Is my f/8 the same as your f/8?

Messages
3,232
Name
Brian (not Jeff)
Edit My Images
No
Hello, Can anyone help me please?

I own a Fujifilm HS10 Bridge camera, this has a superzoom lens. Am I right to believe that as it is not 35mm format (size) when I set my aperture to (for the sake of argument) f/8 it will not actually be the equivalent of f/8 on my old Pentax 50mm SLR Lens of years ago?

Just curious!

Thanks,

B.
 
Hello, Can anyone help me please?

I own a Fujifilm HS10 Bridge camera, this has a superzoom lens. Am I right to believe that as it is not 35mm format (size) when I set my aperture to (for the sake of argument) f/8 it will not actually be the equivalent of f/8 on my old Pentax 50mm SLR Lens of years ago?

Just curious!

Thanks,

B.

In terms of exposure, yes it will be the same. The f/number is a ratio of focal length and diameter of the aperture, so remains constant.
 
It depends what you mean by equivalent! F numbers are a ratio of the diameter of the "hole" and the actual focal length of the lens (not the 35mm equivalent focal length - that doesn't really exist!). So a 50mm lens with a hole that's 50mm in diameter will be an f1 aperture. That translates to any lens in any format. However, if you expect an f8 aperture on a tiny format digital to give you the same depth-of-field as an f8 aperture on a 5x4 large format film camera you're going to be disappointed! So they're equivalent in the amount of light they pass through but not in other effects.
 
Thanks Guys, I was wondering about the effect it had on shutter speed & depth of field.

So, have I understood correctly? - The same combination of shutter speed & Aperture on both cameras (with the same ISO rating of course) would give the same exposure of light to the sensor/film but the depth of field would be greater with the smaller format lens?
 
Last edited:
Thanks Phil, that's the answer I was looking for. It explains why I struggle to get a fast shutter speed sometimes.

Phil is talking about equivalent depth of field, which at f/8, is actually around f/45 equivalent in full frame 35mm terms.

Nothing to do with shutter speed. In exposure terms, f/8 is f/8 regardless of camera or lens or format.
 
I must have been crop sensor dslr perhaps then?

The DoF converstion is f/number x crop factor, and most superzoom compact/bridge cameras are around 6x crop factor. Quick google confirms Fuji HS10 is actually 5.7x, so f/8 x 5.7 = f/45.5.

Diffraction will be horrendous at that level. Many compacts don't go above f/5.6 for this reason, and use ND filters to control exposure in bright light.
 
Sorry guys, you have lost me completely - It said "talk basics" so I assumed I would get a beginner friendly answer! hahaha

But, have I understood correctly?

Would I get the same combination of shutter speed & Aperture on both cameras (using the same ISO rating of course) from the same metered scene?

And would I then end up with a deeper depth of field from the smaller format lens?

Thanks for helping,

B.
 
Would I get the same combination of shutter speed & Aperture on both cameras (using the same ISO rating of course) from the same metered scene?

And would I then end up with a deeper depth of field from the smaller format lens?
B.

Yes that is correct, exposure will be the same but your camera will have a greater depth of field.
 
Brian_of_Bozeat said:
Sorry guys, you have lost me completely - It said "talk basics" so I assumed I would get a beginner friendly answer! hahaha

But, have I understood correctly?

Would I get the same combination of shutter speed & Aperture on both cameras (using the same ISO rating of course) from the same metered scene?

And would I then end up with a deeper depth of field from the smaller format lens?

Thanks for helping,

B.

More would be in focus from the same f number in comparison to a larger sensor :)
 
Thanks. Got it :)

Some of the wildlife photography "tutorials" that I have read have implied that f/5.6 would not give a good enough depth of field to shoot the birds in my garden with a 720mm lens focussed at 10 to 12M.

I tried some depth of field "field tests" and found that I had about 300mm of what I considered acceptable quality depth of field compared to an online calculator that estimated that it would be about 100mm

I was trying to work out where the discrepancy came from.
 
Last edited:
Thanks. Got it :)

Some of the wildlife photography "tutorials" that I have read have implied that f/5.6 would not give a good enough depth of field to shoot the birds in my garden with a 720mm lens focussed at 10 to 12M.

I tried some depth of field "field tests" and found that I had about 300mm of what I considered acceptable quality depth of field compared to an online calculator that estimated that it would be about 100mm

I was trying to work out where the discrepancy came from.
Apologies to the OP... I know he wanted simple
But yet again we have a newbie tripped up by the simple 35mm equivalent focal lengths some insist on using.:bang:

Why can't people just get used to the fact that a focal length is a focal length - you have to take into account the sensor size when discussing them. For every example where the FL equivalent works as shorthand - there's another example where it'll bite you in the bum.

To the OP - you haven't got a 720mm lens, you've got a 126mm lens which points at an extremely small sensor. So that might be described as a 720mm equivalent - but can lead to all sorts of other confusion when you do.
What does the DoF calculator say about a 125mm lens focussed at 10m?;) (about 0.36m:thumbs:)
 
Apologies to the OP... I know he wanted simple
But yet again we have a newbie tripped up by the simple 35mm equivalent focal lengths some insist on using.:bang:

Why can't people just get used to the fact that a focal length is a focal length - you have to take into account the sensor size when discussing them. For every example where the FL equivalent works as shorthand - there's another example where it'll bite you in the bum.

To the OP - you haven't got a 720mm lens, you've got a 126mm lens which points at an extremely small sensor. So that might be described as a 720mm equivalent - but can lead to all sorts of other confusion when you do.
What does the DoF calculator say about a 125mm lens focussed at 10m?;) (about 0.36m:thumbs:)

Some of us come from a 35mm background and some of us use FF DSLRs. I fall into both those categories so think in terms of FoV in 35mm equivalence. I can't say I've ever used a DoF calculator. I look through the viewfinder, hit the DoF preview button and judge by what the results are. Can you honestly say that you can judge exactly 10m and then the DoF at that distance the DoF? Fine if you're setting up a rangefinder or large format camera but hardly necessary with an SLR (with a DoF preview button).
 
Phil V said:
What does the DoF calculator say about a 125mm lens focussed at 10m?;) (about 0.36m:thumbs:)

Should be enough for even the plumpest of turkeys in flight :)
 
Nod said:
Some of us come from a 35mm background and some of us use FF DSLRs. I fall into both those categories so think in terms of FoV in 35mm equivalence. I can't say I've ever used a DoF calculator. I look through the viewfinder, hit the DoF preview button and judge by what the results are. Can you honestly say that you can judge exactly 10m and then the DoF at that distance the DoF? Fine if you're setting up a rangefinder or large format camera but hardly necessary with an SLR (with a DoF preview button).

I've never used a DoF calculator except to answer a point on a forum. I was offering an answer to the OPs question about the DoF with a 720mm lens which confused him, because he doesn't have a 720mm lens.
That's got to be a reason to get rid of 'equivalent focal length'.
 
We'll have to agree to differ on the efl issue! I find it very useful to know and just wish that my new Fuji HS30 showed the efl in its EXIF rather than the true fl (oh, and it does have a 720 (efl) lens, which is IIRC a 126 real fl.
 
AN EFL is always useful when making comparisons between different cameras with different lenses and different sized sensors. Using 35mm film as a base is as good as anything.
But agree that it confuses the issues with calculations and so on so the reason for it's use need to be fully understood. If only all cameras were the same!
 
Using the 35mm equivalent focal length does level the playing field as long as everyone understands it. The Superzoom has a real short end of 4mm but has a 35mm EFL of 24mm. Comparing just the numbers, the 4mm is 1/2 the focal length of my widest SLR lens but is by no means a fiheye! (although the barrel distortion is quite noticeable if there are straight lines close to the edge of the frame.
 
Sorry guys, you have lost me completely - It said "talk basics" so I assumed I would get a beginner friendly answer! hahaha

But, have I understood correctly?

Would I get the same combination of shutter speed & Aperture on both cameras (using the same ISO rating of course) from the same metered scene?

And would I then end up with a deeper depth of field from the smaller format lens?

Thanks for helping,

Haha that happens to me all of the time. The good news is that if you save your threads you can always refer back to them. I realized that a lot of times the op will give info that is way ahead of me and I won't have a clue. But later I will get to the point where it comes together and need to reread the op response. :cuckoo::thinking::cuckoo::cuckoo:
 
Sorry guys, you have lost me completely - It said "talk basics" so I assumed I would get a beginner friendly answer! hahaha

But, have I understood correctly?

Would I get the same combination of shutter speed & Aperture on both cameras (using the same ISO rating of course) from the same metered scene?

And would I then end up with a deeper depth of field from the smaller format lens?

Thanks for helping,

Haha that happens to me all of the time. The good news is that if you save your threads you can always refer back to them. I realized that a lot of times the op will give info that is way ahead of me and I won't have a clue. But later I will get to the point where it comes together and need to reread the op response. :cuckoo::thinking::cuckoo::cuckoo:

Yes.
 
f8 on one camera is no different to f8 on another, Its the sensor size which is different and it is that which changes the depth of field
 
f8 on one camera is no different to f8 on another, Its the sensor size which is different and it is that which changes the depth of field

I disagree. You see more DoF when using a smaller sensor because you're using wider angle lenses or shooting from a greater camera to subject distance. That's all.
 
I disagree. You see more DoF when using a smaller sensor because you're using wider angle lenses or shooting from a greater camera to subject distance. That's all.

If you're going to nitpick, then it's not a wider angle lens, but a shorter focal length, and camera to subject distance has nothing to do with it.

When the subject is framed the same, from the same position, the camera with a smaller sensor will deliver greater depth of field.
 
If you're going to nitpick, then it's not a wider angle lens, but a shorter focal length, and camera to subject distance has nothing to do with it.

When the subject is framed the same, from the same position, the camera with a smaller sensor will deliver greater depth of field.

Oh dear, you're back on form I see Hoppy :D I wasn't nit picking, as you put it. I was just trying to be clearer in the context of a thread aimed at a relative newby.

When you say "shorter focal length" rather than "wider angle" you're nit picking to a much greater degree than I did and in the rest of your post you're just playng with words as you know perfectly well that (in your words) "When the subject is framed the same, from the same position, the camera with a smaller sensor will deliver greater depth of field"... you'll be using a wider angle (or to nit pick, a shorter focal length lens) on the smaller format camera. That's what I meant :D For example FF and 50mm will give the same field of view as Micro Four Thirds and 25mm... from the same position. So, after nit picking and playing with words you've really just confirmed what I said :D

To say that "camera to subject distance has nothing to do with it" is misleading indeed as you know that camera to subject distance will definately have an effect on DoF.

Fit a 50mm lens to a FF camera and then to a micro four thirds camera (x2 crop) and to frame the shot the same you'll have to increase your camera to subject distance and that will give you more DoF as would leaving the 50mm on the FF camera and increasing the camera to subject distance :D

I posted as personally I think that saying that smaller sensors give you deeper DoF is simplistic and misleading and leads to people believing that you can't get shallow depth of field from smaller format cameras when clearly you can, if they have a reasonably wide aperture (many smaller format cameras don't) and especially if you are willing or able to alter your composition. I personally think that it's much clearer and more accurate to talk about focal length and / or camera to subject distance.
 
My Canon S90 has an f/2 lens and it can't get a shallow depth of field without shooting a macro shot (distance to subject does count).

I don't give two hoots about your contrary point of view but my FF, DX and PAS sensors tell me that for any given shot, the larger the sensor the shallower the DoF (for a given aperture).
 
and what is the focal length of the lens on your Canon S90?

When at f2 your S90 is using a focal length of 6mm. Put a 6mm lens on a FF sensor and you will still have a large depth of field. If my use of DoF calculator is correct, at 10 feet you have from 1.65 foot to infinity!
 
and what is the focal length of the lens on your Canon S90?

When at f2 your S90 is using a focal length of 6mm. Put a 6mm lens on a FF sensor and you will still have a large depth of field. If my use of DoF calculator is correct, at 10 feet you have from 1.65 foot to infinity!

1) If you could put a 6mm lens on a full frame camera you would have a totally different pcture. The comparison is meaningless.

2) Why does the S90 and similar compacts have a 6mm lens? Because it has a smaller sensor. The size of the sensor underpins and drives every other consideration, and with a smaller sensor you always end up with greater depth of field.
 
Tell you what, I would hate to walk into a bar and find you lot discussing the technicalities the way you do here, even as an experienced camera user I would off to the juke box to put on something LOUD! :exit:


:lol:


Sorry guys, just a reminder that this is Talk Basics, can we keep it understandable for new users, save this indepth stuff for the more technical areas. NOT having a go, just offering a gentle reminder :thumbs:
 
The problem here is that not all things can be discussed or answered fully by keeping basic but in those cases that could do with being stated or trigger a different thread in advanced (where is the advanced section?)

But then on the other hand I suppose it could have been kept really basic by just saying "Yes" to the question. :)
 
1) If you could put a 6mm lens on a full frame camera you would have a totally different pcture. The comparison is meaningless.

2) Why does the S90 and similar compacts have a 6mm lens? Because it has a smaller sensor. The size of the sensor underpins and drives every other consideration, and with a smaller sensor you always end up with greater depth of field.

Yes but you keep saying, time after time, in thread after thread, that small sensors give more DoF and that simply isn't true. It's misleading to say things like this in a thread aimed at relative newbies, IMVHO, as it's not the whole reason why.

Yes, small sensors make it more difficult to get shallow DoF.... Because You'll (probably) Be Using Shorter Focal Length Lenses :D

Personally, I just think it's worthwhile being clear so that people can understand what's happening and why, otherwise what's the point of being a geek?
 
Last edited:
Yes but you keep saying, time after time, in thread after thread, that small sensors give more DoF and that simply isn't true. It's misleading to say things like this in a thread aimed at relative newbies, IMVHO, as it's not the whole reason why.

Yes, small sensors make it more difficult to get shallow DoF.... Because You'll (probably) Be Using Shorter Focal Length Lenses :D

Personally, I just think it's worthwhile being clear so that people can understand what's happening and why, otherwise what's the point of being a geek?

Alan, if you feel so strongly about it, why don't you take your crusade to everybody else on all every other photo forum on the planet that says exactly the same as I do? 'Smaller sensors give greater depth of field' is a universal expression now, and I for one know it to be true, but don't let that hold you back.
 
What's the argument here? Larger sensors at the same aperture will have a shallower DOF (more out of focus to be basic).

The smallers sensors will give an effective aperture and effective focal length based on the sensor size.

I would never get the shallow DOF on my X10 as I would a f2, 28mm lens on a FF body because the x10, although boasting an effective 28mm wide angle, has an effective aperture of f7.1 making it significantly less of a DOF machine.
 
What's the argument here? Larger sensors at the same aperture will have a shallower DOF (more out of focus to be basic).

The smallers sensors will give an effective aperture and effective focal length based on the sensor size.

I would never get the shallow DOF on my X10 as I would a f2, 28mm lens on a FF body because the x10, although boasting an effective 28mm wide angle, has an effective aperture of f7.1 making it significantly less of a DOF machine.

Back to the OP though, and what no-one argued about.
An aperture value is fixed. there's nothing to add multiply divide or subtract. F8 = F8 whether it's on a compact, APSC or medium format.
 
ernesto said:
The problem here is that not all things can be discussed or answered fully by keeping basic but in those cases that could do with being stated or trigger a different thread in advanced (where is the advanced section?)

But then on the other hand I suppose it could have been kept really basic by just saying "Yes" to the question. :)

Please whatever you do don't limit your input because a title say "talk basics". I for one find the information very useful even if I may not completely understand all of it now I will refer back when the time is right. If I find a thread that is off base and do not want to take part or it just simply looses my interest I just unsubscribe. Others that are not interested could easily do the same.
 
Phil V said:
Back to the OP though, and what no-one argued about.
An aperture value is fixed. there's nothing to add multiply divide or subtract. F8 = F8 whether it's on a compact, APSC or medium format.

So if you took a 50mm and locked it on f8 and put it on 3 different sensor size cameras the size of the opening (fstop) would stay the same but the dof would change.

As someone else stated, in answer to the original question - yes! Lol
 
shaylou said:
So if you took a 50mm and locked it on f8 and put it on 3 different sensor size cameras the size of the opening (fstop) would stay the same but the dof would change.

As someone else stated, in answer to the original question - yes! Lol

Field of view would also change.
 
Please whatever you do don't limit your input because a title say "talk basics". I for one find the information very useful even if I may not completely understand all of it now I will refer back when the time is right. If I find a thread that is off base and do not want to take part or it just simply looses my interest I just unsubscribe. Others that are not interested could easily do the same.

I never limit myself (not much to limit in any case :) )

But I tend to agree with Yv that we should be limiting it in Talk Basics otherwise the section becomes pointless to those trying to use it and although the question is answered the OP doesn't understand the answer.
On the other hand, I would rather people answer any questions I have as technically or complicated as they need to be if that's what it takes as I want to learn it.
 
Back
Top