In two minds whether to post pics from french zoo

Messages
6,141
Name
Nigel
Edit My Images
Yes
I am on holiday in France at the moment and today I went to La Palmyre Zoo.

My intention was to try to get some good shots, learning from my recent visit to Whipsnade and improving on the set I took at that time.

I took a fair few shots, about 160 I think, but to be honest I'm very much in two minds whether to post any.

The reason for this doubt is as a result of my feelings regarding the wellbeing of the animals at the zoo. The concept of animal wellfare seemed to be very different from say the excellent Whipsnade.

Space at La Palmyre for instance was poor by comparison to Whipsnade. For example, 4 elephants in a space about 100m x 100m. The Hippo enclosure was tiny, as was the zebra enclosure.

My biggest feelings were for the polar bears. I can honestly say I was upset by the behaviour of one of the polar bears that appeared to be exhibiting repetitive OCD type symptoms. It was continually, and I mean continually, submering in water and then pushing itself up to the surface, its face pressed up against the viewing glass window. Up and down, up and down, again and again and again. A classic sign of complete and utter boredom.

I just had the feeling that if this was the french concept of what a zoo should be about, then thank heavens for places like Whipsnade.

Anyway, just had to get this off my chest, because although I took some photos, I did not feel good about doing so, more for the sake of it, if you will.

And that's why I'm in two minds about processing the pics and putting some on the forum.

Should I publicise what I think is a poor example of animal welfare? The images, however good, will always remind me of how I felt during my visit, so is it worth it?
 
I think this is something only you can decide!:(

If it was me, I don't think I would, but it's a tough one.

I think there are probably more reasons not to post them, than there is to post them but others may disagree.........
 
if you dont post them then people cant really see what your talking about the way to stop poor animinal care in zoos is to make people aware so they dont visit them.
 
You don't have to write a narrative. Just post the shots. You are only recording what you saw. It may well be within some sort of 'international standard' for zoos, so what have they got to hide? We can all make our own minds up whether to visit.

Graham
 
You don't have to write a narrative. Just post the shots. You are only recording what you saw. It may well be within some sort of 'international standard' for zoos, so what have they got to hide? We can all make our own minds up whether to visit.

Graham

I think what the OP has an issue with is that by posting the pictures it's ignoring the welfare of the animals, and he feels bad for effectively exploiting the animals for their pictures.

If it were me, I wouldn't, but only you can make the choice.
 
I think what the OP has an issue with is that by posting the pictures it's ignoring the welfare of the animals, and he feels bad for effectively exploiting the animals for their pictures.

If it were me, I wouldn't, but only you can make the choice.

Agreed. Also the OP's shots may not demonstrate the conditions there so by posting them it may encourage others to visit. Sadly the treatment of animals in continental Europe is very different to the UK and is one of the reasons I'd never visit a zoo there. :(
 
If you are that concerned look into how you could report the place in question to the appropriate organisation, who that is though I do not know.

You need to decide if showing them or even working with the images are going to upset you. Photography of the type you have done is not worth going against your morals for. If I was you just leave the pics, even the greatest pic is not worth the smallest bit of animal cruelty.
 
I would post them, treat them like reportage.
I went to monkey forest recently and it was a joy to see the monkeys have so much freedom and open space
they can almost live naturally. not quite but it's fairly close as conservation exercises go
 
just look up the zoo on you tube, and you'll soon see the polar bear. I agree with the author
 
just look up the zoo on you tube, and you'll soon see the polar bear. I agree with the author

I really am annoyed now!! That Youtube video was shot over a year ago and the polar bear is still doing exactly the same thing in axactly the same place!! The poor animal must be out of its head with boredom.

My mind has now been made up. Some of you may think me stupid or ridiculous but I will not be posting any of my shots for critique.

La Palmyre zoo does not deserve any publicity whatsoever in my opinion.
 
I remember watching a programme on the BBC called State Of The Ark about the terrible state of certain European zoos (Belgian and German zoos were featured on the programme with bears and polar bears exhibiting this type of behaviour). I will not look at the footage on Youtube because I know it will upset me too much; just wanted to say that ten years on it sounds as if nothing has changed. :( :( :(
 
Here in France you would contact the SPA (Société Protectrice des Animaux) the equivalent to the RSPCA

Their site can be found here

http://www.spa.asso.fr/

If your french is not up to it just write in English and use an online translator like googles.

Good luck.
 
i'm back in England on Sunday, so I'll start my quest for animal justice then.

Good for you :thumbs:
I can't bring myself to look at the Polar Bear footage either, but if things are as bad as you all say, then I think contacting the groups mentioned above is the best course of action.

Make sure that you include some of your photos too - you might find that instead of making you feel bad, some good may actually come from them.
 
My mind has now been made up. Some of you may think me stupid or ridiculous but I will not be posting any of my shots for critique.

La Palmyre zoo does not deserve any publicity whatsoever in my opinion.

Not stupid or ridiculous. My only concern was that the premise was wrong. If you take that line to it's logical conclusion you would never include subject matter where you had an objection. Most wars particularly Vietnam would be unseen.

My point is bringing it to light which you have done. Showing pictures which illustrate your point may actually help the subjects.

I do however think that posting them for c & c with disregard for their plight would be wrong.

So I think I am agreeing with your decision about showing them merely to be judged on their photographic merit.

Graham
 
Back
Top