Letter to Sir Paul Stephenson, Metropolitan Police Commissioner

Messages
984
Name
John
Edit My Images
Yes
I have today written to Sir Paul Stephenson, Metropolitan Police Commissioner, to express my views on the inapropriate use of Stop and Search by his force. For those interested, here is a copy of my letter:-

Dear Sir Paul,

I am writing to you to express my concern over the apparent policy of the Metropolitan Police Force to systematically target photographers through the Stop and Search provisions of Section 44 of the Counter Terrorism Act.

The recent revelation that the whole of the Metropolitan Police district has been subject to a rolling program of authorisation for Stop and Search under Section 44 without reasonable grounds for suspicion since 2001 I find particularly alarming. I seriously consider that the threat to our liberty and freedom that this poses is a greater threat than that of terrorist attack itself.

Having said that, it might be easier to justify if there was any evidence that terrorists were making regular use of high-end digital cameras, in particular DSLRs, for surveillance. As you know there is no evidence to support this, therefore the policy is not only wrong but also ineffective and a waste of police time and resources. I offer the opinion that it would actually make more sense to stop and search mobile phone users at random as not only do these devices record photographs and video but they can also serve as a means of communication between terrorists and even act as remote detonators for bombs. Also, they are less conspicuous and more covert than a professional or enthusiast level DSLR camera. Not that I am advocating the systematic harassment of mobile phone users; that, too, would be wrong.

May I remind you that the principle aim of terrorist organisations is not to kill and maim as many people as possible; that is just a means to an end. Their real objective is to cause fear, panic, mistrust and division within our society, which they hope will eventually lead to its downfall. They have won the first round, by creating a division between the police and law-abiding photographers. Many photography Internet forums are currently rife with indignation, anger and contempt for the police, mostly from middle-aged, middle-class, law-abiding people who have traditionally supported, respected and appreciated the police.

We must not let the terrorists win by allowing them to intimidate us, divide us and turn us against each other. We must stand firm and protect our hard won freedoms and liberties that have been progressively woven into the fabric of our society since Magna Carta.
Following the judgement on the 12th January by the European Court of Human Rights that the use of stop and search powers without reasonable grounds for suspicion contravenes article 8 of the Human Rights Convention, I seek your urgent assurance that there will be an immediate and fundamental change in your force's policy, restricting both Stop and Search and Stop and Account to occasions when there are clear and reasonable grounds for suspicion.

Then, and only then, can we seek to rebuild the respect and trust that we have traditionally enjoyed between the public and our country's principle police force. Should you wish to discuss this issue in greater depth I will be willing to meet you or your representatives from the Metropolitan Police force.

Thank you for taking the time to read this letter.


Yours sincerely,



John Perriment.


copies circulated to Home Office and interested photography groups




If we all do our bit........:)
 
well done - look forward to hearing from you re the reply.
 
Nicely written and makes a good point, I hadn't even thought to equate camera usage with mobile phone usage, so obvious once pointed out.
 
Yes, good letter.
I cannot see how any terrorist would want to risk being seen doing a recce with a prominent camera when he can sit at home with Google Earth.
 
He won't read that letter. A minion will read it and you will get a standard reply. Trust me I know. :thumbs:
 
He won't read that letter. A minion will read it and you will get a standard reply. Trust me I know. :thumbs:

possibly, but if you don't send it you won't get anywhere and its eassy to find excuses not to bother.

Nice letter BTW
 
Are you insinuating that a high ranking officer might be unable to read? :)

A supprisingly large number of people have reading difficulty. We also had a blind home secetary. One would hope he can read, but rank is no guarantee. :)
 
He won't read that letter. A minion will read it and you will get a standard reply. Trust me I know. :thumbs:

Please don’t take any offence Mike, but that’s a typical British attitude, such as "I know it’s wrong but there’s nothing we can do about it (as we slump back in our armchairs)".
You may well be right in the end, and my experiences indicate you probably are, but that’s no excuse for lethargy, we must stand up and be counted in these matters. I don’t advocate the French style of rioting that we hear so much about or anything similar, but lets stand together and make our voice heard.
This letter is very well written and full marks to John for taking the time to write such a concise and polite, yet factual and meaningful letter. Well done :thumbs:
I hope that the members of this forum will stand behind John should the need and opportunity arise, somehow I think we all will.
 
Please don’t take any offence Mike, but that’s a typical British attitude, such as "I know it’s wrong but there’s nothing we can do about it (as we slump back in our armchairs)".
You may well be right in the end, and my experiences indicate you probably are, but that’s no excuse for lethargy, we must stand up and be counted in these matters. I don’t advocate the French style of rioting that we hear so much about or anything similar, but lets stand together and make our voice heard.
This letter is very well written and full marks to John for taking the time to write such a concise and polite, yet factual and meaningful letter. Well done :thumbs:
I hope that the members of this forum will stand behind John should the need and opportunity arise, somehow I think we all will.

He really won't read it, and the minion won't read it to him either. A low ranking clerk will answer it from an automated answering system. So it is really very pointless sending it to the police who are directed by government. I know this because I have ventured on an exact course and written a similar letter to the police. In the end I wrote to my member of parliament, who are duty bound to answer personally. You will never get the police to change policy, you would however have some influence with a co-ordinated campaign at an understanding MOP. The idea is to get it mentioned in parliament, see HERE , I would suggest the letter is directed to someone like Mr John RANDALL (Con), who seems sympathetic?
 
He really won't read it, and the minion won't read it to him either. A low ranking clerk will answer it from an automated answering system. So it is really very pointless sending it to the police who are directed by government. I know this because I have ventured on an exact course and written a similar letter to the police. In the end I wrote to my member of parliament, who are duty bound to answer personally. You will never get the police to change policy, you would however have some influence with a co-ordinated campaign at an understanding MOP.

I agree.
 
He really won't read it, and the minion won't read it to him either. A low ranking clerk will answer it from an automated answering system. So it is really very pointless sending it to the police who are directed by government. I know this because I have ventured on an exact course and written a similar letter to the police. In the end I wrote to my member of parliament, who are duty bound to answer personally. You will never get the police to change policy, you would however have some influence with a co-ordinated campaign at an understanding MOP.

While I don’t retract anything I said, but taking on board your comments Mike, there might be a justifiable case to extend the scope of the letter. Perhaps John would give consideration to sending copies to his MP, MEP, and for what its worth, to Jack Straw, the Secretary of State for Justice. It would be interesting to hear what John’s thoughts are on this. It would be a pity for such a well composed letter not to be used to maximum effect.
 
While I don’t retract anything I said, but taking on board your comments Mike, there might be a justifiable case to extend the scope of the letter. Perhaps John would give consideration to sending copies to his MP, MEP, and for what its worth, to Jack Straw, the Secretary of State for Justice. It would be interesting to hear what John’s thoughts are on this. It would be a pity for such a well composed letter not to be used to maximum effect.

I think this is an excellent suggestion. It's also been suggested that I approach shadow ministers as it is probable that we will have a change of government within the next five months. A job for tomorrow maybe!

Thanks to everyone for your support. I agree with those who caution me not to expect too much but I feel I must try. Also, you could compare me to a flea on the back of a large dog. The dog will ignore the flea for a while but if the flea keeps biting eventually the dog will feel compelled to scratch it!
 
Great letter
 
Just to update those who are interested.

I have received the predictable response from David Searle at the Commissioner's Private Office that my letter has been forwarded to the Customer Service Unit - without, of course, Sir Paul himself reading it.

Oh well, time for another atttempt. Here is my reply:-


Dear Mr Searle,


I recently wrote personally to the Commissioner, Sir Paul Stephenson, expressing my concern at the way in which Section 44 of the Counter Terrorism Act is being applied, or miss-applied as I consider, in the Metropolitan district (copy of letter enclosed).

Whilst I appreciate your prompt reply I am nevertheless disappointed that my letter has been forwarded to your Customer Service Unit with the intended recipient, Sir Paul, apparently not having read it himself. You and I both know that only a standard policy response will be forthcoming from your Customer Service Unit and that is not good enough, for it is the policy itself which must change.

I would therefore ask you again, please, to ensure that Sir Paul reads my letter and affords me the courtesy of a personal reply. I would also urge him to accept my offer of a meeting during which this extremely important issue of personal rights and liberty can be discussed in detail. Can I ask you please to impress upon him the growing strength of anger of thousands of honest, law-abiding photographers. This situation is most unhealthy and plays straight into our enemies hands because, if it continues, I foresee the Metropolitan Police becoming so embroiled in disputes with photographers on the streets, resulting in a multiplication of complaints that require laborious investigation, that they become ineffective in countering the real threat of terrorism which has nothing to do with photography.

I await Sir Paul's reply with interest.


Yours sincerely,



John Perriment



I am not naive enough to think that I might get an appropriate response, or even a reply from the person who matters, but we must keep up the pressure in any way we can.
 
Back
Top