Is to much being made of video mode?

To Joe - your daughter didn't swim much did she? And what's she doing bringing your granddaughter with her too - bit cheeky that :D

To all - not read through all of this as I came unstuck when some techie bits started as I have had, and still have, no interest in shooting any form of video

No doubt that will all change when Graphi et al launch their 'Harry Potter' range of storybooks with moving images in them, until then, it's not a feature that would sway me at all - a bit like Liveview in its present form, another interesting feature that's a waste of time at present for me

DD
 
My sentiments pretty much echoed here - http://digitaljournalist.org/issue1...he-canon-7d-making-the-switch-to-hd-dslr.html - by someone who does appear better qualified than me to comment.

Not sure that post does echoes your sentiments, you were talking about average Joe's. This guy is referring to professional video taking and the accessories he mentions are paramount for that.

"At minimum, you'll need some sort of viewfinder to use the LCD screen in the back of the camera. I use the Zacuto Z-Finder, which magnifies the image 3x with Zeiss optics. There's really no way to use the camera without a viewfinder for professional results. This is a must."

Notice he says for professional results. The average Joe is not looking for professional results when he films his son's birthday - it's a home movie. ANd looking through the viewfinder is no different to looking through the camcorder flip out screen. So it's not a must for us average Joe's.

"The onboard sound in any HD-DSLR is abysmal at best"

again, for professional videos this is true. But for the average Joe, the sound quality is as good as any moderate camcorder. It's certainly no worse than my previous panasonic camcorder the HS300 or the HS100 before that. To the average Joe's ear that is. To the pro I'm sure it's easy to pic a difference.
 
From my understanding, putting video onto a DSLR was fairly low. The big cost was putting live-view in. After that, it is just a software extension.

Have to admin, that I have never used live-view in anger either. I can see the point for paparazzi and landscape, but not for wildlife or sports.
 
Not sure that post does echoes your sentiments, you were talking about average Joe's. This guy is referring to professional video taking and the accessories he mentions are paramount for that.

"At minimum, you'll need some sort of viewfinder to use the LCD screen in the back of the camera. I use the Zacuto Z-Finder, which magnifies the image 3x with Zeiss optics. There's really no way to use the camera without a viewfinder for professional results. This is a must."

Notice he says for professional results. The average Joe is not looking for professional results when he films his son's birthday - it's a home movie. ANd looking through the viewfinder is no different to looking through the camcorder flip out screen. So it's not a must for us average Joe's.

"The onboard sound in any HD-DSLR is abysmal at best"

again, for professional videos this is true. But for the average Joe, the sound quality is as good as any moderate camcorder. It's certainly no worse than my previous panasonic camcorder the HS300 or the HS100 before that. To the average Joe's ear that is. To the pro I'm sure it's easy to pic a difference.

Look at posts 2 and 30. I started out by describing the need for all the extra to turn an HD vDSLR into a proper video system. The thread then moved on to discuss "Joe Public". My initial stance was that the camera/lens on its own was insufficient to turn in results worthy of a DSLR video quality.

Let me put it another way - I am not a video professional, or even a video enthusiast. In my eyes that makes me equivalent to a "Joe Public" where video is concerned. However, I would not be satisfied with the wobbly, shakey, OOF, noisey results that Joe Public is likely to produce when hand holding and operating a DSLR as a video camera. I'd really rather not bother. Hence I don't bother.
 
Look at posts 2 and 30. I started out by describing the need for all the extra to turn an HD vDSLR into a proper video system. The thread then moved on to discuss "Joe Public". My initial stance was that the camera/lens on its own was insufficient to turn in results worthy of a DSLR video quality.

Post 2 you said:

I have two DSLRs that shoot video (Canon 7D and 5D2), both bought at the end of October last year. I've had a dabble with the video side of things but it really isn't something that interests me. It was not a feature that swayed me to buy the cameras and I really wouldn't be troubled if neither had video at all. If I was interested in video I'd buy a video camera. I actually do have one but I haven't used it since 2006, and then it was only getting wheeled out once a year to record the Xmas panto of our tennis club.

DSLRs are not at all well suited to the task of video unless you invest in a truckload of accessories to improve the ergonomics and audio quality. I understand that some people have made some great productions with DSLRs as video cams, but not without additional equipment and the expertise to pull it off. For regular Joe Consumer, like me, I don't see much point.

Seems like you were talking about shooting video in general, not just for pro's, you even said that for a regular Joe in this first post. Anyway I'm not nitpicking whether the original article supports your sentiments, it doesn't matter if you wrote that exactly, that could still be your sentiment. I'm not going to tell you otherwise, you know your own opinions!

Even so a zacuto costs £250 and you can purchase an external sound recording device for less than that. You are still left with a camera that even when accessorised up to the level needed for professional recording works out cheaper than a fully pro camcorder - and a fair bit lighter too :thumbs:
 
I think the article agrees with me in that we both say that additional accessories are required in order to make a decent video solution from a DSLR. That includes a viewfinder, external sound and some form of stabilisation. It doesn't matter whether you are a pro, enthusiast or "Joe Pubic". Without those things you have a rather poor video solution.

As soon as you add those things you add to price, bulk, weight, complexity, and while that is fine for the pros and enthusiasts, that is not what Joe Public is going to want, especially if the idea of having a DSLR perform double duty as a camera and camcorder was to save on costs and/or weight/bulk.

For people who claim to be so concerned about the quality of the video image delivered by the sensor, I really feel they ought to pay equal concern to producing a stable, well focused image too. That doesn't come from holding a DSLR out in front of your face, which is why people feel the need to come up with solutions like this....

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z1kCVTczgdA

Not quite as consumer friendly as some would have us believe, is it?
 
I think the article agrees with me in that we both say that additional accessories are required in order to make a decent video solution from a DSLR. That includes a viewfinder, external sound and some form of stabilisation. It doesn't matter whether you are a pro, enthusiast or "Joe Pubic". Without those things you have a rather poor video solution.

As soon as you add those things you add to price, bulk, weight, complexity, and while that is fine for the pros and enthusiasts, that is not what Joe Public is going to want, especially if the idea of having a DSLR perform double duty as a camera and camcorder was to save on costs and/or weight/bulk.

agreed. But comparing what Joe public can get from a standard camcorder he's going to get at least the same results from his dSLR as he would with his normal camcorder. As shown above in my swimming video

If he wants to get better quality he can't use his dSLR as it comes but his normal camcorder isn't going to do it either. So either way he needs to either add all those accessories or buy a much more competant camcorder
 
Back
Top