Merits of manual/auto focussing?

Messages
255
Name
Mark
Edit My Images
Yes
Have used the search function to see if this has been discussed before, but can't see owt about it.

I have attended a few landscape workshops over the last few months learning from different photographers each time.

Most advocated auto-focussing before pulling the trigger, whilst others only ever manually focussed their shots.

On the one hand I have been advised to auto-focus on part of the composition (one third in etc), then switch to manual focus, recompose & pull the trigger.

On the other hand I have been told to manually focus on say the same part of the composition, before recomposing and taking the shot.

What's the difference, if any?

Is it just a matter of choice, preference or are there real merits to going with one or t'other?
 
Well, autofocusing generally leaves you to concentrate on other parts of the photograph such as composition and can be handy if you are just trying to get that quick snap. However, it can be unreliable in the sense that the camera doesn't always know where YOU want the focus to be and instead chooses the focus point for itself.

Manual focus can sometimes be faster that autofocus but if you add that in to having to deal with all the other steps then it usually ends up slightly slower. However, it gives you much more control over where the focus is applied so can help you get it right 'first time'.

My preference is that if I am using a lens that has the option for manual focusing then set the camera in aperture priority, set the aperture and then manually focus. If I am using a FBW (focus-by-wire where you use a dial on the back of the camera to move the focus) lens like my X10 then I leave it in auto focus as FBW is never as intuitive to use. I also usually have it set to multi-point focus but if I know for definite where I want the focus and I'm not sure the camera will get it then I move to area focusing and choose a section of the view-screen that I want to focus on.

Hope this helps,
Asa
 
I often use hyperfocal for landscapes to get basically everything in focus. If I'm using a lens with a focus window, I'll use manual focus as it takes out the guesswork.
 
I grew up with MF and still prefer it in many ways, but my ageing eyes struggle a bit with the small/dim viewfinders on a crop camera. It's fine on my F2 or FM. With the 30D, I usually shoot AF with back button focus to separate it from exposure.
 
i use back button focus on theD7000, but the 18-105 kit lens is auto/manual all the time, so i either press the button or twist the ring ( or both ) and concentrate on what im trying to take
 
+1 for back button focus, you should be able to set this on the 50D in the custom menus.
 
If you're using a crop camera with a standard focus screen, and you're manually focussing, you're tying an arm behind your back. Modern AF is loads better than most people can MF with this kit. Trying to MF like this is like doing all your own gear changes in an automatic car.

OTOH a FF or medium format camera or film camera, with a suitable focus screen is a tool designed to manually focus.
 
Another thing to bear in mind is that the optical viewfinders in most DSLRs have a quite a large depth of focus compared with film SLRs of the past. This which means that accurate manual focus is difficult.

Precision focusing screens are available for some cameras which make it much easier to achieve good manual focus but the nature of there design means that unless you are using a fast lens (f/2.8 or lower) then the viewfinder may become unacceptably dark. Also, metering may be affected (Canon's with the ability to switch VF screens have a custom function to accommodate this).

This wasn't so much of a problem in the 35mm film SLR days as all VF's were FF and fast lenses were more the norm.
 
I switched from manual focus cameras to autofocus back in the eighties, when my eyes first started to show signs of age and I needed specs. Autofocus made things faster for me then. Now I use autofocus most of the time for general views, but when things are really critical I switch back to manual focus and spend a bit more time getting things right. This applies especially to macro photography, when depth of field is very small. Nowadays many SLR viewfinders have dioptre adjustments, which helps a lot. Another superb aid for critical focus in macro photography is LiveView, as you can use this to zoom in on your screen and see precisely what is sharp and what isn't.
 
+2 for back button focus, it's a bit like manual focus for the lazy, and you always know where your focus is
 
Back
Top