Is there a price beyond which improvement in quality is negligible?

Messages
1,355
Edit My Images
Yes
Saw a Hasselblad on sale for more than £20K. This got me thinking...

What justifies this preposterous pricetag? Many, in fact, I'll go out on a limb here and suggest MOST, successful photographers maintain quality and career using kit a fraction of this price. Can there possibly be an objective advantage to shelling out such a large amount of money for a camera? What can you do - that would be noticed - with a £20k camera that you can't do with a £1-4k machine?

Or is it just the case, like a lot of things, that the appeal, for those that can afford it, is the price and the name?
 
If you can grasp the fact that a FF DSLR is intrinsically better quality than an APSC DSLR, which is intrinsically better than a bridge camera, then you should understand that a Hasselblad will produce better images (all things being equal).

So the only important question is 'Do you have a need for this much quality', the answer to which for enough people is 'Yes'. I'm not one of those people, but back in the days of film, the advantage of the bigger negative was worth me going MF. The market for digital MF is smaller than it was for film, but still significant enough to create a market.

In fact FF digital is about the same saturation point that MF was on film. But of course MF was never one size, with negatives from 6x4.5 up to 6x17. Digital MF is taking the market space once held by larger MF cameras and small sheet film cameras.
 
Depends what you are using it for to though...

Not going to any Hasselblads at any sporting events or for photojournalism. However, for weddings, landscapes, and studio uses if you need to print large and maintain a lot of detail then it is more than worth the entry fee.

I'd love a hassy, but there is no way I could ever afford one without being a full time pro working on weddings or studio shoots...
 
totally depends on the situation and print size.


you'd not see any persevable difference between an aps-c, FF or MF digital on a 6x4 or 7x5 or even an A3 on the wall without going right upto it.



If you can grasp the fact that a FF DSLR is intrinsically better quality than an APSC DSLR, which is intrinsically better than a bridge camera, then you should understand that a Hasselblad will produce better images (all things being equal).
.
 
It is just law of diminishing returns as with any products.
Is a £500 camera twice as good as a £250 camera - maybe
Is £10000 camera twice as good as a £5000 camera - probably not as the £5000 camera is at such a high level.
But if you think or need that extra 5% you will need to pay much more than a 5% premium.

I don't generally think people buy £20K cameras as a status symbol and would only buy them if they really do need the 5%.
 
It is just law of diminishing returns as with any products.
Is a £500 camera twice as good as a £250 camera - maybe
Is £10000 camera twice as good as a £5000 camera - probably not as the £5000 camera is at such a high level.
But if you think or need that extra 5% you will need to pay much more than a 5% premium.

I don't generally think people buy £20K cameras as a status symbol and would only buy them if they really do need the 5%.

that would be pretty much my summary too, though with a motor trade background and knowing the same applies to cars, not surprising really ;) :thumbs:
 
ernesto said:
I don't generally think people buy £20K cameras as a status symbol and would only buy them if they really do need the 5%.

I think, given the proliferation of tasteless and very, very expensive Leica limited editions, not to mention the Ferrari-branded Hasselblads, somebody must.....
 
Saw a Hasselblad on sale for more than £20K. This got me thinking...

What justifies this preposterous pricetag? Many, in fact, I'll go out on a limb here and suggest MOST, successful photographers maintain quality and career using kit a fraction of this price. Can there possibly be an objective advantage to shelling out such a large amount of money for a camera? What can you do - that would be noticed - with a £20k camera that you can't do with a £1-4k machine?

Or is it just the case, like a lot of things, that the appeal, for those that can afford it, is the price and the name?

The image quality.
 
I think, given the proliferation of tasteless and very, very expensive Leica limited editions, not to mention the Ferrari-branded Hasselblads, somebody must.....

:agree:
There is always going to be the Snob value to a dear camera that a very few people have to show off.
 
People buying limited edition Leicas etc are keeping them in vaults or display cases. You don't see many people shooting the Nikon FA Gold. Collectors are a different breed.
 
Laudrup said:
The image quality.

Is the image quality worth an extra £15,000? Is it perceivable enough to the end consumer to justify that outlay? That's basically my question.
 
I guess if you want to put it in practical terms: could you find a market for an image taken with a £20k Hasselblad that you couldn't find for an identically composed and exposed image taken with a £2k Canon or Nikon or whatever?
 
Is the image quality worth an extra £15,000? Is it perceivable enough to the end consumer to justify that outlay? That's basically my question.

I'm scratching my head now.

Do you understand that a Hasselblad has a larger sensor?

And that a larger sensor will give better quality large prints?

So there is a quality increase, it's not just about snob value, bragging rights or the build quality of the camera. Some (small) sectors of the photographic industry demand the highest quality output.

I guess if you want to put it in practical terms: could you find a market for an image taken with a £20k Hasselblad that you couldn't find for an identically composed and exposed image taken with a £2k Canon or Nikon or whatever?

So - Short answer.

Yes.

If not having a £20,000 camera means you don't get weekly £10,000 jobs photographing supermodels then the camera is great VFM.:thumbs:
 
If you want the very best possible you will need to pay for it. How much better it is and how much it costs to get that is a consumer choice.

This is the same in any field, but the camera field is less about the name and cachet and more about the end result.
For the opposite, look at people who buy Ferraris. Yes they are nice to drive and nicely made to a high level to allow fantastic performance but the majority of owners probably wouldn't buy one if nobody was going to see them driving it.
The average man on the street wouldn't have a clue what a Hasselblad was and would not even dream that it had cost £20K.
 
Generally you get what you pay for, better build quality, better sensor etc etc, whether the different in price matches the difference in quality is another matter.
Take the Canon 550d, it's using the same sensor as the 60d, both will give the same optical quality, but the 60d is built better, is faster, better focusing etc etc.
 
Is the image quality worth an extra £15,000? Is it perceivable enough to the end consumer to justify that outlay? That's basically my question.

People will own but also rent or lease these cameras for the day or week or specific shoots. If you have top models, designers, actors etc who cost a fortune and want their faces/fashion/film captured in the highest possible quality and enlarged on massive billboards then you use the best equipment. An IQ180 is going to blow away any Canon or Nikon in the IQ stakes and when you can have multi million pound budgets sometimes then £20k for the camera is peanuts.
 
Phil V said:
I'm scratching my head now.

Do you understand that a Hasselblad has a larger sensor?

And that a larger sensor will give better quality large prints?

So there is a quality increase, it's not just about snob value, bragging rights or the build quality of the camera. Some (small) sectors of the photographic industry demand the highest quality output.

So - Short answer.

Yes.

If not having a £20,000 camera means you don't get weekly £10,000 jobs photographing supermodels then the camera is great VFM.:thumbs:
So there is a definite increase in quality? I don't mean just on close and careful analysis, but from even a cursory consideration?

I guess I'm just idly pondering whether it's similar to, say, high end audio. Cable manufacturers charge silly money for dubious technology that, time and time again, industry "experts" and hobbyists cannot distinguish from more basic alternatives in double-blind tests. Yet people shell out for it because it's held in high regard by the audio culture. They probably think they can hear a difference too.

But, like you say, perhaps it's a totally different thing. There's an objective difference that's significantly perceivable by the end user, and that's worth the extra cash.
 
Here's a video comparing the, then new, Nikon D800 with a Hasselblad H4D-40.....

[youtube]9UBTE4xpvpk[/youtube]
 
Last edited:
martyp said:
Depends what you are using it for to though...

Not going to any Hasselblads at any sporting events or for photojournalism. However, for weddings, landscapes, and studio uses if you need to print large and maintain a lot of detail then it is more than worth the entry fee.

I'd love a hassy, but there is no way I could ever afford one without being a full time pro working on weddings or studio shoots...

Have a look at the sports section of David burnettes website
http://www.davidburnett.com/gallery.html?gallery=Sport&folio=Galleries
 
Last edited:
Its not all hasselblad you know lol
And 20k is easily bumped up if you look around.
Phase one make really good mf equipment but in this field of cameras its less about the body and more about what's on the front and what's in or on the back. The body is essentially just a mirror box and prism. Have a look at the specs on the leaf aptus 2 digital back compared to the hasselblad hd that everyone keeps saying got beat by the nikon. its a bit like comparing a d80 to a d3.
Then there is the glass. Worlds apart from your usual stuff, i heard someone saying recently that they love German glass as it attains sharpness through the quality, engineering and glass used and not through contrast that Japanese glass relies on.
But if you need convincing then just check out the work of photographers known to use these systems compared to your shooters using crop or full 35mm frame and ask yourself is it worth it? Not forgetting the top pro shooters using mf are at the top of their game and not just bumping out a few weddings at the weekend
 
So there is a definite increase in quality? I don't mean just on close and careful analysis, but from even a cursory consideration?

I guess I'm just idly pondering whether it's similar to, say, high end audio. Cable manufacturers charge silly money for dubious technology that, time and time again, industry "experts" and hobbyists cannot distinguish from more basic alternatives in double-blind tests. Yet people shell out for it because it's held in high regard by the audio culture. They probably think they can hear a difference too.

But, like you say, perhaps it's a totally different thing. There's an objective difference that's significantly perceivable by the end user, and that's worth the extra cash.

The cameras are totally different (well the senor and lenses anyway). You cannot compare it to different audio cables. That would be more like compare memory cards expecting one to store better images than another.
 
I'm thinking that the word "quality" doesn't really fit the discussion.
After all, we can get quality results from a 6mp D70, so it really is all about size.
If we're gonna throw "quality" in to the equation, given that the glass is as good as it can be, surely the skill of the photographer has far more influence over the "quality" of the output than something as arbitrary as the size of a sensor.
I mean, a crap big picture is no more useful for being big than a crap small picture.
 
Here's a video comparing the, then new, Nikon D800 with a Hasselblad H4D-40.....

[youtube]9UBTE4xpvpk[/youtube]

Interesting vid :)

Telling comment right at the end (16:10) "I can't be seen to be using the same camera as the client, I've got to have the best..." or words to that effect.

At the very highest commercial level where budgets are in the tens of thousands per day, there's a lot of 'marketing' involved in being seen to justify your fee with exotic gear.

I can't see medium format surviving much longer though. Full-frame digital has wiped out Hasselblad's bread and butter market - jobbing commercial and wedding togs. Most medium format film rivals have already gone to the wall.

On the occasions where you need a Hasselblad these days, hire one. They can't survive on that kind of volume, there will be no R&D, and those old Kodak CCD sensors are old hat already with hopeless ISO performance. Hasselblad is little more than a shell company now, they don't actually make anything (Fuji makes them) having changed hands a few times. It's not looking good.
 
Who is to set the standard, and how are the 'degrees of excellence' to be judged?

Nobody sets the standard, the standard of the item in question is determined by comparison to similar objects.]Medium format is higher quality than a FF DSLR but the quality can only be determined when it is compared, you can't just say MF is high quality unless it is measured against a similar item. The quality factors/degrees of excellence depend on the use of the item. For example a camera is judged on ISO, DR, colour, resolution etc because they effect it for the job it is designed to do. Just because a DSLR might record video doesn't make it a higher quality camera because we are comparing them as photographic cameras. Fairly simple really :)
 
Last edited:
Nobody sets the standard, the standard of the item in question is determined by comparison to similar objects. i.e Medium format is higher quality than a FF DSLR but the quality can only be determined when it is compared. Fairly simple really :)

How simple? Can comparison only be made between cameras of the same model, using the same lens, processed the same way, shooting the same thing? Is medium format of higher quality every time? (ie: what sort of camera would take the best quality shots of a football match played under floodlights?)
 
How simple? Can comparison only be made between cameras of the same model, using the same lens, processed the same way, shooting the same thing? Is medium format of higher quality every time? (ie: what sort of camera would take the best quality shots of a football match played under floodlights?)

Ooops you replied whilst I edited :lol: I think my edit cleared things up
 
So are you now saying that the difference in quality is more about the photographer than the equipment?

Nothing like that, I said that the 'quality' difference is dependent on the job it is used for. For example a D4 will produce better quality images at 12800iso than a MF because they aren't designed for that sort of work. However at 100iso in a studio the MF will be miles ahead in terms of quality.
 
Nothing like that, I said that the 'quality' difference is dependent on the job it is used for. For example a D4 will produce better quality images at 12800iso than a MF because they aren't designed for that sort of work. However at 100iso in a studio the MF will be miles ahead in terms of quality.

But surely that is simply saying that a spanner is better at tightening nuts than a screwdriver? How can one be, definitively, better quality than the other when the two tools are designed for different utilities?
 
But surely that is simply saying that a spanner is better at tightening nuts than a screwdriver? How can one be, definitively, better quality than the other when the two tools are designed for different utilities?

Yeah you got it :thumbs: Also a stiff spanner would be of higher quality than a non-stiff spanner because it would do the job much better :thumbs: its all subjective the job in hand
 
Last edited:
Back
Top