Is to much being made of video mode?

Messages
56
Edit My Images
Yes
I saw this survey http://www.whatdigitalcamera.com/interactive/polls.html and started wondering are we making a big issue regarding movie mode.

For example camera reviews often criticises cameras that don't have this function but If only 28% stating they favour movie mode then movie mode should not be stated as a big feature.
 
I have two DSLRs that shoot video (Canon 7D and 5D2), both bought at the end of October last year. I've had a dabble with the video side of things but it really isn't something that interests me. It was not a feature that swayed me to buy the cameras and I really wouldn't be troubled if neither had video at all. If I was interested in video I'd buy a video camera. I actually do have one but I haven't used it since 2006, and then it was only getting wheeled out once a year to record the Xmas panto of our tennis club.

DSLRs are not at all well suited to the task of video unless you invest in a truckload of accessories to improve the ergonomics and audio quality. I understand that some people have made some great productions with DSLRs as video cams, but not without additional equipment and the expertise to pull it off. For regular Joe Consumer, like me, I don't see much point.
 
I have two DSLRs that shoot video (Canon 7D and 5D2), both bought at the end of October last year. I've had a dabble with the video side of things but it really isn't something that interests me. It was not a feature that swayed me to buy the cameras and I really wouldn't be troubled if neither had video at all. If I was interested in video I'd buy a video camera. I actually do have one but I haven't used it since 2006, and then it was only getting wheeled out once a year to record the Xmas panto of our tennis club.

DSLRs are not at all well suited to the task of video unless you invest in a truckload of accessories to improve the ergonomics and audio quality. I understand that some people have made some great productions with DSLRs as video cams, but not without additional equipment and the expertise to pull it off. For regular Joe Consumer, like me, I don't see much point.

To get equivalent quality of video from a dedicated video camera, that a dSLR can provide you with... you'd be looking at spending £thousands!

The relatively small task of adding video capability, is a good idea.. even when purchasing the additional extras to fully make use of the video feature, I bet you'd still be saving a couple of £thousand!

The reason why a £200 HD DV camera won't give equal results? It doesn't have the wide range of lenses to use... and it simply won't give the small depth of field that creative video users need. Then of course there is better noise handling in low light due to the larger sensor.. and so on and so forth..

I don't think manufacturers added it to peeve photographers... more to attract videographers! It's worked too.. I know a good number who have switched to 5D Mark IIs for the main bulk of their video work!
 
i would rather the effort was put towrds the still image or reducing the price.
 
i would rather the effort was put towrds the still image or reducing the price.

Thanks to video we may likely get faster readout, electronic shutter (eliminating the dreaded shutter failures), pixel binning, high ISO performance, decent liveview autofocus and so on. It may be a couple of camera generations until it all materialises - and I can't wait.
 
Personally I think of video capabitliy on a DSLR as an added bonus, nice to have if you ever decided to use it, but certainly not a deciding feature in choosing a camera.

Agreed, it's handy to have but was actually a buying factor, but not a major one, for me. We have a camcorder here that the wife bought 4yrs ago and it's never been used, we never take it with us although occasionally wish we had. That's when the built in video comes in handy as we always have the D300s with us.

I have had a quick play with the video function and whilst it's not the easiest of things to master, the image quality with my 50mm @ f4 was outstanding - obviously the quality of glass that can be used with a DSLR is better than a £200 camcorder, but autofocus takes some practice :lol:
 
Don't under-understimate video as a feature to have. I've used it a few times just to record personal moments, and it's brilliant to have that opportunity

Can't see myself putting together a film just yet as it's quite time consuming and would place big demands on my laptop but it's a lovely feature to have
 
I use very few of the functions available on my dslrs. But i am sure somebody uses each and every one of them. A significant minority use video just like a significant minority use ultra high iso settings. Video has now become normal in dslrs and so cameras will be judged on this basis in reviews just as they are judged on high iso performance. If reviews only looked at the key functions all photographers use they would be short and pretty useless reviews along the lines of "this camera takes great photos in everyday situations".
 
Its all been said above, when buying a stills camera that is what you look for but should it have video capability it is a nice feature that you will have to hand, I wouldn't buy one just because it has video on it. I rarely used the video camera we had, it was just a pain to carry about but I always had a camera with me and still have a camera with me most of the time so having something with you that will is a bonus and has the chance that it will get used.

Its the same with phones with a camera, no one took photos for pleasure originally when they had to take the camera out with them, now most phones have a camera everyone has a camera with them and use it more than they would before. When it comes to some people looking for a camera added features can make or break a deal, most people moving from a point and shoot are used to having video on the camera so they will look for video on a DSLR and it will affect their decision.
 
I've only had my 5D2 a couple of days but find the video side is interesting me more and more. Working out how to get the best from it and how to edit it.

Like other posters above we have a camcorder but it rarely gets used even if it does come on holiday with us. Having video to hand as an option on a camera that I'll be using all the time means video will get shot. knowing that the quality will be good makes it more likely too.

Now i just have to learn how to do it :)
 
i use a good quality compact to video it then leaves me with my DSLR to take pictures at the same time.
its nice to have it but does it add to the weight/cost of the camera?
 
I saw this survey http://www.whatdigitalcamera.com/interactive/polls.html and started wondering are we making a big issue regarding movie mode.

For example camera reviews often criticises cameras that don't have this function but If only 28% stating they favour movie mode then movie mode should not be stated as a big feature.

we have digital cameras and digital video

guess which one we take the video on;)
 
I find the replies interesting in respect to -nice to have but not necessarily to use.
 
i use a good quality compact to video it then leaves me with my DSLR to take pictures at the same time.
its nice to have it but does it add to the weight/cost of the camera?

This is the thing, I'm not sure about others but on the 500D you can shoot images while the video is recording, now that is a nice feature. The negative side of that is that you get the sound of the shutter going in your video soundtrack.
 
This is the thing, I'm not sure about others but on the 500D you can shoot images while the video is recording, now that is a nice feature. The negative side of that is that you get the sound of the shutter going in your video soundtrack.

:gag:

talk about multi tasking...that for me is overkill
 
I think it's a very nice feature to have. Even if you don't use it often it's nice to know it's there should you ever need it. And for alot of professional photographers (not including sports or studio shooters) it is going to become a bigger and bigger part of your job.
Wedding photographers especially need to be able to diversify and add video to their repertoire. And think of it this way, if you learn how to do it now at what is essentially the start of the convergence of media then you can add it as a billable item. Wheras, if you start with video in a few years when the vast majority of people are also offering it then you probably won't do as well out of it.
I heard it explained recently that if photographers start offering video now then they can build in the cost to them of: new gear, software, time, learning costs etc.

Also, one argument I have heard against having video on dSLR's is that people would do without it and prefer to save themselves money. Really that isn't a factor since access to video on dSLR's is only limited by the firmware they use. So, if video wasn't included on a camera such as 7D or 5D2 it wouldn't have reduced the price much, if at all.

That's my 0.02p
Tom N.
 
Do not have video on a DSLR at the moment, but will probably getting a 7D for my wife soon. Video will not be the reason for upgrading her 10D, but am intrigued if still images can be acquired from video footage and - if so - what is the quality?
 
I was talking to a bloke who told me that I could pull stills from the video due to it being 1080p HD I have only used the video feature on 2 occasions once for some fireworks the 2nd time to see if I could shoot photos while recording video and it worked.

I will have a go at it at some point and see what the results are like.
 
Personally I think of video capabitliy on a DSLR as an added bonus, nice to have if you ever decided to use it, but certainly not a deciding feature in choosing a camera.

In my case it decided me NOT to buy the 500D because all I want from a camera is a camera NOT something more to go wrong and NOT something I had no intention of using but which I would have to pay for.

And I definitely agree with straycat - I would much rather they reduced the cost of the camera.

And to be quite honest most of the "films" I've seen made with them are simply rubbish - and pretentious to boot!
 
Do not have video on a DSLR at the moment, but will probably getting a 7D for my wife soon. Video will not be the reason for upgrading her 10D, but am intrigued if still images can be acquired from video footage and - if so - what is the quality?

If recording video at 1080p then you would get about the equivalent of a 2 megapixel image.

Tom N.
 
Wedding photographers especially need to be able to diversify and add video to their repertoire.

Wedding videos have been available for years from many firms.

And they use real video cameras not DSLRs.
 
Wedding videos have been available for years from many firms.

And they use real video cameras not DSLRs.

I didn't say wedding videos haven't been available for years. And dSLR's are real video cameras. If you mean dedicated video cameras then dSLR's still win, for me. As has been mentioned before they provide the best results at their price point and the flexibility they have is invaluable.

This was posted a while back on this or another photography forum and was shot almost entirely on 5D Mark II's. LINK!

Tom N.
 
I didn't say wedding videos haven't been available for years. And dSLR's are real video cameras. If you mean dedicated video cameras then dSLR's still win, for me. As has been mentioned before they provide the best results at their price point and the flexibility they have is invaluable.

This was posted a while back on this or another photography forum and was shot almost entirely on 5D Mark II's. LINK!

Tom N.

very interesting...i am not an expert...but think the digital video camera is the one for the job...using tape
 
The more I'm playing with video on the 5D2 the more impressed I'm getting. It takes a bit more than setting the controls to auto and pressing the button but the results are very good - especially now I'm experimenting with the 50mm 1.4 fitted.

I can't see any camcorder coming near to what i'm seeing in full HD. I will admit the camcorder would be a darn sight easier to use but the 5D2 does seem worth the learning curve so far.

All the onlline tutorial stuff seems to date from before the latest firmware which now gives better control so i'm finding my own way a bit.... slowly :)
 
i love the video on my 7D, but I'd still use my HD DV Camcorder over it, there's too much faff with the 7d, no autofocus/autometering for a start and it's not just point, shoot, press as the camcorder is

but

if the 7D's setup on tripod at the bird feeder/lake then it's nice to shoot with and do manual focus, not to mention the quality of it
 
We've been using the 5dmk2 and RED for some video work we're doing. Can't believe people are writing off video on the 5dmk2 as some sort of sales gimmick.
 
I think its a great option to have, and one of the reasons I am probably going to go for a D300s over a D700 (wish I had the money for a D3s lol!) unless the D700s becomes a reality.

One of the best videos I've seen shot with a DSLR (5D mkII)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ADNb0F0YjNI
 
We've been using the 5dmk2 and RED for some video work we're doing. Can't believe people are writing off video on the 5dmk2 as some sort of sales gimmick.

Yes, but what sort of accessories do you require in order to make the 5D2 function successfully as a "video camera"? What do you do for sound - microphones, mixing, controling levels and synching? What do you do about follow focus? What do you do about steadying the camera - tripod only, steadicam rig, hand held, something else? How do you monitor the scene - external monitor, Z-Finder type thingy, builtin LCD, something else? How do you control zooming without causing shake?

I assume you don't just stick a lens on the thing and then point and shoot. What is the rough cost for turning a 5D2 into a professional grade mobile video camera for tracking shots, maintaining focus and recording stereo or surround sound (without handling noise) that befits an HD image?

Also, what about jello on pans or fast sideways action? What about aliasing on sharp horizontal details? What about the PITA non standard frame rates? What about the difficulty of editing native files with most "amateur" software and the majority of hardware that home users have available? What about the limited file sizes and/or clip lengths? As far as I know, these cameras do not pixel-bin to get down from ~20MP to 2MP. They line skip, which means inferior noise performance relative to stills shot at equivalent ISOs, and is the cause of the aliasing problems I mentioned earlier.

How about lighting? Bouncing a flash won't cut it, so that's a whole new ball game too.

I'm sure nobody denies that lovely results can be obtained, but it isn't as simple as just sticking a lens on the thing and going off to shoot something, is it? Just as there is a big leap from "point and shoot" photography to maximising the results from a DSLR, the move to video is one that requires a whole new skillset and viewpoint too, never mind the supporting paraphenalia. The IQ might be good, given the right circumstances, but ergonomically, DSLRs suck as video cameras - IMHO - unless you kit them out with all manner of accessories to make them work as a video camera should.

This looks like the sort of setup you need in order to turn your DSLR into a "proper" video camera, or am I wrong? - http://digitalphotographer.com.ph/forum/showthread.php?t=24968 or http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ROaV3rSkgBA or http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_3tHON2H6HU&feature=SeriesPlayList&p=0AC6E6E244DF0FCA

(BTW, as I'm sure you can tell, I'm clueless about video, so I'm sure there are several other questions that should be asked and answered, but I don't know what they are.)
 
Haven't seen a single video posted on TP - that says quite a lot I think.
 
Haven't seen a single video posted on TP - that says quite a lot I think.

There's been quite a few, mainly the "look at this link from the web" type thing showing what is possible with the new breed of DSLRs and mostly from Weddings. One I remember is a wedding video taken on the 5DMK2 of an oriental couple in the states but TBH that was more videography than photography. The other one that stands out (and on I want to find the link again but can't) is a wedding slide show where the tog put small video clips between the stills and showed me the possibilities of video on a DSLR, in one bit there was the classic bridal pose in a window seat but the next image was actually a video clip of her standing up and walking away (no sound, just brilliantly lit motion in time with the selected score).

I can see the possibilities and my next camera will definitely have Video, I just can't decide on the D3S or the D300S (well I can but I just need to figure out how to afford it ;))
 
Sorry I meant videos posted and taken by TP members - quite a few of them have cameras with video capability.
 
Sorry I meant videos posted and taken by TP members - quite a few of them have cameras with video capability.
I agree for purpose of debate where are the tp users making video? The ones I have seen have all been professionally made including the link posted by Newbeee.
 
I agree for purpose of debate where are the tp users making video?
Perhaps there is a need for a new sub-forum dedicated to the video side of things. POTN, for example, has set up a video area....

http://photography-on-the.net/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=131

The ones I have seen have all been professionally made including the link posted by Newbeee.
Quite. Video is not an extension of photography. It is a whole seperate genre of image making, with sound and a host of other things to consider, and a whole new skillset and toolset required. Just because DSLRs can now "do video" does not suddenly make it easy to make good videos. All the sensor IQ in the world is no use if your pictures are shakey, your subject OOF, your sound poor and your storyline uninspiring. It's much the same as expecting miracles from replacing your point and shoot with a professional DSLR. If your skills aren't there then having a great camera will probably not help much. Indeed, results may actually go downhill.
 
That was my point Tim - people are dashing out to buy the latest models with video - and yet they are wholeheartedly failing to make videos worth watching - if they were I'm sure they'd be all over TP. There is a LOT more to it than the equipment as you say.
 
When i decided to go for a 5D2, video capabilities didn't figure in the decision process but since I've had the camera i have used the video function quite a bit usually when we are out as a family , not video that would be posted on a internet forum.
 
Yes, but what sort of accessories do you require in order to make the 5D2 function successfully as a "video camera"? What do you do for sound - microphones, mixing, controling levels and synching? What do you do about follow focus? What do you do about steadying the camera - tripod only, steadicam rig, hand held, something else? How do you monitor the scene - external monitor, Z-Finder type thingy, builtin LCD, something else? How do you control zooming without causing shake?

I assume you don't just stick a lens on the thing and then point and shoot. What is the rough cost for turning a 5D2 into a professional grade mobile video camera for tracking shots, maintaining focus and recording stereo or surround sound (without handling noise) that befits an HD image?

Also, what about jello on pans or fast sideways action? What about aliasing on sharp horizontal details? What about the PITA non standard frame rates? What about the difficulty of editing native files with most "amateur" software and the majority of hardware that home users have available? What about the limited file sizes and/or clip lengths? As far as I know, these cameras do not pixel-bin to get down from ~20MP to 2MP. They line skip, which means inferior noise performance relative to stills shot at equivalent ISOs, and is the cause of the aliasing problems I mentioned earlier.

How about lighting? Bouncing a flash won't cut it, so that's a whole new ball game too.

I'm sure nobody denies that lovely results can be obtained, but it isn't as simple as just sticking a lens on the thing and going off to shoot something, is it? Just as there is a big leap from "point and shoot" photography to maximising the results from a DSLR, the move to video is one that requires a whole new skillset and viewpoint too, never mind the supporting paraphenalia. The IQ might be good, given the right circumstances, but ergonomically, DSLRs suck as video cameras - IMHO - unless you kit them out with all manner of accessories to make them work as a video camera should.

This looks like the sort of setup you need in order to turn your DSLR into a "proper" video camera, or am I wrong? - http://digitalphotographer.com.ph/forum/showthread.php?t=24968 or http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ROaV3rSkgBA or http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_3tHON2H6HU&feature=SeriesPlayList&p=0AC6E6E244DF0FCA

(BTW, as I'm sure you can tell, I'm clueless about video, so I'm sure there are several other questions that should be asked and answered, but I don't know what they are.)

Pretty much the same stuff as if you were using a dedicated HD video camera then?
 
Perhaps there is a need for a new sub-forum dedicated to the video side of things. POTN, for example, has set up a video area....

http://photography-on-the.net/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=131


Quite. Video is not an extension of photography. It is a whole seperate genre of image making, with sound and a host of other things to consider, and a whole new skillset and toolset required. Just because DSLRs can now "do video" does not suddenly make it easy to make good videos. All the sensor IQ in the world is no use if your pictures are shakey, your subject OOF, your sound poor and your storyline uninspiring. It's much the same as expecting miracles from replacing your point and shoot with a professional DSLR. If your skills aren't there then having a great camera will probably not help much. Indeed, results may actually go downhill.

Try telling a director of photography that video isn't a form of photography. No one is saying it's easy to make videos, not sure where you're getting that from. Just like it's not easy to take great still images.
 
The biggest feature is DOF, oh and also loads of DOF. Other than that it's all uphill.
If you intend devoting as much time/budget to video as you devoted to photography then many issues can be worked round though.
Here'a a video expert and DOP's point of view.
http://www.dvuser.co.uk/video-play.php?VID=63
 
Back
Top