Landscape photography.... Most used Filters

Messages
706
Name
Graeme
Edit My Images
Yes
I fancy having a go @ landscape rivers/ streams photography, having had I few attempts at it already I've concluded that I'm in need of some filters, but I've got a few questions first is there a filter out there that is most commonly used for landscapes. I don't have a wide angle lens but I think my efs 17-55mm f2.8 will be ok so I need to help with regards a what filters system to go for. I've been steering towards a graduated filter but have know idea as which to go for. I was thinking the cokin p series type but again I don't know weather you fit theses on top of the uv filter and what nd value is suitable.....

To help aid my question? I went out walking on the edge of the peak district at Thorpe and tried to capture some landscape shots of the surrounding hills and scenery, but what I found was if exposed for the sky which was clear the land would be dark and dull, but if exposed for the land the sky was blown. Unless I take two pics one for the land and another for the sky at the correct exposures and sort in pp with layer masks etc

There must be a better way

Thoughts Please
 
You need some ND grads to sort out bright skies. My most used are 2 and 3 stop hard grads. I think on a crop body at 17mm you might get away with P series filters (85mm) but if you're going to get serious it is worth buying 100mm filters in case you get a wider lens in future (10-22 etc).

In 100mm filters Lee are the best, then Hitech or Cokin Z Pro.
 
markmullen said:
You need some ND grads to sort out bright skies. My most used are 2 and 3 stop hard grads. I think on a crop body at 17mm you might get away with P series filters (85mm) but if you're going to get serious it is worth buying 100mm filters in case you get a wider lens in future (10-22 etc).

In 100mm filters Lee are the best, then Hitech or Cokin Z Pro.

Thanks, I'm glad you posted as I thought soft grads would of been more popular? I don't live by the coast so didn't think I needed hard grads?
 
simonkit said:
A polariser without doubt, adds extra contrast/saturation to landscapes - great with autumn colours - must admit I rarely use my NDgrads though:shrug:

Simon

I've recently got a polariser of fleebay its only a cheap one tho and I don't fancy screwing it direct on to my lens, but I've screwed it on my uv filter, Is there a reason why you are still able to rotate it?
 
I find with soft grads that if the whole sky is bright then then you've got a choice of having the top of the image very dark, or the bottom of the image still blowing out due to the soft graduation. With a hard grad that doesn't happen, and it is not a big job just to pull back any trees or whatever that have strayed into the dark section.

I will sometimes use a hard and a soft grad together.
 
I've recently got a polariser of fleebay its only a cheap one tho and I don't fancy screwing it direct on to my lens, but I've screwed it on my uv filter, Is there a reason why you are still able to rotate it?

Pop it direct onto your lens, you've got a lot more chance of the edges of the filters appearing in shot if you stack them, not to mention the deterioration in quality.

You rotate it to set it, just look through the viewfinder and rotate it, you'll see blue skies look more saturated, water get clearer, foliage get more colourful etc.

Be aware though that CPLs work best at 90 degrees to the sun, with the sun directly in front or behind you the effect will be much reduced.
 
Polarizers are epic, but they can cause weird effects on wide angle lenses, so not always suitable. Though have to say my prefered filter has to the the Lee ND Grad 0.9
 
jpwild said:
Polarizers are epic, but they can cause weird effects on wide angle lenses, so not always suitable. Though have to say my prefered filter has to the the Lee ND Grad 0.9

I read someway that you can do a tv test on the filter, whatever that is supposed to be, can you elaborate and give example when you'd use a polarizer, the reason I got it was to take photos of cars and reduce the glare from the windows as I was advised on this forum
 
I read someway that you can do a tv test on the filter, whatever that is supposed to be, can you elaborate and give example when you'd use a polarizer, the reason I got it was to take photos of cars and reduce the glare from the windows as I was advised on this forum

Think what they mean is turn on your TV (or computer screen) hold the polariser up to it, then turn and watch the effect. Should go from clear to black depending on the angle.
 
Look at it this way, you are walking along on a nice sunny day and have you're sunglasses with you.
Look at a nice scene that you think would make a nice shot,put the sunglasses on ,take them of ,notice how much more nicer it looks with the glasses.
Thats because (as said) by putting the glasses (polariser) on the lens ,you are adding more saturation (colour ) to the scene.

I have been walking around with a small compact and actually held my sunglasses in front of the lens to act as a polariser. Bit tricky though.:lol:
 
Circular polariser for certain. Essential for landscapes. The only other one i use is a 9 stop ND to get slow shutter speeds if needed. Often i use the 2 filters together.

Not bothered with ND Grads at all for ages now - just shooting raw and using the ND grad in PS or LR or layers in photoshop can do the effect with far more fine control.
 
A circular polariser is a good filter for landscapes. However, it would not fix the problem the OP mentioned (sky being over exposed/ground being under exposed) for that an ND grad would sort that out. I prefer a 2 stop hard grad.
 
Not bothered with ND Grads at all for ages now - just shooting raw and using the ND grad in PS or LR or layers in photoshop can do the effect with far more fine control.

Whilst the grads in ACR, PS or LR are good they don't help situations where the difference between the foreground and sky is very high (eg Scotland where you can have a bright cloudy sky and a very dark heather or rock foreground), you'll end up blowing the sky or blocking the foreground if you rely just on one raw, the camera just can't capture such a high dynamic range. The alternative is to bracket shots and combine them with layer masks but that is no good if the subject is moving.
 
gnirtS said:
Circular polariser for certain. Essential for landscapes. The only other one i use is a 9 stop ND to get slow shutter speeds if needed. Often i use the 2 filters together.

Not bothered with ND Grads at all for ages now - just shooting raw and using the ND grad in PS or LR or layers in photoshop can do the effect with far more fine control.

Software grads are good but not as good as the real thing.

You'll always lose a lot of finite detail with software grads as they effectively fiddle with the raw exposure levels and unless your body has *extremely* good dynamic range (beyond what is currently available) the real grad, properly used, will always be better.
 
This is such a hard question to answer :lol: I do quite a bit of landscape stuff and find ND soft grads to be very useful though if I were close to the coast I would have to get some hard grads :thumbs: I also have a high quality CPL which can really be useful, finally for when I really want a very show shutter I have my B&W ND110 :thumbs:

I also would much rather use real filters than digital ones :thumbs: they are just better :thumbs:

Matt
MWHCVT
 
I would say its pretty essential to have a selection of ND grads and a good polariser.

Digitally doing it in photoshop is a poor way of doing it, limiting and can cause issues that ultimately end up taking up a lot of time to sort out.


Paul.
www.photographybyriddell.co.uk
 
Digitally doing it in photoshop is a poor way of doing it, limiting and can cause issues that ultimately end up taking up a lot of time to sort out.

Roughly 5 seconds to drag an ND grad and set the exposure you want (provided you haven't over done it by 2-3 stops in the first place). Compare that to needing lots of ND grads, fiddling to get right one, still not having absolute precise control over the exposure and still tweaking the image in PS anyway.

Provided its not burnt out the ND grad in software is far faster, easier and flexible than using fixed filters on the camera! Its far less limiting.
Plus of course you have the option of stacking exposures to get a proper sky and proper foreground as opposed to the blunt real filter effect which will often darken the tops of mountains or anything above that horizon line.
 
gnirtS said:
Roughly 5 seconds to drag an ND grad and set the exposure you want (provided you haven't over done it by 2-3 stops in the first place). Compare that to needing lots of ND grads, fiddling to get right one, still not having absolute precise control over the exposure and still tweaking the image in PS anyway.

Provided its not burnt out the ND grad in software is far faster, easier and flexible than using fixed filters on the camera! Its far less limiting.
Plus of course you have the option of stacking exposures to get a proper sky and proper foreground as opposed to the blunt real filter effect which will often darken the tops of mountains or anything above that horizon line.

The result from a properly used real ND is better.

Plus I'd rather do as much as possible in camera, as a photographer and not a graphic artist!
 
gnirtS said:
Roughly 5 seconds to drag an ND grad and set the exposure you want (provided you haven't over done it by 2-3 stops in the first place). Compare that to needing lots of ND grads, fiddling to get right one, still not having absolute precise control over the exposure and still tweaking the image in PS anyway.

Provided its not burnt out the ND grad in software is far faster, easier and flexible than using fixed filters on the camera! Its far less limiting.
Plus of course you have the option of stacking exposures to get a proper sky and proper foreground as opposed to the blunt real filter effect which will often darken the tops of mountains or anything above that horizon line.

I tried this several times and as has been already said, and is obvious, you lose detail etc. The result is far inferior imo.
 
Interesting argument on using Grads v software. I still havent fully decided. But Im still learrning the ropes really. What I would say is that if your a beginner and funds are a bit tight so you cant afford the best Lee filters, £50 on photoshop elements maybe money better spent.
These days with shooting in RAW you're going to have do some computer work anyway so adding on a bit to do virtual ND grads isnt a lot more effort.

I still fancy trying ND grad filters though but every shot I seem to do that would need one always has something irregular sticking up into the sky area, whether its a pier or coastal cliffs at one side or other or durdle door etc. With a Grad I cant help but think they would look artificially dark and ruin the shot?
I'll have to try it and find out I guess.

The result from a properly used real ND is better.
Hmmm, I suspect thats not universally true. Flick through this years AA LPOTY book and I doubt you'd (as in anyone) know which ones were using software Grads and which ones used real ones.
 
If you want to do it on the computer (and save the cost of expensive Lee grads) then you can take two shots, one exposed for sky, one exposed for land, and then merge in Photoshop - layer on top of each other and brush out the top image to reveal the lower one.

Also handy for when you've used a hard grad and want to remove the 'silhouetted' land that sometimes creeps into the sky part of the image (cliffs for instance on a seascape).

I personally wouldn't use software grads as you'll have to compromise something on the exposure anyway so either have noisy foreground due to it being too dark in the original shot, or burnt out portions of sky if you have exposed the foreground properly.
 
Last edited:
If you're looking at P series (85mm filters) then Hitech rather than Cokin, if you want 100mm filters (to suit wider lenses or those with larger front elements) then Hitech or Cokin Z Pro. Lee are the best but they are pricey, if I add up my Lee filters (hard and soft grads, pro holder, adaptor rings, Big Stopper, 2x CPL (105mm and 100mm square) etc) you're looking near enough £1000 which is a powerful amount of money for some painted plastic!
 
Back
Top