ND 10(1000). ND16

Messages
1,683
Edit My Images
Yes
I have an ND 10 (1000) filter and it is ideal for sunspots and creamy waterfalls etc. I read that for the forthcoming eclipse, & for work on the sun (sunspots) etc an ND 16 filter is better. So I ordered an ND 16. It arrived today but I can see through it and the sun is much too bright for it. It says on the rim it is an ND16. Have I bought the wrong filter or is it the wrong glass in it.
 
A quick Google suggests you've fallen foul of the somewhat confusing alternatives for ND filter ratings.
An ND16 is a 4 Stop filter, so much less than the 10 Stop (ND 1000) filter you had.
Google suggest for a solar eclipse you want a specialised 16 stop filter (ND100000) that includes additional IR and UV blocking
EG:
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Concept-ND100000-Optical-Celestial-Observations/dp/B0CPXJ1N3Q

(hopefully someone with experience of photographing an eclipse will confirm)
 
It's an easy mistake to make. The different ND rating systems can be quite confusing, so thanks for raising the question. It'll probably save someone else from buying the wrong filter too.
 
As an astronomer...............
Buy a sheet of proper Baader solar film. Anything else and you're risking damage to your camera, and possibly your eyesight. You can use a cereal packet to knock up a home made mount that just slips over the end of your lens, or if you prefer into a square filter holder. The slip over design is better for a large aperture lens. Every time before you use it hold it to a light source (a bulb, not the Sun) and check for any damage. A pinprick is enough to wreck the film and it's not very substantial, so store your filter carefully.
For visual observing be even more careful. Use proper eclipse glasses and again store and check them carefully. Also bear in mind that if you're using the eyepiece of an SLR design camera to line up on the Sun (rather than the rear screen) you are still effectively visually observing
For the forthcoming large partial eclipse with the Sun low in the sky it may be we get a 'natural' filter in the form of cloud or haze in which case a filter may not be needed. If you can't see or can barely see the Sun through the filter it's okay to take it off.
 
Back
Top