Image pinched from facebook and entered in photo comp by someone else!

sunnyside_up

<span class="poty">POTY (Joint) 2016</span>
Messages
3,622
Name
Bethy
Edit My Images
No
Hiya... Not sure where to put this, but I have just found out that someone has ripped off my image. Basically, I went round a friends house and snapped a few pics of her 2 week old kittens. The owner tagged the recipient of one in one of the photos. She's now taken the photo (what she could download from Facebook), done a stupid cheesy edit on it ( and I mean extremely cheesy) and entered it in a pet photo competition! I found out through my friend that owns the kittens currently. So.... Basically, I think I'm more cheesed off that she ruined the photo with her edit, but the fact that I wasn't even asked if she could use my photo is infuriating. I suppose there is the fact that anything you upload to Facebook becomes more or less public property, but where's the morality? Stupid me, i didn't even water mark the pic as they were for a friend, ... Lesson learned in more ways than one. The photo comp is for a charity, and the prizes aren't really anything to speak of... But its the principle of the matter! Just needed to vent really. Apologies if this is in the wrong section.

Humph!
 
I'd contact the competition organisers and get it removed. Whilst it may only be a small charity thing, I think it's important to stand by the principle in this case.
 
I'd contact the competition organisers and get it removed. Whilst it may only be a small charity thing, I think it's important to stand by the principle in this case.

True, and you can get FB to remove it. Also your meta data should be in there somewhere to prove it's yours and you could also threaten legal action.
 
I suppose there is the fact that anything you upload to Facebook becomes more or less public property,

That thought will persist if no one stands up for their rights. :shrug:

I would get in touch with the person who has stolen your image to get them to stop using it, and to remove it from the competition.

If they don't, then you should get in touch with the people running the competition and inform them that one of your images has been stolen and used in their competition. I'm sure they would not like the bad publicity that would come from a person maybe winning their competition, and it later coming to light that the image was stolen. :nono:
 
I would get in touch with the person who has stolen your image to get them to stop using it, and to remove it from the competition.

If they don't, then you should get in touch with the people running the competition and inform them that one of your images has been stolen and used in their competition. I'm sure they would not like the bad publicity that would come from a person maybe winning their competition, and it later coming to light that the image was stolen. :nono:

:plusone: more than likely innocently done by thinking it's her pet and a quick word can save the day and the friendship ... going in with all guns blazing isn't the best way to resolve this type of issue IMO
 
:plusone: more than likely innocently done by thinking it's her pet and a quick word can save the day and the friendship ... going in with all guns blazing isn't the best way to resolve this type of issue IMO


I'd go with this. Ignorance is no excuse but it may be the case here and a quick word could resolve it.
 
I agree... I've calmed down now... I think it's the 'bad manners' of it all that gets me. Going to send the person an email asking then to withdraw the photo and the reasons why. Thanks for your input all.
 
The person who has used the photo without permission is the breeder's (<-----my friend) recipient, if that makes sense? I've emailed her. We'll see what happens next.
 
Most comps have a clause in the T&Cs in which entrant must state that they have taken the shot or have permission to enter it from the copyright holder.
 
Facebook photo competitions are ridiculous, you could enter an MS paint scribble and still win with a well planned spam campaign.
 
Ok, so the image is removed and I contacted the person running the competition. They wanted ME to provide proof that the image was in fact mine! I did have a go at them for not supplying t&cs relating to image ownership and permissions, to which I got the reply 'we're a charity, an you're not being very charitable' ... Lol. A joke really... Anyway, resolved, but now I am weary of posting images on Facebook without a big old watermark. Facebook doesn't keep the metadata in the image, does it?
 
Blank_Canvas said:
Unbelievable you couldn't make this up - FB has a lot to answer for !

To be honest, I didn't think you were even allowed to run competitions like that on Facebook where money is taken for a submission and given for prizes...
 
To be honest, I didn't think you were even allowed to run competitions like that on Facebook where money is taken for a submission and given for prizes...

What you're allowed to do on Facebook & what actually happens on facebook are two totally different things:D
 
sunnyside_up said:
Ok, so the image is removed and I contacted the person running the competition. They wanted ME to provide proof that the image was in fact mine! I did have a go at them for not supplying t&cs relating to image ownership and permissions, to which I got the reply 'we're a charity, an you're not being very charitable' ... Lol. A joke really... Anyway, resolved, but now I am weary of posting images on Facebook without a big old watermark. Facebook doesn't keep the metadata in the image, does it?

Lol so allowing someone to steal is now classes as charity?

I should rob a bank and have a go at the police that arrest me, accusing them of not being charitable towards me!
 
I appreciate that the photo was stolen and the person taking it should have asked permission, although in my opinion a word with the person taking it would have been sufficient, unless I was planning to market the image or sell it, I don't think I personally would have gone as far as asking for it to be removed etc. I would have been quite happy with a simple apology and rested in the knowledge that my work was going some way to help a charity.

I still agree that this does not compensate for the image being stolen in the first place.
 
Mani Gill said:
I appreciate that the photo was stolen and the person taking it should have asked permission, although in my opinion a word with the person taking it would have been sufficient, unless I was planning to market the image or sell it, I don't think I personally would have gone as far as asking for it to be removed etc. I would have been quite happy with a simple apology and rested in the knowledge that my work was going some way to help a charity.

I still agree that this does not compensate for the image being stolen in the first place.

So you'd be quite happy with someone nicking your photo and making a complete hash of the PP, would you?

It's nothing to do with 'charity', because there's no way for them to make money out of the submissions.....


...unless they've done a rights grab and are intending to sell the pics of course- and what nice charity would want to do that?
 
Mani Gill said:
I appreciate that the photo was stolen and the person taking it should have asked permission, although in my opinion a word with the person taking it would have been sufficient, unless I was planning to market the image or sell it, I don't think I personally would have gone as far as asking for it to be removed etc. I would have been quite happy with a simple apology and rested in the knowledge that my work was going some way to help a charity.

I still agree that this does not compensate for the image being stolen in the first place.

Hmmmmm... I respect your opinion in this matter and how you may have dealt with it, however it's not about charity and getting that 'I've done something good' feeling. It's about the principle of it all. I donate to charity, but I choose who I donate to. And this is not one of them. I don't make oodles of money from photography, but enough to set aside for the special little extras in my kids lives. As far as I'm concerned, Images are property. The organisers had a responsibility to supply and enforce appropriate t&cs to ensure that the entry was a. The owner of the photograph or b. granted permission to use. Being a charity doesn't excuse them from their professional responsibility. And while I'm up on my horse (lol, I'm joking), I think I was well within my right to ask to have it removed. I know of a few photographers who would not have been so gentle.

On the part about the pp that was done to it... It's like I said to the offending doodler... If I had intended the image to look that way, I would have done it myself. Don't graffiti on my freshly painted wall lol! :)

Anyway, like I said, I do respect your opinion, but I needed to handle it the way I did out of principle. :)
 
Nicely dealt with Beth, I'm glad they didn't make it too difficult.
I'm with you on photos being property too, and I bet the thief, I mean breeders recipient, knew full well they shouldn't be taking it and using it. Maybe the PP was to disguise it... like how Chavs put body kits on stolen cars! Tasteless :lol:
 
DemiLion said:
So you'd be quite happy with someone nicking your photo and making a complete hash of the PP, would you?

It's nothing to do with 'charity', because there's no way for them to make money out of the submissions.....

...unless they've done a rights grab and are intending to sell the pics of course- and what nice charity would want to do that?

Hi Mark,

I agree it is clearly wrong to steal, especially a photo which is somebody's individual creation. I'm also saying that with this being a charity it does not negate the fact it is still theft and does not make the situation right, it is still theft. I was just voicing my opinion in that I would look at each situation on its merit. If it was someone taking my photo and selling it as their own, I would have probably been a little more aggrieved. In this instance for me, I think I would have spoken to the offender/charity and made them realise the error of their ways.

I must have missed the bit about the PP, I agree with OP, I would not like my image nicked and then made to look a mess, although mine probably do :(

I'm not a professional and photography is only a hobby for me, which I hope brings joy, otherwise I would not do it, so I may not see it from a professionals point.
 
sunnyside_up said:
Hmmmmm... I respect your opinion in this matter and how you may have dealt with it, however it's not about charity and getting that 'I've done something good' feeling. It's about the principle of it all. I donate to charity, but I choose who I donate to. And this is not one of them. I don't make oodles of money from photography, but enough to set aside for the special little extras in my kids lives. As far as I'm concerned, Images are property. The organisers had a responsibility to supply and enforce appropriate t&cs to ensure that the entry was a. The owner of the photograph or b. granted permission to use. Being a charity doesn't excuse them from their professional responsibility. And while I'm up on my horse (lol, I'm joking), I think I was well within my right to ask to have it removed. I know of a few photographers who would not have been so gentle.

On the part about the pp that was done to it... It's like I said to the offending doodler... If I had intended the image to look that way, I would have done it myself. Don't graffiti on my freshly painted wall lol! :)

Anyway, like I said, I do respect your opinion, but I needed to handle it the way I did out of principle. :)

Hi

I did not mean any offence in writing out my opinion above, I hope it was not taken in that way.

I agree, it is your photo and you have every right to do what you did. I just wanted to state how I would have gone about it, but there are far more people who would have done what you did, rather than the way I would.

As stated, I'm only a hobbyist so I probably cannot see it from a professionals or someone who makes money out of photography point of view.

I'm glad that you stood up for your principles and managed to get your photo back, there is no right or wrong way to do it.
 
Back
Top