Kodaks' patent spat threatens photo web sites

Messages
372
Name
Chris
Edit My Images
Yes
Kodaks' patent spat threatens photo web sites

The fallout from a patent dispute between Kodak and web photo site Shutterfly could embroil many online image sites, says patent experts.

Kodak claimed it owns patents regarding the display of online images that is being infringed by Shutterfly.

The photo-sharing site disputes these claims and has launched a counter suit.

But the landmark case could have ramifications for other popular online photo sites such as Yahoo's Flickr and Google's Picassa.

The past two years have seen a number of cases launched that claim online photo sites have breached patents.

But this is the first time such a large, established technology company has sought to assert its rights over online images, said Deborah Bould, a specialist in intellectual property at law firm Pinsent Masons...

Additional information at the BBC.
 
So in a desperate attempt to survive, they're becoming a patent troll...
 
Probably not, Kodak owns loads of patents to do with digital photography.
Kodak last year had sales of $7bn.
 
yeah like Dave says, it just seems like a last attempt at keeping in business. Look at the bottom aswell, Kodak are going to sue Blackberry and Apple makers for using patent technology in their handsets.

Look like there's a war going on :lol:
 
Depending on the patent wording you will probably find it will be unenforceable as it sounds overly broad. Also depending on the filing date there might well be a ton of prior art that renders the patent worthless.

Sad to see such a once popular a company become a troll though.
 
I wonder what apple can find to file a counter case against Kodak. I suppose it makes a change from it just being the phone manufacturers going after each other.
 
I find it silly. Software patents are the bane of the world, they stifle innovation as the broadness of some of these patents can effect many technologies not relating to the company that owns them.
 
I find it silly. Software patents are the bane of the world, they stifle innovation as the broadness of some of these patents can effect many technologies not relating to the company that owns them.

You can't patent software.
 
You can't patent software.

You can in the US, which essentially means you can more or less world wide. The US patent system is the big problem, as its does little to no checking before granting a patent and leaves it up to the holder to sue and see if it sticks.
 
There have been similar cases in the software world and they generally haven't turned out well for the litigator. SCO vs Novell springs to mind. It's often the sign of a failing organisation desperate to survive.
 
You can in the US, which essentially means you can more or less world wide. The US patent system is the big problem, as its does little to no checking before granting a patent and leaves it up to the holder to sue and see if it sticks.

No you can't - software is still not statutory subject matter under US patent law. There is also as much 'checking' under the US system as there is in any other jurisdiction.

You can in the US, which essentially means you can more or less world wide.

Don't get it.
 
You can't patent software.

Then how did Intel successfully sue AMD over the microcode AMD stole out of Intel processors? Could it have been copyright rather than a patent issue? If one can't protect one's intellectual property how come Microsoft got as big as they did?
 
I must say that given the strength of feeling here about photographic copyright infringements it seems a bit hypocritical to criticise a company for attempting to protect its patents. Or has Kodak become a charity and not told any body? Mind you Kodak got caught with it's trousers down when they tried to copy Polariods patented processes.
 
Then how did Intel successfully sue AMD over the microcode AMD stole out of Intel processors? Could it have been copyright rather than a patent issue? If one can't protect one's intellectual property how come Microsoft got as big as they did?

Possibly copyright, possibly clever claim drafting, not sure of the facts. You cannot patent software per se, but you can patent a practical application of software (e.g. something involving a specific 'machine' or a transformation, in the US).
 
Last edited:
I must say that given the strength of feeling here about photographic copyright infringements it seems a bit hypocritical to criticise a company for attempting to protect its patents. Or has Kodak become a charity and not told any body? Mind you Kodak got caught with it's trousers down when they tried to copy Polariods patented processes.

Exactly - they're not really trolls in the classic sense as they didn't just buy up the IP to use for litigation; there's r&d of their own doing behind it. Perhaps they simply decided to get into that business now. Perhaps negotiations to license the tech to the companies listed failed. Perhaps they simply forgot they had these patents (can happen if there's a large portfolio), and so on.
 
I think the reason people get annoyed is more why are they doing it now only when there's money to be made vis suing, rather than when 1st granted to protect the technology.

but you can patent a practical application of software (e.g. something involving a specific 'machine' or a transformation, in the US).
Which is what most people understand to be a software patent, but you are right a "software patent" doesn't exist as such, but the bottom line is the same.
 
Last edited:
I must say that given the strength of feeling here about photographic copyright infringements it seems a bit hypocritical to criticise a company for attempting to protect its patents.
Well said!
 
Sorry, but when did I say Apple where in the clear? They are just as bad as any when it comes to overly broad or trivial patents.
Sorry, I didn't mean to imply that you thought otherwise. I was just making the observation that there were lots of people giving Kodak a kicking, but I don't recall ever seeing similar responses to Apple's patent disputes.

Kodak suing someone over patents means the company is clearly on its knees.
But Apple suing someone over patents doesn't mean the company is clearly on its knees.
 
? If one can't protect one's intellectual property how come Microsoft got as big as they did?

Closed source, the windows source code is extremely well guarded (though large portions of it do occasionally get leaked).

There are free alternatives, have been for decades (I use linux as my primary OS), but marketing is king and M$ have tremendous marketing clout.
 
You missed Cisco Systems, Inc. suing Apple. Cisco own the trademark for the name "i-phone", and successfully sued Apple over it's use - however they came to an "agreement" out of court ;)
 
hmmm i wonder if we should think of as may i-names as possible and register them all then apple's next venture we can get a good payout. I'm thinking iDrive as some special mac hard disk that sings and makes tea at the same time
 
hmmm i wonder if we should think of as may i-names as possible and register them all then apple's next venture we can get a good payout. I'm thinking iDrive as some special mac hard disk that sings and makes tea at the same time

I think BMW own iDrive.:geek:

TBH, I'm getting sick of iThis and iThat. Even KFC have an iChicken or something. It's getting ridiculous.:cuckoo:

Just goes to show - our "marketing" bigwigs in the world are just sheep. So few of them can actually create anything new.
 
idrive is also a brand of backup.

iarse - the new apple singing bog roll that streams itunes wirelessly and uses hypersonics to blast klingons.
 
This is from the telegraph, refering the the suing of Apple,

In the first suit, it alleges that Apple infringed two patents covering image previews and the processing of images of different resolutions. In the second, Kodak accuses Apple of infringing patents that describe the method by which a computer program can "ask for help" from another application to carry out certain computer-based imaging tasks.

Can anybody shed more light on this?

Does anyone know exactly what it is these photo websites have done?

It all seems a bit too vague to me.
 
Kodak in patent infringement row with web photo publisher Shutterfly

Kodak filed its suit against Shutterfly earlier this month in the US for allegedly infringing on its patents related to the display of digital images. It claims that it owns the patent to the selection of photographic images using index prints and sought an injunction against Shutterfly. The latter then filed a counter-suit against Kodak, accusing it of infringing one of its own patents.
 

Ah right, well thats a bit more clear. So it is just a bit of patent trolling then.
I do feel sorry for Kodak though, they are a massive part of photography's history. And Mr Eastman was a bit of a humanitarian/philanthropist too, from what i've read.

Dont see how they can patent the concept of showing multiple images on one page as a way of selling them to a customer though. I mean what if i did it, are they gonna sue me too?
 
Ah right, well thats a bit more clear. So it is just a bit of patent trolling then.
I do feel sorry for Kodak though, they are a massive part of photography's history. And Mr Eastman was a bit of a humanitarian/philanthropist too, from what i've read.

Dont see how they can patent the concept of showing multiple images on one page as a way of selling them to a customer though. I mean what if i did it, are they gonna sue me too?

I doubt they would sue you but they might sue your ISP for facilitating. The ISP would/may have to pay a small royalty for all the sites they hosted.
 
Back
Top