Large speck of dirt inside Tamron 17-50

Messages
1,120
Name
Eddy
Edit My Images
Yes
Don't know HOW it got there, but I'm just wondering whether or not I need to worry? It doesn't seem to show up when I take a picture with 450D, but I'm worried it may cause further damage if it's left in there?! :|

I'll be taking a few pictures with the lens on a film SLR in the next few days, so it will be interesting to see whether it shows up during developing...

What do you guys think?

Cheers,

Eddy :)
 
Relax. Unless it is truly massive it isn't going to cause you any issues at all.

Have a look at this linky to see what level of damage optics can endure while not impacting on the image.

Hopefully you'll stop worrying about a single spec now...

It's not uncommon for extending zoom lens designs to suck in dust.
 
Last edited:
Ive got a chip on the element for one of my lenses, dont make any difference to my images
 
I remember when I bought my Henimex and Soligor lenses back in the 70s, if you got a lens without an "air bubble" you were lucky, dust etc.
 
Whack it into aperture priority, dial down the aperture to minium (highest f number) and take a picture of the sky (in daylight obviously).

If you can see it like that, it might be a problem, if you can't then don't worry.

Suspect you will see more sensor grot than anything else :D
 
I had a Tamron 17-50 2.8 VC for a short while, within one photoshoot, in a dry dustfree studio, it had plenty in there. It happens, it won't matter :)
 
Thanks for all the replies guys. I did as suggested and tune aperture to f.22 and it indeed seems to appear on my shots :(

Here's a picture of the chip. It seems to be on the rear element and has obviously made contact with front element during focusing, causing a double-scratch mayhem! :(


Lens chip by SuperEddzz, on Flickr

Here's a shot taken of a blue still. You can clearly make out the dark spot where the chip has effected the image.


Lens issue by SuperEddzz, on Flickr

Is this fixable if I were to have the lens serviced? REALLY annoyed as this is my prize lens! So much so, that I was on the cusp of upgrading my camera body instead of lens... :bang:
 
Last edited:
Well, f22 at a bright subject is as bad as it will get... whether you see it at larger apertures and on other less bright subjects is questionable...

Eg, try a f4, f8 and f10 shot of something like a normal scene (inside a room, of your garden, of the front of your house etc) and see if its really noticeable....

Then decide if you actually can accept the real world results.
 
I know it sounds odd but have you tried knocking the lens with you hand to move it firm knocks won't do any damage. NOT on a brick etc :nono:
 
I have tried knocking it yes and doesn't budge :/ oh man, this is depressing lol!
 
A few years I imagine. Bought it second hand a couple months ago and it was fine then. Don't know how the defect has occurred but it's definitely appeared during my possession of the lens.
 
It's visible through view-finder at sort of f.9 onwards :(
 
I was holding in the DOF preview button and turning the dial to adjust aperture, watching as the speck came into view.
 
You say that it looks like a chip on the rear element which has collided with the front element? If so then there is indeed an increased likelihood of it appearing on your shot the closer to the sensor focal plane it is.

Normally there should be no possibility of the two elements colliding although if they were very close at there nearest points then it is conceivable that a large piece of debris could have got sandwiched between the two elements.

Is it visible on your shots at f/9? If not, at what aperture does it become visible?

Considering what the lens is worth I think I would personally take decision to take action based on whether it was visible on shots taken at practical apertures you are likely to use. It's visibility in the viewfinder is of little relevance, especially as it will only happen with DOF preview pressed.

If you do decide it is a practical problem to you though you may end up spending as much to get it cleaned/repaired as you would picking another used copy up.
 
I'm doing a shoot today at a Christmas market. I'll try a range of apertures with the lens and check back with you guys later! :)
 
Seems to make varying appearances depending on light conditions.
 
Sounds like a bin job to me mate then... they aren't particularly expensive lenses, which makes repair largely pointless.

I'd pick up a second hand one, assuming it wasn't covered by an insurance policy for accidental damage.
 
Sounds like a bin job to me mate then... they aren't particularly expensive lenses, which makes repair largely pointless.

I'd pick up a second hand one, assuming it wasn't covered by an insurance policy for accidental damage.

Lol thanks, that's really motivating! :suspect:
 
I don't think motivation and positive outlook is going to fix this one...
 
Lol thanks, that's really motivating! :suspect:

I think what desantnik was trying to get at is that these lenses only cost £200 or so second hand. If you consider that to repair the lens would cost circa £50 an hour, it would only take 2 hours work to make it cheaper for you to sell your existing lens as for repair and pick up a second hand lens.
 
It looks as though the front element is removable? There are three screws that allow it to be removed... I'm not really sure in what way lenses are assembled however... Would I be able to access the front of the rear element if I were to remove the front one? Because the mark is between the two of them
 
It looks as though the front element is removable? There are three screws that allow it to be removed... I'm not really sure in what way lenses are assembled however... Would I be able to access the front of the rear element if I were to remove the front one? Because the mark is between the two of them

Not an easy job,if you mess it up,if it was me i would use the lens for the moment,then just pp if it show up on photos,then when you get some money together replace it,the sell the other one as spares :)
 
Eddzz!! said:
It looks as though the front element is removable? There are three screws that allow it to be removed... I'm not really sure in what way lenses are assembled however... Would I be able to access the front of the rear element if I were to remove the front one? Because the mark is between the two of them

There are guides on how to do this on the canon 17-55 online which look fairly straight forward. Under the circumstances I would say you have little to lose.

As others have said, it may not be cost effective to have it professionally cleaned or repaired.
 
It looks as though the front element is removable? There are three screws that allow it to be removed... I'm not really sure in what way lenses are assembled however... Would I be able to access the front of the rear element if I were to remove the front one? Because the mark is between the two of them

Sure as long as you took all of the other elements out too and the diaphragm etc, oh and you would need a place that is dust free.

Have you tried high pressure air can spray, place the tube in the lens hold the can level and spray, you never know, especially as you are considering turning it into a paper weight :nono:
 
Last edited:
I took it apart and fixed it up nicely. Good as new! (Except I snapped one of the tiny pins on the screw cover, whoops!). Cheers for all the advice guys, despite some of it being 'throw it away' ... Lol!
 
Back
Top