Legalities of exhibiting / selling images shot on private property..

  • Thread starter Thread starter tbm
  • Start date Start date

tbm

Messages
459
Name
Mike
Edit My Images
Yes
I'm looking at possibly exhibiting a few photos (with a view to selling them), and am after some advice regarding image rights please.

Several shots I wish to include have been shot on publicly accessible, but privately owned land (some owned by national trust and some by a university).

Am I correct in thinking that to sell these images legally I need a release from the owners of the land, and if so, how would I go about acquiring one and what do I need to ask when I contact them?

Are they likely to ask for a flat fee, a percentage of the sale price or some other concession with respect to the image?

Thanks - any pointers much appreciated :)
 
The owner of private property can stop you taking photos, within reason, but once you've taken them you're pretty much in the clear.

The National Trust makes a fuss about it, but that's just hot air in a, largely vain, attempt to protect the income from their own images. There was a big thread about this a year or so ago, I'm sur it'll come up in a search.
 
However it is very unlikely you will get into trouble. You are in the clear if you haven't paid an entry fee for the said NT property. Also if you have taken the shot from a public area of a private property that's ok too.
The NT are notoriously precious about their properties but if you have a look at any picture library you will see numerous shots of them.
As the Duke of Wellington said "Publish and be damned"!
Phil.
 
There is also the issue of public rights of way across land, thats public access so again legal to shoot from.
 
Thanks for the replies :)

The owner of private property can stop you taking photos, within reason, but once you've taken them you're pretty much in the clear.

The National Trust makes a fuss about it, but that's just hot air in a, largely vain, attempt to protect the income from their own images. There was a big thread about this a year or so ago, I'm sur it'll come up in a search.
Cheers - I found the thread but it doesn't seem to contain any solid guidance. I'm assuming there's a slim possiblity they could sue me were I making money out of an image taken on their land..

For the National Trust, read this : http://www.nationaltrust.org.uk/main/w-global/w-contact_us/w-faqs/w-faqs-visitor.htm

It's a condition of entry that photos taken are for private use only.
Thanks for the link - makes it reasonably clear, however there's nothing about how to apply for property release etc..

However it is very unlikely you will get into trouble. You are in the clear if you haven't paid an entry fee for the said NT property. Also if you have taken the shot from a public area of a private property that's ok too.
The NT are notoriously precious about their properties but if you have a look at any picture library you will see numerous shots of them.
As the Duke of Wellington said "Publish and be damned"!
Phil.
There is also the issue of public rights of way across land, thats public access so again legal to shoot from.
Thanks guys; the shots were taken on NT or university owned land, although I'm not sure whether I was on a public right of way or not. Does it make a difference to the rights issue if I haven't paid / been issued a ticket to enter the property? Does anyone have any links to concrete evidence of this?

I'm half tempted to approach the NT and enquire about rights / offer them the image for their stock, but half tempted not to broadcast my intentions and keep quiet. Anyway, I'm off to hunt for public rights of way in places..

Thanks again for the thoughts; any more much appreciated ;)
 
Thanks for the link - makes it reasonably clear, however there's nothing about how to apply for property release etc..

They do provide an email address:
Any individuals wishing to sell or publish photographs should contact photo.library@nationaltrust.org.uk.


I'm half tempted to approach the NT and enquire about rights / offer them the image for their stock, but half tempted not to broadcast my intentions and keep quiet. Anyway, I'm off to hunt for public rights of way in places..

Well, given the typical responses on this forum to photographs being used by organisations and newspapers without permission of the photographer, it would be hypcritical to suggest you publish without seeking permission of the landowner. So ask permission. The NT will probably want a commercial use fee, which you should pay (IMO of course).
 
Thanks :)

A very good point, and tbh the issue that uneased me most was the potential for hypocrasy given the outrage that frequently ensues on here when someone finds their image has been used without their consent.

Happy to play by the rules providing they play ball and don't try and screw me for 95% royalties or an extortionate useage fee.

Have sent emails to both parties; will wait and see if they're reasonable or try to stiff me.

Will post again when I know what's going on ;)
 
At the end of the day the release may be needed for displaying the photograph published work, but not prior to the sale. By getting one you will be making life easier to the publisher and may gain an extra sale, but may also face fees upfront.
 
At the end of the day the release may be needed for displaying the photograph published work, but not prior to the sale. By getting one you will be making life easier to the publisher and may gain an extra sale, but may also face fees upfront.
Cheers, I assume (rightly or wrongly) that I wouldn't need a release simply to display the images since I wouldn't be making any money from them and they're effectively editorial.

I see the problem arising with any sales as a result of the exhibition, so I don't want to be caught napping if I haven't secured a release when someone wants to buy an image.


I just got a very quick reply from the National Trust, which impressed me:

Chris Rowlin said:
Dear Mike,

We have chosen to only enforce our photography policy on pay-on-entry land, and since White Horse Hill is free access to the public you are therefore entitled to exhibit and sell your images in any way you choose without our permission. The only exception to this would be if you wanted to sell your images for advertising, for which a property release would be required.
So it appears that you only need to worry about a release for material shot on National Trust land if you had to pay to get in or wish to use the image for advertising. Yay for a clear and concise answer for once :thumbs:
 
Cheers, I assume (rightly or wrongly) that I wouldn't need a release simply to display the images since I wouldn't be making any money from them and they're effectively editorial.

I see the problem arising with any sales as a result of the exhibition, so I don't want to be caught napping if I haven't secured a release when someone wants to buy an image.


I just got a very quick reply from the National Trust, which impressed me:


So it appears that you only need to worry about a release for material shot on National Trust land if you had to pay to get in or wish to use the image for advertising. Yay for a clear and concise answer for once :thumbs:

The only thing the National Trust are interested in, is money. The angle they're getting at is that if you have paid for a ticket, then there will be some small print on the back that says you agree to abide by their terms and conditions of entry, and that will exclude commercial photography.

However, in practise, clauses like this have no formal or automatic legal status. For example, if you go to a motor race and it says 'Motor sport is dangerous, at you own risk etc' this does not absolve the organisers of responsibility for safety and if you get hurt through their negligence, then you can sue.

Basically, unless you have signed something specific, the NT can't do anything once the images are taken. Other than to puff and puff. And the law also makes no distinction between commercial/advertsing and editorial/free. It's just that with commercial work there is obviously some cash involved, and they want a slice of it.

With the NT, there is also the moral question of whether or not their properties, which essentially belong to the nation, are in fact private in the true sense anyway.
 
The other side of this equation is of course that maintaining NT properties and contents together with their landholdings, costs money> If their income from all their souces were removed then we wouldn't have the opportunity for some great location photographs. It's a question of balance, do you support them by being a member for instance.
 
Back
Top