Long Exposure Noise Reduction WTF???... and a couple of other night shot questions!

Messages
1,764
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi

I was doing a few night shots last night whilst on my break at work of the two Forth Bridges I noticed a few things... Canon EOS 5d Mk1 btw...

Firstly i'd forgot to charge my battery and after a couple of shots my camera would not let me take long exposures... but still remained on and went through the motions of taking the shot... it just did not record it to the card... I only noticed when I took a shot and then when went to review it... it showed the shot I'd taken 3 shots back... you can imagine me head scratching... but then seen the battery dead light flashing... but yet for the banter I tryed taking the shot again and nothing... What was more odd about that was that when I got in the office I tryed snapping something on the green P and it recorded the image no prob... just seemed to be with long exposures.... any thoughts or ideas why?

Secondly I was going to put on automatic mirror lock up on in the custom functions when I noticed long exposure noise reduction... I put it on... but didn't have the power to do a comparison shot as it went out my mind when the first point started hapening... anyway what is this custom function... does it work or is it a bit of a waste of time if you are shooting at ISO100 and on a tripod anyway?

Any thoughts would be appreciated.

M
 
Even at ISO100 you are going to get noise with a long exposure. Noise reduction does it's best to reduce that for you. I've never seen an example that compares what it's like with it on and off.
 
Are you aware that the processing time for "long exposure noise reduction" is longer than the exposure time itself....ie, if you take a 30 second exposure then it'll take more than 30 seconds before the data is written to the card? It will also prevent another shot being taken until this period has ended.

Bob
 
To expand on what Bob said

When you use long exposure noise reduction what the camera does is open the shutter for the specified time, then it will close the shutter and take another frame of exactly the same duration. This will be used as a basis for the noise reduction processing - so the camera will be out of action for at least twice the duration of the TV setting.
 
I try to avoid very long exposures. To be honest you get very little noise at ISO400 (well, I do on my Nikon). And I do not like the star effect you get from direct lights because it looks too unnatural. I suggest you turn off your noise reduction and maybe consider shorter exposures to reduce noise. Do not be afraid to use the ISO, just keep it reasonably low at 400 or below.
 
I try to avoid very long exposures. To be honest you get very little noise at ISO400 (well, I do on my Nikon). And I do not like the star effect you get from direct lights because it looks too unnatural. I suggest you turn off your noise reduction and maybe consider shorter exposures to reduce noise. Do not be afraid to use the ISO, just keep it reasonably low at 400 or below.

I've always thought that increasing the ISO on night shots was a big noise issue... but then again the other big issue is camera shake... prob more so than noise so the less time the shutter is open the better... I always shoot about f8 at night with the focus set to infinity... I'll need to get out and do some real good test shots of all this stuff...

I noticed it took a lot longer with that custom function on... does the mirror lock up increase the time by more than a few secs...

Also last night a ten sec exposure would take aprox 30secs with these funtions on... but I only heard the actual shutter open and close once... so does it take the both exposures without the shutter moving... sorta does not make sense to me now :cuckoo: should really read the manual but i remeber reading about custom functions in it when I got it and felt the section was vague!
 
I find ISO400 barely noticeable with noise in my shots. Instead of a 10 second exposure, why not experiment with 5 seconds and ISO200 or something of the sort and then compare with your 10 second exposure.

To avoid camera shake I always use a tripod and the self timer to avoid vibrations when removing my finger from the shutter.
 
Also last night a ten sec exposure would take aprox 30secs with these funtions on... but I only heard the actual shutter open and close once...

The first "exposure" is normal. The second "exposure" is simply applying the equivalent gain to the photosites for the same time period to see which ones warm up/saturate without opening the shutter.

Bob
 
I find ISO400 barely noticeable with noise in my shots. Instead of a 10 second exposure, why not experiment with 5 seconds and ISO200 or something of the sort and then compare with your 10 second exposure.

To avoid camera shake I always use a tripod and the self timer to avoid vibrations when removing my finger from the shutter.

Oh yes... I always use a tripod and cable release... didn't think anyone wouldn't for night shots!
 
The first "exposure" is normal. The second "exposure" is simply applying the equivalent gain to the photosites for the same time period to see which ones warm up/saturate without opening the shutter.

Bob

I know you will think im stupid but does the shutter then open for the length of the full two exposures because that is what it seemed to do...

1 I pressed the release...
2.camera was set to two second delay... and mirror lock up activated...
3. after two secs the shutter opens... assume it is as I hear it!
4. exposure was set to ten secs but about 25 passed...
4. then I heard the shutter close...

So thats what happened outside... what happened inside with the shutter as there was no opening and closing noise made between the two exposures it takes?
 
I personally turn the NR reduction off and do it myself in post processing. The 5D doesn't let you control how much NR it will apply and sometimes it's too much that the photo loses details. The 5D mark II can let you choose the strength of NR though, I heard :suspect::suspect:
 
Sometimes you need the long exposure to get the effect you want, star trails etc.

I use the long exposure noise reduction (I though it measures a second exposure at that ISO/shutter speed [with the mirror down?]) and fid that it works well.
 
I know you will think im stupid but does the shutter then open for the length of the full two exposures because that is what it seemed to do...

1 I pressed the release...
2.camera was set to two second delay... and mirror lock up activated...
3. after two secs the shutter opens... assume it is as I hear it!
4. exposure was set to ten secs but about 25 passed...
4. then I heard the shutter close...

So thats what happened outside... what happened inside with the shutter as there was no opening and closing noise made between the two exposures it takes?

Chances are you missed the shutter closing but heard the mirror slapping back down into position. The noise the shutter makes when closing is very quiet.
 
I would have said that there may be a safety feature on the camera which prevents long exposures when the battery is low on power. You wouldn't want the camera to run out of power during a long exposure, and maybe lock with the mirror and shutter open. :nono:

Doing long exposures requires a fully charged battery or two. ;) Even more so when it is cold.


As has been said, activating the long exposure Noise Reduction in camera will make the camera unusable for the same amount of time as the original exposure, which could be long time if you are using the Bulb setting.

You would probably have more control over Noise Reduction by doing it in software after capture in a computer. It would be interesting to see if anyone has done a comparison between the two methods.
 
Noise is random

Why not take multiple exposures, and get photoshop to remove the differences?
 
Some noise is random, but some photo sites may heat up and give predictable results, so the in built NR turns the sensor on for the same amount of time, whilst not recording an image, to replicate the original exposure, and subtract the photosites which may have recorded a value with no light.

Very long exposures may also have 'amp glow', where the sensor records areas of colour where the sensor has started to overheat. NR by computer may find this kind of 'noise' difficult. In camera NR may replicate the 'amp glow', and remove it more successfully.

I've never done long exposures beyond the maximum 30 seconds, so don't know whether this is still as big a problem as a few years ago.
 
...Very long exposures may also have 'amp glow', where the sensor records areas of colour where the sensor has started to overheat. NR by computer may find this kind of 'noise' difficult. In camera NR may replicate the 'amp glow', and remove it more successfully.

I've never done long exposures beyond the maximum 30 seconds, so don't know whether this is still as big a problem as a few years ago.

The 5D (well mine at least) suffers quite badly from this. Pretty annoying at times. Generally on exposures of many minutes though, so it is asking quite a lot from the sensor.

Best thing for noise on long exposures in my experience: Don't underexpose. :thumbs: Just because it's night, doesn't mean your photo should be black.
 
On my 400D is don't bother with noise reduction, it causes shots to take twice as long and wastes the battery (not to mention creating massive gaps in startrails), instead I had the camera map the pixels that go erronous (hot pixels) and it will automatically take them out, with no extra time. I regularly shoot in the range of 5 minutes at a time (sometimes 10-20 shots at 5 minutes each) and have never had a problem with noise on this camera.

From what I understand ISO noise isn't helped by LENR anyway?
 
Mark how did you set the exposure, was it manual or one of the auto settings?

I done what I always do... set my camera to f8, for this type of scene set the focus to infinity... and then take a 10 sec exposure... look at my first shot then by trial and error home in what seems to be the correct exposure... I've never once needed to go past the 30secs so not used bulb really before... except for fireworks when I was painting with the light... Anytime i've tryed to use the spot meter on nightshots to pick up highlights my first shot has seemed wrong to always ended up going with trial and error really... which prob is not correct but i'm ok with it so far...

What do the rest of you do... am I totally wrong there... as I guess its a self taught mix match of technique...

M
 
I done what I always do... set my camera to f8, for this type of scene set the focus to infinity... and then take a 10 sec exposure... look at my first shot then by trial and error home in what seems to be the correct exposure... I've never once needed to go past the 30secs so not used bulb really before... except for fireworks when I was painting with the light... Anytime i've tryed to use the spot meter on nightshots to pick up highlights my first shot has seemed wrong to always ended up going with trial and error really... which prob is not correct but i'm ok with it so far...

What do the rest of you do... am I totally wrong there... as I guess its a self taught mix match of technique...

M

I was just womdering where the 10 seconds came from, if your metering and using auto, sometimes in low light it'll say one thing and do something different time wise, I'd probably do it the same way as you though.
 
I know you will think im stupid but does the shutter then open for the length of the full two exposures because that is what it seemed to do...

1 I pressed the release...
2.camera was set to two second delay... and mirror lock up activated...
3. after two secs the shutter opens... assume it is as I hear it!
4. exposure was set to ten secs but about 25 passed...
4. then I heard the shutter close...

So thats what happened outside... what happened inside with the shutter as there was no opening and closing noise made between the two exposures it takes?

If the camera is taking a "dark frame" to eliminate hot pixels etc then surely the shutter won't open? Otherwise you'd end up with another picture!!!

Read this:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_frame

Hope it helps.

Dark frame subtraction has long been used in astrophotography as a means of noise reduction since hot pixels look dangerously like stars! If you camera does this automaticaly then it look like dark frame subtraction has hit the mainstream. Either way- I don't think the shutter will open for a dark frame.

For real long exposures many astrophotographers (me included) turn off all the noise reduction / sharpening functions etc and shoot in RAW. There's not much you can do about ISO noise but dark frames can be taken manually and applied later in processing.
 
Back
Top