Loss of focus on moving subjects

Messages
229
Edit My Images
Yes
I took my new Tamron out the other day and I'm somewhat disappointed in it. But then, I don't know whether I should be placing the blame on my skills, or lack of. :shrug:

I held focus on my boys for a good 2-3 seconds before they started running towards me, but I only managed a couple of shots before the camera just gave up trying to focus. I stopped taking shots, but kept AF-ON pressed and it never regained focus.

I'd like to think it was my technique at fault, as that could be rectified, with time/practice. If it's the equipment, that's more difficult.


IMG_0876 by Craig & Ruth, on Flickr
Shot 1.
Single focus point held on kids for at least 2 or 3 seconds before they started running. Then continuous shooting commences.

Note: I use AF-ON to 'back button focus'. Camera set to AI Servo mode and, if I remember correctly, low speed continuous shooting (as opposed to high speed).


IMG_0877 by Craig & Ruth, on Flickr

IMG_0878 by Craig & Ruth, on Flickr

IMG_0879 by Craig & Ruth, on Flickr
Shot 4.
Focus well and truely lost.
I keep AF-ON pressed, but stop taking shots waiting for focus to be re-established - it wasn't. In fact, the camera/lens stopped hunting completely. It just gave up!
 
Last edited:
I took my new Tamron out the other day and I'm somewhat disappointed in it. But then, I don't know whether I should be placing the blame on my skills, or lack of. :shrug:

I held focus on my boys for a good 2-3 seconds before they started running towards me, but I only managed a couple of shots before the camera just gave up trying to focus. I stopped taking shots, but kept AF-ON pressed and it never regained focus.

I'd like to think it was my technique at fault, as that could be rectified, with time/practice. If it's the equipment, that's more difficult.

*snip!*

I notice you held the focus on them for a few seconds before they started running - this wouldn't have helped the AF tracking as it had nothing to track and therefore wouldn't have "learnt" the rate of movement of the subject(s). Additionally, it looks like something could have stolen the focus away from the lads. Which focus point where you using? Was it kept on one of the boys throughout?

My camera's AF tracking is nowhere near as sophisticated as yours so forgive me if this explanation doesn't directly apply to you, but when shooting people running directly towards me, I use the centre AF point, track the subject for about 1 second as they are running (keeping the centre point on one of the subjects throughout) before firing a burst.
 
Last edited:
Looks to me like you were trying to focus on quite a small target, the 7D is good but it does take a bit of practice to get the best from it. Try giving the AF button a couple pumps to lock back on when you have the subject over the AF point.
 
The focus point was kept over the targets throughout. I haven't got DPP installed at the moment, so I can't confirm which focus point it was. (Does it show focus point when the camera is in AI Servo mode, or just One Shot? I can't remember.) I think it was the one just to the right of centre.

Your point about tracking a non-moving target is interesting though and something I will consider in the future.

I've had situations like this several times with this new Tamron lens and on fewer occasions with my others. In the past I have released AF and re-applied it. But on this occasion I didn't want to waste time waiting for the camera to lock on again as they were on me quite quickly. I had hoped it would sort itself out more quickly, but it didn't at all.

I'm wondering about the possibility of something else 'stealing' the focus, but there's nothing there. If you look at the images, there's nothing in them in focus. That would have been an explanation I could work with. :(
 
Last edited:
Have you got it set to release priority or AF priority? At least with the latter you'd have something in focus before it would let you take a shot. I'd try with other moving subjects and recomposing on static ones at different distances. Were they within the minimum focussing distance for the focal length of the lens at any point? Doesn't look like it unless they're borrowers...

I've never tried shooting small children running at me so I have no idea whether that is something tricky or well within what any decent dslr should manage without much fiddling about.

Perhaps it was because you had the slower continuous shooting enabled?? Is it a bit more with it with high speed ie expecting faster movement?
 
Servo tracking is the hardest thing you can ask a camera to do.

You need a very good camera, centre AF point, a very good lens, and very good technique. Even then you won't score 100% every time.
 
i would have expected my old 20D to track kids running easily (it was fine with cantering horses), a 7D should have no problem in my opinion. but yes the lens wont help if its on the slow side, which tamron is it?
 
Last edited:
neil_g said:
i would have expected my old 20D to track kids running easily (it was fine with cantering horses), a 7D should have no problem in my opinion. but yes the lens wont help if its on the slow side, which tamron is it?

17-50 2.8 VC
 
I've only had the Nikon version of that lens, for obvious reasons, and although it is nice and sharp it wasn't particularly fast to focus. But a lot of that was down to the quite poor image stabilisation, I found it needed nearly a second to settle and thus I missed the shots. Were you shooting with VC on? It might be worth trying it with it off. I was lucky as the lens was badly focussing for me I got a refund and bought the non-VC version in the end.

For a situation like that with children running towards you I'd use the 3D focus mode on my 7000D as that utilises dynamic tracking across all 39 focus and must admit it works really well for dynamic 'unpredictable movement' in which I'd include running towards you as well. If it is a more static distance but like left-right movement or minimal distance I use normal AF with in constant mode.

As I did look at the 7D, but not own one so this is theoretical, it looks to me like the AF-Zone mode is similar to the 3D tracking on my Nikon. I would try that and with VC switched off and see if that is better.

And, I know I can't belief it either :), but actually with the subjects being clear as they are why not try the full 19 point auto focus. The 7D has got a good reputation and as long as your DOF is not to shallow I bet it will do a good job.

Just some thoughts, but mainly if VC is on switch it off. In my opinion it is not a touch on Canon IS or Nikon VRII.
 
Thanks all for the replies. It's given me a lot to consider and try out.

I agree about the speed of focusing on the Tamron and it's something I've cursed a few times during the short time I've had it. I try not to, but I find myself comparing it to my 70-200. I know this is unfair and I try not to be too critical, but there is a small voice saying, 'You should have bought the Canon.' But the Canon was just too expensive in my mind and I'm going to try and work with the Tamron.
 
I've only had the Nikon version of that lens, for obvious reasons, and although it is nice and sharp it wasn't particularly fast to focus. But a lot of that was down to the quite poor image stabilisation, I found it needed nearly a second to settle and thus I missed the shots. Were you shooting with VC on? It might be worth trying it with it off. I was lucky as the lens was badly focussing for me I got a refund and bought the non-VC version in the end.

For a situation like that with children running towards you I'd use the 3D focus mode on my 7000D as that utilises dynamic tracking across all 39 focus and must admit it works really well for dynamic 'unpredictable movement' in which I'd include running towards you as well. If it is a more static distance but like left-right movement or minimal distance I use normal AF with in constant mode.

As I did look at the 7D, but not own one so this is theoretical, it looks to me like the AF-Zone mode is similar to the 3D tracking on my Nikon. I would try that and with VC switched off and see if that is better.

And, I know I can't belief it either :), but actually with the subjects being clear as they are why not try the full 19 point auto focus. The 7D has got a good reputation and as long as your DOF is not to shallow I bet it will do a good job.

Just some thoughts, but mainly if VC is on switch it off. In my opinion it is not a touch on Canon IS or Nikon VRII.

Is there a way to confirm the actual focus point(s) on shots using Nikon software, or other software?
 
It is in the exif but when using Apple Aperture you can press option+F and it will overlay the focal points based on both how many you had active and thicker borders around those none, one or more that were actually used.
 
It is in the exif but when using Apple Aperture you can press option+F and it will overlay the focal points based on both how many you had active and thicker borders around those none, one or more that were actually used.

Very handy as I use Aperture! Even with 3D tracking (D90/700) its not keeping up with the originally selected focus point all the time. I wonder if, say 21pt, would reduce the load on the processor/be faster?
 
Possibly, haven't tested that. I guess it also depends what the lens is like, and (I am guessing now as I don't know how the interals work) where the particular lens provides the distance details as well to the camera.
 
Well I was using a 70-200mm VRI with AF-S so I guess its as good as any.

I did experiment with a 37-70 AF-D and the focus tracking was not as good.

I think there's always going to be some lag, so maybe best to fire of a few
more FPS to get it covered. At least that's what I'm going to try next time,
in addition to 21pt.
 
i would have expected my old 20D to track kids running easily (it was fine with cantering horses), a 7D should have no problem in my opinion. but yes the lens wont help if its on the slow side, which tamron is it?

Agreed. Mine will lock on to things travelling at 400 knots.

Sponge - do you have another lens you can try the body with?
 
Your AF point is placed perfectly over the boy in green and you have AF point expansion enabled. I can't explain why AF tracking got thrown off, but it does appear as though the camera lost its grip on the boy and started to rack focus towards MFD in the hope of trying to find something to latch onto. Once the camera gets its knickers twisted like that it really is best to release the AF-On button and re-acquire a fresh lock.

In this scenario it probably didn't help to have AF point expansion on because the boy is so small that pretty much one AF point almost covers him entirely in the beginning of the sequence.

20110917_152114_000.jpg


You will also note that in terms of colour and brightness the boy in green does not stand out well from the background of grass, and once focus goes off he is even less distinct, leading to the racking focus to try to find the subject. Given the 7D AF system is colour aware you may have had more success by tracking the boy in the orange top.

Finally, given the extensive DOF at the start of the sequence it's my guess that the camera did not even notice the boys starting to run until it was too late. Focusing for several seconds while they stood there would not have helped. The camera needs to establish a pattern of movement in order to track successfully. The massive DOF probably concealed the movement altogether, at least at first, and by the time the camera spotted it was all going wrong it was already too late. Hence the focus racking and the disaster that followed. Quite possibly, if the lens is slow to focus then that probably just added to the woes.

With all that said, I can't say I can recall any similar issues with my 7D which could not be explained by the more challenging nature of a fast moving, low contrast target. I don't use my 17-55 much, and rarely for action, but here's one example where the 7D seems fully able to track a fast subject with a similar short zoom lens.

20110917_143120_000.jpg
 
Back
Top