Is it me or do Macs show up noise worse than PCs?

Messages
1,449
Edit My Images
Yes
I'm in the middle of switching from PC to Mac. Sold my Dell XPS on eBay and had been using a fairly old flat panel monitor with it.

Got back from shooting a wedding earlier (my first ever, photos to come soon!) and had a quick look at some of my shots and the noise is HORRIFIC. Seriously, absolutely awful. I was shooting at ISO1600 most of the time because the lighting was so bad.

I've not noticed how bad the noise is on my 40D until I open my shots on my MacBook Air.

Thank god i'm converting them all to B&W, the noise really is unbearable. Also my 2nd tog was using a Nikon D300 and the noise on her photos is almost as bad.

I wish I had a better body, the 40D just isn't good enough in low light, even with an f/2.8 lens.

So do Macs tend to show up noise worse? Is it just because i've been using a worse quality screen all this time (i.e. a Dell which must be about 5 years old by now)?
 
I wouldn't have thought the computer would make any difference to the way noise is displayed. Lets be honest, there isn't much difference between a Mac and a PC these days.

It would be interesting to see the results on the old flat panel monitor connected to the Mac to see if you get the old low noise image.

I've not used the Air, only looked at it in the Apple shop. Could it be the display that is giving the effect?

Have you tried printing any of the images to see if they are really that grainy
 
Hey Noah, hope the wedding was alrite. Sounds a like a bit of a challenge if you ask me. You know what my advice would be. It begins with D and ends in 3!
 
Sounds like a calibration issue to me. I suspect the Mac display has a higher gamma level and has a bit more brightness in the shadow areas which is highlighting the noise.
 
Hard to say really, you need to print to see what is really happening. I shot a karate tournament last week on a D300 at ISO1600, gave them some NR on ACR during processing, just to make sure, and had some of them printed at 12 x 8 and they look fabulous with very little signs of noise, if any, at that size.

Different monitors will render the shots differently, as will different graphics cards, my old laptop towards the end of its days became unusable for pics as even stuff shot at ISO100 looked noisy, it was dreadful. :shrug:
 
I wish I had a better body, the 40D just isn't good enough in low light, even with an f/2.8 lens.
I'm a bit surprised by this statement - the noise performance of the 40D is good. At 1600 ISO I'd expect to see some noise, particularly in subdued light.

Noise always looks more noticeable though viewed at 1:1 file size. Printed smaller than that it's unlikely to be noticeable. The same is true reducing the file size, when it largely disappears.
 
i noticed i can see more noise in my EOS 1D mk2 shots now i am using a Mac. I think it must be something to do with the Gamma settings as previously suggested
 
You don't say if you're shooting in RAW or Jpeg? If you're shooting RAW there will be very little (if any) noise reduction prior to processing the images.

I use a 40D and it handles noise very well IMO but if shooting in RAW you have to do some work to process the image to a satisfactory level (which is kind of the point of shooting RAW I suppose :thinking:). Don't blame the 40D.

I also use Mac computer and monitor and it does show up the noise to a greater degree on screen than my old PC used to, simply because its a better monitor so more detail is shown up in all aspects of the image - good and bad (the bad being the noise).

Just be glad you can see the noise on screen before printing a load of £$%$!
 
isn't a mac default gamma something like 1.8 and a pc 2.5? As above, I suspect this is where the issue is. I think the general view is to calibrate to around 2.2 so your pics look decent on all platforms. Printing though, may be an entirely different ball game.
 
They are unprocessed RAWs so there's bound to be more noise on them, but it's something i've noticed generally now that i'm exclusively using my Mac - the noise on all my photos seems more predominant on my MacBook Air...

They are all probably fine, and will look ok when printed and on other screens, it's just weird.
 
isn't a mac default gamma something like 1.8 and a pc 2.5? As above, I suspect this is where the issue is. I think the general view is to calibrate to around 2.2 so your pics look decent on all platforms. Printing though, may be an entirely different ball game.

Some time ago the gamma for a MAC was 1.8 and for a PC 2.2. These were based on uncalibrated monitors and video cards. That was really the only reason. Nowadays with calibration tools widely available and MAC and PC having similar video cards the gamma should be the same. However the viewing screen will also have some influence on uncalibrated systems.

The 2.2 gamma setting is now generally accepted as the "Standard" for both platforms
 
Back
Top