some contrast and sharpness.
 

Cheers, Tomas. I had a quick search but the best advice I could find there was to get the flash off-camera. Not much advice for getting stunning results on-camera. I'll have a closer look though.

http://strobist.blogspot.com/2006/03/lighting-101balancing-flash-with.html

I really like natural light but I'm starting to experiment more with (speedlight) off-camera flash and, in some circumstances, I think it provides a nice punch to an image. I shot this from a wedding last year and it's one of my favourites (after pics of the bride and groom of course)!

The flash was onboard with a Lightsphere diffuser.
This is nice and does look natural. Can you share any lessons learnt so far?

I think I'm least convinced from an indoor perspective so far. Unless I had a nice big lightly coloured wall to bounce off close by I'd much rather use natural light. Direct or even softened with a Stofen I still find ugly.

Outdoors in direct sunlight I see the advantage for filling harsh shadow but as mentioned haven't managed to reliably do it without ruining skin tones and accentuating shinny skin.

Andy.
 
Cheers, Tomas. I had a quick search but the best advice I could find there was to get the flash off-camera. Not much advice for getting stunning results on-camera.
Andy.

That's because on camera flash is one of the most ugliest lights there is mate, even with diffusion you very limited in your options with it.
Getting the flash off camera and in a much more appropriate position is the name of the game. :thumbs:
 
That's because on camera flash is one of the most ugliest lights there is mate, even with diffusion you very limited in your options with it.
Getting the flash off camera and in a much more appropriate position is the name of the game. :thumbs:
I definitely agree with you there. I guess that's probably why this guy was advocating on-camera flash for weddings. I can't imagine setting up off-camera lighting can be even remotely practical in that situation.

Andy.
 
I can't imagine setting up off-camera lighting can be even remotely practical in that situation.

Andy.

Think a little more, it's not practical as a sole approach, but there are many opportunities during the day that can present themselves, for example:
the first dance, two speedlights in a cross light set up on the dance floor are going to get some very nice results.

It's very similar to pulling out the odd reflector or diffuser when needed.

There are many ways of applying off camera flash, it's very quick to set up and very effective, it just takes a little effort and practice.
 
It's perfectly practical when you have the camera in one hand and the flash in the other :)

That's how I shoot "on the hoof" of a wedding shoot. I take the 5D in one hand and a 580EX in the other with a lightsphere on it and controlled by a ST-E2. On staircases it's a blindingly good setup.
 
It's perfectly practical when you have the camera in one hand and the flash in the other :)

That's how I shoot "on the hoof" of a wedding shoot. I take the 5D in one hand and a 580EX in the other with a lightsphere on it and controlled by a ST-E2. On staircases it's a blindingly good setup.

Nice one! I had a very nice helper last summer who held a unit for me and fired it through a diffusion panel. :thumbs:
 
I have a 580ex11 on each body at a Wedding, simply because I don't like or can't carry a bag, tuck the ST-e2 behind my ear and some CF cards in my undies and jobs a *** 'un - use it alot in the evening but not really through the day !
 
Just trying to get up to speed with off cam flash for fill, how do people use them, ie on stands, or in hand, or get someone else to hold?

I'm looking at a 420ex, hoping this will be sufficient for what i need to add some umph to some faces?

Sorry to barge in on the thread, seemed most appropriate for my question.
 
Hammerhead was ideal for roll film cameras but the DSLR can cope with a good gun on the top. Just my opinion. :)
3425143837_4a12334935.jpg
 
Just trying to get up to speed with off cam flash for fill, how do people use them, ie on stands, or in hand, or get someone else to hold?

All three work, it really depends on the circumstances, what you have time for, how much room you have to play with.

Here's a great video that explains the basics of gear and how to put it together:

[YOUTUBE]<object width="425" height="344"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/lKAD7leNOVY&hl=en&fs=1"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/lKAD7leNOVY&hl=en&fs=1" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="425" height="344"></embed></object>[/YOUTUBE]

I know a lass who received permission to use a couple of flashes during a ceremony (doesn't happen often), before everything kicked off she super clamped two units, very discreetly either side on balcony above the altar and programmed a very subtle power output. A few test shots were made to determine a nice balance with the ambient light in the church.

The only time she flicked her radio triggers active and used the flashes was for the kiss at the end of the ceremony, the rim lighting through the veil was superb and hardly anyone noticed the flash going off.

Not something that can happen an awful lot but she asked and got awesome frames.
 
Flash is a tool, you shoulnd't cover a wedding without one as it limits your options and its best to avoid limiting your options
 
If your doing shots inside a church, you can be pretty sure the vicar/priest wont allow flash photography event for the official tog.

Some do but most don't, especially during the vows etc.
 
Back
Top