New Lightroom/Photoshop.

Avo

Messages
2
Name
martin
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi all, I’m just wondering what everyone thinks about the latest Lightroom/Photoshop updates ?
Being able to re light a photo after it’s taken is crazy.
Is it all getting a bit too AI ? I enjoy some of it but when it takes to much away from actual photography I’m out.
 
I dont think much because the updates were minimal this time. You have a couple of new gen ai toys which you can safely ignore as they will likely be the same low res subpar slop as before
 
The relight layer is amazing. And incorporating built in Topaz AI edits can also be amazing (or stupid). But for the most part I just don't use those capabilities.

What bothers me is how heavily a lot of others are using AI extensively for their photography... it's getting hard to trust what you see.
 
I think there is a fine line between basic touching up an image and then the adding of elements, lights, rays of sun, different skies, stars, generative AI and such.

When does it cross over from photography into something else?

That being said, some of the stuff people use is very clever and having a sound grasp on the PP side of things can turn a poor photograph into a pleasing image......but is it still a photograph?
 
I think there is a fine line between basic touching up an image and then the adding of elements, lights, rays of sun, different skies, stars, generative AI and such.

When does it cross over from photography into something else?
I'm not sure it matters... I've always been fine with pretty heavy edits; even in the darkroom with film (composites, removing items, etc). I've always looked at it as "art" rather than documentary.

But it's getting to the point where there is no requirement for creative effort, just type some suggestions into a prompt box. And AI edits ca be just as bad; having nothing of the original image other than having used it as a reference.
 
Gonna have to look up that relight thing ,, my main joy was they have fixed the LR- PS denoise problem,my only use of AI is to remove twigs or leafs but that’s it
 
I think photography is becoming digital art with the amount of stuff that gets routinely changed / altered on photos. There's nothing wrong with that. It is what it is.
 
Gonna have to look up that relight thing ,, my main joy was they have fixed the LR- PS denoise problem,my only use of AI is to remove twigs or leafs but that’s it
In my case add rubbish bins that nobody wanted to touch or move, certainly not me
 
I think photography is becoming digital art with the amount of stuff that gets routinely changed / altered on photos. There's nothing wrong with that. It is what it is.
There was always digital art, well for me anyway when i got into it around 2009. It was regarded as distinct form of art, and was created at will, not random seed hashtag
 
I think photography is becoming digital art with the amount of stuff that gets routinely changed / altered on photos. There's nothing wrong with that. It is what it is.
For me, digital art has always existed (well, for as long as digital has) but it isn't photography, and "photography" cannot become digital art because it's then no longer photography.

My rule of thumb is that with some obvious exceptions, I'm not that fussed about things getting changed or altered as long they retain an "honesty of interaction" between the photographer and the subject, And, the initial file has come from a "live" interaction between the subject and a photographer using a light-sensitive medium to record how they "saw" this interaction.

We could complicate this by discussing the use of other wavelengths across the electromagnetic spectrum, as well as remote triggering of cameras where the photographer may have spent years setting up the cameras, but wasn't present when the photograph was taken, but I'm happy to include these as "photography".
 
your all obviously not doing a lot of exporting, in classic at least.

the update has broken export and it freezes after the 3rd or 4th file/batch of files and necesitates a restart. I do question why i pay all this money for such a shoddyly performing product. Convinience and "locked in" i guess....
 
as well as remote triggering of cameras where the photographer may have spent years setting up the cameras, but wasn't present when the photograph was taken,
Reminds me of a Wildlife Photographer of the Year Award of an Orangutan at the top of a tree, taken on a placed GoPro with no photographer present ... yes it was a photograph, but not my kind of photography.
Tim Laman (2016): Won the prestigious Wildlife Photographer of the Year award for his wide-angle perspective of a Bornean orangutan climbing a fruiting fig tree in Gunung Palung National Park, Indonesian Borneo. He rigged remote-control cameras high in the canopy before dawn to capture the unique view.
 
your all obviously not doing a lot of exporting, in classic at least.

the update has broken export and it freezes after the 3rd or 4th file/batch of files and necesitates a restart. I do question why i pay all this money for such a shoddyly performing product. Convinience and "locked in" i guess....
Odd, I haven't noticed any problem with exporting in the latest LRC (iMac).
 
Odd, I haven't noticed any problem with exporting in the latest LRC (iMac).

It seems to be a known issue

 
It seems to be a known issue

Could be why I haven’t experienced it. I never export more than one photo at a time.
 
I had this issue yesterday. I was only exporting one image at a time but when I tried to close the program I had still exporting messages showing progress of zero.
 
Reminds me of a Wildlife Photographer of the Year Award of an Orangutan at the top of a tree, taken on a placed GoPro with no photographer present ... yes it was a photograph, but not my kind of photography.
Having worked with remote triggered cameras a reasonable amount, for scientific purposes, the amount of work needed to make a "good" photograph is immense, and needs a lot of skill.

I do have a more general point however, in that I think these awards should be the Wildlife "Photograph" of the year, and not "photographer", unless they are based on a portfolio of work, to account for "lucky" shots.
 
Hi all, I’m just wondering what everyone thinks about the latest Lightroom/Photoshop updates ?
Being able to re light a photo after it’s taken is crazy.
Is it all getting a bit too AI ? I enjoy some of it but when it takes to much away from actual photography I’m out.
Could not agree more. I cannot see the point of a photo of something that wasn't there. I like to keep my post processing to a minimum.
 
What's with this Vectorscope thing? It takes up a lot of space on the rh develop panel. Is it possible to get rid of it?

Some of these things seem like change for the sake of change.
I think you can right click on it and remove it.

The vectorscope is a standard tool for correcting white balance, flesh tones and colour saturation in video editing and it's something that many people have been asking Adobe to port into their stills processing tools for decades.

It's been in Affinity Photo since its introduction and in Open source programs like Darktable and Raw Therapee for as long as I can remember, and available as third party plugins for Photoshop.

There is an introduction in how to use it in the Canva help


This is just one of a suite of colour grading tools found in video editing tools, and "some" stills processing software

Canva list them here

 
I think the Vectorscope view is useful but some as demonstrated by earlier posts dislike it.
There is a v16.0.1 update which I accepted earlier today.
 
I think the Vectorscope view is useful but some as demonstrated by earlier posts dislike it.
There is a v16.0.1 update which I accepted earlier today.
Yes, I think all of these colour/tonal grading tools can be useful to have available. I
 
Back
Top