Critique Lighthouse, Bridges & Skies

[Deadlock]

Hi there,

I've been playing around with some B&W conversions and would be interested in feedback on the conversions & shots.

Thanks.


Clouds over lighthouse on Mull crossing- by *Kats Photography*, on Flickr


Forth Bridges Skies-3 by *Kats Photography*, on Flickr


Forth Bridges Skies-2 by *Kats Photography*, on Flickr


Forth Bridges Skies-1 by *Kats Photography*, on Flickr

 

[Tunbridge]

I'm not expert on conversions but No1 & 2 look too high contrast to me, it just doesn't look right. The composition in No.1 is good though. What did it look like in colour?
I really like No.3, think it's the pick of the bunch for me. The composition is good and the silhouette of the bridge works well in B&W.
No.4 is also pretty good, it's a classic shot but I've liked it in colour.