Just how good/bad is the 5d for sports?

Messages
2,553
Edit My Images
Yes
I am just in the process of going from a 50D to a 5D.

I know that they are not ideal for sport, but I would like to use it occassionaly for Rugby/surfing.

So apart from the cropped sensor bit, what are the pro's & cons of using a 5D for sport?

Thanks in advance

Spence
 
Hi

Biggest con I would have thought would be the infamous autofocus.

Cant comment from experience I'm afraid.

Regards

Danny
 
The AF system would be my biggest concern if you mean a 5D rather than a 5D MkII.
 
Hi

Biggest con I would have thought would be the infamous autofocus.

Cant comment from experience I'm afraid.

Regards

Danny

Than Mahoneydd187,
Looks like a rethink maybe.

The AF system would be my biggest concern if you mean a 5D rather than a 5D MkII.

Thanks DL,
I have used one for a couple of weddings, & was really impressed with the image quality.

I did mean a 5D, & not a 5D MkII.

Spence
 
Thanks DL,
I have used one for a couple of weddings, & was really impressed with the image quality.

I did mean a 5D, & not a 5D MkII.

Spence[/QUOTE]

5D and 5D II have, I'm almost certain, the same (and now outdated) af system.
 
Never had an issue with surfing or U9's rugby with my MK2 - never noticed a difference in focus speed from my 50D :shrug:
 
It's a similar focus system to your 50D.

IIRC, it has less cross type AF points, but some additional invisible AF points that aid the centre point.
 
Never had an issue with surfing or U9's rugby with my MK2 - never noticed a difference in focus speed from my 50D :shrug:

It's a similar focus system to your 50D.

IIRC, it has less cross type AF points, but some additional invisible AF points that aid the centre point.

Thanks all,
But will this also apply to the 5D?
Spenc
 
I've used mine for motorsport with a 100-400 which only has a maximum aperture of f/5.6 at the long end, which is not the ideal aperture to assist autofucus, and I've been more than happy with the shots I've got with that combination.
 
As a 5D owner Af has always been fine, as for sport the fps are going to let you down, my 5D is for portrait and landscape with a few planes landing, for boxing and MMA I am going for the 1DIii or 1Diin

Merc
 
Depends really on the specific conditions you are shooting under and what you intend to capture. For example, village green cricket on a fine sunny day will be fine but rugby/football under floodlights will probably challenge the 5D to the max. Depends a bit on your lenses though.

You then have the problem that the 5D AF points are clustered in the centre of the viewfindr so this MAY not give you the composition that you want with AF.

Next there is the number of fps which is a bit low on the 5D for action sports.

Then there is the responsiveness of the AI servo mode which you might use. This again is not the best.

Oh yes, then there is the weather sealing...

Lots of people will advise you that you CAN get great sports images with the 5D but you might find it a bit frustrating for low light action shots.

I do have a 5D1 but would always pick up the 1D3 for sport to obviate the above, and other reasons.

Personally, I would look at a used 1D2N for about the same price as a decent 5D plus grip, or, if you want to push the boat out a bit try a used 1D3.

Basically, a 5D CAN get good sports images it is just so much easier and effective to do so with one of the aforementioned bodies.

Good luck in your selection.
 
I know it is not what the OP asked for but have just noticed that MPB have a 1DIIN for sale for £719 with a new shutter put in some time ago. You could check out the reviews of this at Fredmiranda here:

http://www.fredmiranda.com/reviews/showproduct.php?product=297&sort=7&cat=15&page=1

This really is a good sports/action cam and will keep the surf out a treat.

Before anyone asks, I am not connected with MPB. This is a hell of a camera for relatively little money !
 
Back
Top