lens's and all my cameras aahhaa

Tamar Photography

Suspended / Banned
Messages
258
Edit My Images
No
Hi All, im now finding it difficult, I have a Canon EOS 1000D and a Canon EOS 10D, I understand that if the camera has a Red Dot or White Square then the matching lens will be compatable with each other, here's how far Ive got.

EOS 1000D, Canon 18-55mm (White Square) Canon 75-300mm (Red Dot) etc

Eos 10D: Canon 75-300mm (Red Dot) should be ok

Now just to confuse things, when i bought my 10d it came with a crappy Sigma 18-50mm lens the 1:3.5-5.6DC lens but whats confusing me is this has a White circle so is this compatable with the 10d? and also 1000d???

Thanks
 
As long as it is a canon fit it should be ok the sigma DC lenses are optomised for crop sensor bodies .
 
Both of you bodies have a crop sensor canon start full frame with the EOS 5D up . the Dc lenses have a smaller focus point ( some one correct if I'm wrong .) so would have a dark edge around the image on a full frame sensor . So the DC lens is ideal for both bodies . I've not got my sigmas to hand but I'm sure that they have a red dot for aligning them to the body though . Just see it it will line up but don't try to force it if wont go .
 
Hold on a sec!!! The Canon 10D will NOT accept EF-S lenses. So, if its EF-S, its a no for the 10D (it would be ok on the 20D and above)
 
Oooppps my bad didn't know that 10d didn't take both types sorry for mis informtion . I was sure that all D crop bodies accepted both types .
 
Thanks for all your replies, not really sure what Deasy is on about.. Ive been using it for 8 weeks on the 10d, but thought id check..
 
Does the 10D have a red dot and a white square. I had one but can't remember.

It's a crop sensor camera so EF-S lenses work okay.

Never use an EF-S lens on a NON crop sensor, it is more complicated than just plug it in and try.

If you where to plug a 10-22 Efs lens in a 5d or 5d2 and fire the shutter at least you'd jam the camera at worst shatter the mirror.

EF-S lenses are designed for 1.6 crop factor cameras with smaller mirrors. Thats the 10d, 20D, 30D, 40D, 50D and now to confuse everyone the 7D.

Not forgeting the 300D, 350D, 400D, 450D, 500D as well in the crop factor group :D
 
Does the 10D have a red dot and a white square. I had one but can't remember.

It's a crop sensor camera so EF-S lenses work okay.

Never use an EF-S lens on a NON crop sensor, it is more complicated than just plug it in and try.

If you where to plug a 10-22 Efs lens in a 5d or 5d2 and fire the shutter at least you'd jam the camera at worst shatter the mirror.

EF-S lenses are designed for 1.6 crop factor cameras with smaller mirrors. Thats the 10d, 20D, 30D, 40D, 50D and now to confuse everyone the 7D.

Not forgeting the 300D, 350D, 400D, 450D, 500D as well in the crop factor group :D

Hi There the 10d Has a red square?? thx
 
ok from what have i have found on the web the 10d has an EF mount and not an EF-S so if I were you I'd drop sigma an email to see if they can tell you if it safe to use it . I think that it would be ok ( as you have already been using it . ) Just better safe than sorry though really . I think that all sigmas have an EF fitting and not EF-S .
 
I think the main problem is that an EF-S lens protudes into the camera further and the mirror on full frame cameras hit the back of the lens. The 10D isn't full frame, but an EF-S lens produces vignetting especially when wide open at a wide angle on a 10D. The only problem I see that may be a problem is the 18-55mm
 
All Digital Canons are EF mount ( Electronic focus ) the 10D is an EF mount so is the 1D series, all the xxD series and the XXXD series.

EF-s is just for lenses designed specifically for crop sensor cameras, it's to denote you don't stick it on a full frame sensor.

The 10D is an APS-C sensor and should not suffer vignetting on an EF-s lens.

The EF-S lens mount is a derivative of the EF lens mount created for a subset of Canon digital single-lens reflex cameras with APS-C sized image sensors. It was released in 2003. Cameras supporting the EF-S mount are backward-compatible with the EF lens mount. Only Canon cameras with the APS-C sized sensor released after 2003 support the mount. All other cameras do not support it.

The "S" in EF-S stands for "short back focus", which means that the rear element of the lens is closer to the image sensor than on regular 35 mm SLR cameras. The proximity of the rear element to the image sensor greatly enhances the possibilities for wide angle and very wide angle lenses, enabling them to be made smaller, lighter (containing less glass), faster (larger aperture) and less expensive. Most current Canon EF-S lenses are wide angle.

Lenses designed specifically for APS-C sized sensors are often optically designed to provide a narrower light cone to match the sensor. However, not all such lenses require the shorter back focus, and may feature the standard EF mount. Such lenses will give noticeable vignetting if used on a 35mm film or sensor camera.
 
Hold on a sec!!! The Canon 10D will NOT accept EF-S lenses. So, if its EF-S, its a no for the 10D (it would be ok on the 20D and above)

Sigma DC lenses aren't actually EF-S fit - they will fit on a full frame camera and clear the mirror. They just have a smaller image circle - so if it communicated with the 10D correctly it would be fine. Canon 10D won't support EF-S lenses but they say nothing about third party lenses, and to all intents and purposes Sigma DC lenses are full frame 35mm lenses except for the image circle. Canon EF-S lenses actually have a different fit, and would foul the mirror of a 35mm SLR.


I think the main problem is that an EF-S lens protudes into the camera further and the mirror on full frame cameras hit the back of the lens. The 10D isn't full frame, but an EF-S lens produces vignetting especially when wide open at a wide angle on a 10D. The only problem I see that may be a problem is the 18-55mm

The 10D is an APS-C sensor the same size as all other Canon APS-C cameras so an EF-S lens wouldn't vignette anymore on it than on a 7D - it just wouldn't work with the camera.
 
Thanks people,, i mean the lens goes in the same way as thr 75-300mm as far as it enters the camera, I will indeed send sigma an email.. thanks ..
 
All Digital Canons are EF mount

That maybe but to fit an EF-S lens the lens fits on to the body at a slighty differant point to an EF lens . On my 40d there is a white square and red dot at differant points on the body so there must be a slight differance with the canon lens mounts , but I'm sure that all sigmas just line up the same as a canon EF lens so you could by accident fit a DC lens to a full frame body and cause some damage where as with a canon EF-S lens it should not fit to a full frame body . I think that this is a safe gaurd that canon built in . Not 100% sure though as I've never tried it .
 
Not sure if a ef-s lens will even fit a 10d.

Whether or not it will fit is irrelevant, it will not communicate with the body


That maybe but to fit an EF-S lens the lens fits on to the body at a slighty differant point to an EF lens . On my 40d there is a white square and red dot at differant points on the body so there must be a slight differance with the canon lens mounts , but I'm sure that all sigmas just line up the same as a canon EF lens so you could by accident fit a DC lens to a full frame body and cause some damage where as with a canon EF-S lens it should not fit to a full frame body . I think that this is a safe gaurd that canon built in . Not 100% sure though as I've never tried it .

Mother of god - we've already been over the fact that Sigma DC lenses are EF fit. They will fit on any EF body including full frame and will clear the mirror. It's just the image circle that is smaller, specifically to fit APS-C.

Repeat after me: A Sigma DC lens will fit on a full frame body and will clear the mirror.
An EF-S lens will not work on a 10D


Thanks people,, i mean the lens goes in the same way as thr 75-300mm as far as it enters the camera, I will indeed send sigma an email.. thanks ..

If it works on the camera then that is all you need to know. No need to send Sigma an email as there is no issue here! :shrug:
 
Mother of god - we've already been over the fact that Sigma DC lenses are EF fit. They will fit on any EF body including full frame and will clear the mirror. It's just the image circle that is smaller, specifically to fit APS-C.

Repeat after me: A Sigma DC lens will fit on a full frame body and will clear the mirror.
An EF-S lens will not work on a 10D

Sorry my typing is just a little slower than yours
 
This is really annoying me now what is Deasy's problem,, this is a photography forum correct if im wrong this is not an English Forum..
 
what is Deasy's problem,,

He's got a Sony thats his problem.

LOL Lighten up everyone this is supposed to be fun not 6th form College.

Oh and I'm buggered if I can spell either and can't be bothered with spell checkers.

This thread otherwise has been very informative :D
 
Arkady

I looked up the Chang Cheng DF-3 but couldn't figure if it took EF or EF-S lenses LOL.

Cracking old timer gear though :D
 
It takes hand-polished lenses made from old Coke bottles from the 1940's - awesome kit...
 
Arkady

I looked up the Chang Cheng DF-3 but couldn't figure if it took EF or EF-S lenses LOL.

Cracking old timer gear though :D

Psssst.....he has no idea how to use it though..............;)
 
It looks the part and that's all that matters. :p
Internet-Photographers don't need to actually use their kit to be important, you know...:nuts:
 
It looks the part and that's all that matters. :p
Internet-Photographers don't need to actually use their kit to be important, you know...:nuts:

Bit like some arze who bought a Rollieflex then?.........................:lol:
 
...and a cravat...?

Smoking jacket, if you don`t mind..................:thumbs:

You reckon that everybody else is thinking " What the **** are these two clowns on about"........?
 
I think that this is a safe gaurd that canon built in

Yes, but the design is to prevent you fitting an EF-S lens to an EF mount camera and causing damage, not the other way round, which is perfectly fine.

So glad I don't use a Canon...:shrug:

It's really very simple. I don't understand the confusion.

An EF-S-mount body will work all EF-S and EF-mount lenses.

An EF-mount body will take only EF-mount lenses. It is not possible to mount an EF-S lens on an EF body.

Sigma's DC range will mount safely on an EF body, but vignette enormously the same as the F-mount version would on on a Nikon FX body.

P.S. If you an provide me with an equally brief explanation of which F-mount lenses will work with which Nikon bodies, I'll be impressed :)
 
P.S. If you an provide me with an equally brief explanation of which F-mount lenses will work with which Nikon bodies, I'll be impressed :)

lol...In the nicest possible way:
I just don't care...:lol:


All of my lenses work on all of my cameras - that's all I need to know...
 
lol...In the nicest possible way:
I just don't care...:lol:


All of my lenses work on all of my cameras - that's all I need to know...

It's simple really - just don't nance about with cropped sensors...

(must get rid of that 450d sometime :()
 
This is really annoying me now what is Deasy's problem,, this is a photography forum correct if im wrong this is not an English Forum..

Yes, maybe you'd be happier to continue using non-words like lens then?

What kind of khaemerah do you have?
 
Back
Top