Newbie in need of DSLR buying help (please)

Llamaman

Proud Addick
Messages
7,422
Name
Not an addick!
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi

I’m looking for some advice on a first DSLR/Microsystem. Sorry for the length of the post, but I figure that the more info I give you, the easier it is for you to give advice!

Some basic info;
I already have a pretty good point-and-shoot (Lumix TZ7) but would like a DSLR for improved IQ and also to give me some creative options (particularly depth of field and filters/polarisers), plus giving me something to learn about photography with. I’m never going to go pro, but I’d like a bit more input into my photography than point and click.

The main uses will be cityscapes, landscapes, some portraits and indoor work. Probably some opportunistic wildlife but no sports.
I reckon I need a kit zoom and a prime to start with , and will probably have to save up and get a dedicated wideangle and a telephoto lens later. My initial budget is about £600-£800, including lenses, filters, etc but obviously I’d like to spend a lot less if I can!

I’m not bothered by size (I already have a point-and-shoot for when I need something small) or looks.
I’ll primarily use the viewfinder for composition, but a flip-out LCD might come in useful occasionally for awkward angles.

I’ve done a bit of research already, including handling some cameras in a shop (didn’t get advice as it was a high-street general electronics shop…).
I’ve got quite big hands (span rather than fat) and found the Sony Alphas too difficult to hold (gap between grip and lens snout is too small).
The Canon 550D looks like a great bit of kit, but combined with an extra lens and other kit, it becomes a bit too pricey for me at this stage (pushing £1,000).
I’m not keen on MFT as they seem to be overpriced – they cost the same or more than an SLR but have fewer features. The Sony NEXs were also a litlle small for my hands.

I’ve narrowed it down to 5 cameras, in two different price ranges;

Options 1 - 3 - Cheap (~£500)
1. EOS 1000D with 18-55mm kit-zoom and EF 50mm f1.8 mk2 lens (total £438)
2. Nikon D3000 with 18-55m kit-zoom and 35mm AF-S f1.8 G DX (total £518)
3. Samsung NX10 with 18-55m kit-zoom and 30mm pancake (I know it’s not an SLR but it has an SLR-size sensor?) (total £500)

The NX10 looks an OK option for the price, but I’m wary about committing to a brand-new format with only 3 lenses (I know they’ve promised 5 more, but 3 of those were promised for second half this year and there’s still no sign of them…). If Samsung kill the range off, I’m stuck with a white elephant with few lenses, no upgrade route and little resale value. Plus, with no OVF, you don’t have the option of phase-detect AF which I understand is superior to contrast-detect (will I notice the difference?). The Canon is a bit cheaper (£450) and I can keep the lenses if I upgrade to a more fully-featured camera in a year or two. The downside is no video (but I rarely use it on my point-and-shoot, so not a deal breaker) and a fixed LCD.
The Nikon looks OK, but has no live-view and costs more than the Canon. The only plus is that the prime and zoom have the same filter thread, so I only need one set of filters/polarisers (although would a step-up ring achieve the same on the Canon?)
Overall, I think the Canon wins at this price-point?

Options 3 & 4 - A bit more costly
4. Canon 500D with 18-55mm kit-zoom and EF 50mm f1.8 mk2 lens (total £608)
5. Nikon 5000 with 18-55mm kit-zoom and 35mm AF-S f1.8 G DX (total £638)

The Nikon seems to be ahead in this one – it has a video mode, a flip-out LCD and an in-camera help function for newbies like me. I’ve also read that it’s better in low light than the Canon. The only downside is that the reviews I’ve read for the Canon prime lens really rate it (the IQ, if not the build quality) – should this sway me the other way?

My gut instinct at the moment is to go for the EOS1000D – it seems OK enough and the upgrade route to the 550D’s successors should be a good one. Or do you think I should cough up the extra couple of hundred and go for a slightly better specced model (in which case, the Nikon might be the one)?

I’d be very grateful for your thoughts / help!

Oh, and one final thing – the key driver for the purchase is that I’d like it for my honeymoon (flying out 22/09) so it’ll need to be a model available now (so the Nikon 3100 is out). I hope to make a purchase before the weekend to give me time to play with a little (and cycle the battery) beforehand.
 
I'd recommend looking at the Nikon D5000 and also possibly the D90.

But best advice is to go instore, Jessops, etc. and have a feel of the camera. Don't want to buy one based on reviews or specification and then find you don't like the feel of it.

Once you decided on the model or models, hunt online (try camerapricebuster) for the cheapest price. Or you may be lucky and find that the model you want is available cheapest at a local store.

Always remember also that the likes of Digitaldepot are members of talkphotograpy, so worth contacting them, via the forum, to see what kind of deal they can do.
 
Option no 2 seems to me to be the most suitable, bearing in mind your proposed usage, though you might wanna pay a little extra for the 18-55 VR kit if VR appeals. Be easier to sell the VR kit lens whan you grow out of it.

Others will disagree..... :thumbs::thumbs:
 
D5000 is a do-it-all, you'd never need to upgrade. It has the articulated LCD on top of good foundations. 18-55 and 35 1.8 are both great lenses. Has to be option 5, if you ask me.

All the best!
 
I have the 1000D and only the standard lens at the moment. Sometimes I'm very happy and surprised with the image quality that I get and other times I'm not too happy at all. That is probably just inexperience though. If you could afford to get a 450D or maybe the 550D I would recommend it
 
Just to fuel the fire go Canon, its worth it:D


Seriously get to a shop and have a feel of the models that are within your budget and pick the one that is most comfortable for you:thumbs:

Give some thought about possible upgrade paths for the future if this is something you want to do ongoing.

If you had more time i would suggest starting with 2nd hand kit as you tend to get a lot more for your money.

But MOST importantly enjoy your honeymoon and stuff the camera:naughty::lol:
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the replies so far!

In reply to all your posts generally;

I've already handled the cameras on my short list (and ruled out the Sonys as a result) and found the Nikons and Canons to be roughly the same comfort-wise (neither was wonderful, but that's probably due to my freaky paws and I can't afford a full-frame beast).

I initially also ruled out the Nikons due to dark viewfinder, although I've since found out that that was due to either a flat/no battery, so they made it back onto the list.

I didn't play around with the menus much as I didn't know what I needed to be looking for (only bought my guide to photography book today!). Obviously that kind of thing is very subjective, but I'll probably just get used to whatever I get as it'll be my first SLR so nothing will feel "wrong".

The 550D is a very nice piece of kit, but it's just that bit too expensive for me to justify it (to myself) as a first SLR.

I should have pointed out that the price I quoted for the D5000 included the VR lens.

If the Nikon prime can match the Canon, I think Nikon just about nick it with the flip-out LCD and noob-friendliness (sorry Canon enthusiasts!)

Sadly,I don't have time to look into 2nd hand for the body and first lenses (serves me right for eloping rather than spending a year planning the wedding), but I'll definitely look at getting further lenses/flash etc with used kit.

I'll shop around a bit, but Jessops is likely to be my port of call as there's one very close to work (Canary Wharf) with all of my shortlist in stock...

One extra question - the honeymoon (and wedding!) is in the States, starting in New York. I might be able to get a good deal at B&H (not as great as it used to be with the exchange rate heading south), but at the expense of losing the retailers warranty. Will Canon/Nikon UK honour a warranty purchased outside of their territory or will I have to return it to the states if I get a fault under warranty?
 
I started with a Nikon D3000 only lasted 2 weeks before I upgraded to the Canon 5d MK I as the iso on Nikons entry level cameras are not good at anything beyond 800 ,
The second hand route is the best way to go you can pick up a great xxD Canon for around the £500 mark ( my 5D was second hand grade 10/10 for £699 ) there are plenty of bargains out there
 
I initially also ruled out the Nikons due to dark viewfinder, although I've since found out that that was due to either a flat/no battery, so they made it back onto the list.

That makes no sense to me.

The battery has nothing to do with the viewfinder. It's optical, light reflected from the lens by the mirror, so shouldn't be affected in any way by battery levels.



I think the nikon D5000 would be a great option as a first camera because of it's (as you said) 'noob friendliness'.
But the 1000D does leave you with more money to blow on lenses.

I'd perhaps also through in that you can pick up good condition used 40D's for less than £400 now. That's got to be the best VFM you can get at the moment.
 
Last edited:
I agree with everyone who is advising 'try before you buy. How it handles and whether you actually LIKE the thing are far more important than make or even model. I changed from Canon to Nikon because the controls fell to hand/finger better for me, it may be the other way round for you. I could have saved myself some few years of struggle as well as a load of cash by trying before I bought.
 
I initially also ruled out the Nikons due to dark viewfinder, although I've since found out that that was due to either a flat/no battery, so they made it back onto the list.

That makes no sense to me.

The battery has nothing to do with the viewfinder. It's optical, light reflected from the lens by the mirror, so shouldn't be affected in any way by battery levels.

True.

If you think the Nikon has a dark viewfinder then it does. To you, that is. It's nowt to do wi battery.
 
Hmm, I respect your opinions, but others beg to differ...
http://www.photokb.com/Uwe/Forum.aspx/photo-digital-slr/9530/Dim-Nikon-viewfinder-compared-to-Canon
http://www.flickr.com/groups/nikond5000club/discuss/72157623372121095/

The theory is that the LCD overlay (used for gridlines etc) in the OVF goes dark with no power. I'll go into Jessops and try it out properly.
The dangers of Google!

I beg to offer my apologies. I'm utterly wrong. Ooops:bonk:

Just never had a battery THAT flat!
 
I went with the Canon 500D for my first dlsr, never looked back! From your option 2 you can get it for alot less than £608 - recently on Amazon/Camera Buster prices have gone down to £479 for the camera & 18-55IS lens - I've just purchased a nifty from eBay for £76 inc P&P (brand new)
 
Everyone will suggest based on what they have or like, I'm no different myself though I don't have the same level of brand loyalty some seem to have.

I would suggest one of two options, both similar prices in total

1 - Nikon D90 +18-105mm VR F3.5-5.6 lens £769

2 - Canon EOS 500D body + Tamron 17-50mm F2.8 lens £738

The Nikon is a good camera and the lens gives a reasonable zoom range, the set up is only limited in as much as the lens wont let in as much light as the Tamron and thus shutter speeds will be slower.

The Canon is an admirable camera, works very well in my experience and the Tamron lens is both fast ie it lets in more light and allows faster shutter speeds, and as sharp as a razor.
The two work well together and as someone who shoots indoors all the time in low light I know it will work well.

Both are priced from cameraworld, cheaper than jessops but a reliable company to buy from.

The canon would leave just about enough from your budget for a 4GB memory card, spare third party battery and cheap zoom case, the Nikon would be just a memory card and maybe a cheap zoom case.

If you only really just wanted the 50mm F1.8 with the 500D you can knock £200 of the quoted price,again its a cracking combination and also an unbelievably light and compact combination.
 
Last edited:
I beg to offer my apologies. I'm utterly wrong. Ooops:bonk:

Just never had a battery THAT flat!

I assume the shop removed the battery to prevent light-fingered customers...
 
To further prove my complete ignorance, it has been pointed out to me (on another forum) that my logic in buying the fast prime (low f/stop value for DOF work) was fundamentally flawed. Having now read up a bit on DOF, I reckon a f/3.5 kit lens will do well enough for me to play with for the time being, thus saving on the prime and leaving more cash for the body.

Assuming I plump for the D5000, I then have the quandary of whether to take the 18-55 kit lens (£638) or body-only and get the 18-105 (total £678). Will I sacrifice much IQ for that increased reach?
 
Assuming I plump for the D5000, I then have the quandary of whether to take the 18-55 kit lens (£638) or body-only and get the 18-105 (total £678). Will I sacrifice much IQ for that increased reach?

That 18-55 is, by all accounts, a fantastic lens. Very good value. If you're looking for a little extra reach without losing sharpness, I'd highly recommend the Nikon 18-70 DX (you can pick one up second hand for around £130). Would love to advise on the 18-105 but haven't used it myself.
 
and found the Sony Alphas too difficult to hold (gap between grip and lens snout is too small).

Presumably you mean the a200/300 series which are the entry level bodies? They are very small, the other crop sensor bodies (400/500 series) are more conventionally sized and the a450 + 18-55mm kit lens is £313 from Comet online at present.
 
I originally bought the 1000D as my 1st dSLR camera in Dec 2008 and was immediately impressed and didn't know why I ever bothered trying to get a good picture with a compact. But then again, I found myself comparing the quality of the pictures against pictures taken from better spec Canon cameras such as the 5d, 450d etc.

First thing the woman who was in curry's who was helping me said was, you either swear by nikon or by canon...very rarely both and as far as im concerned so far she is right...for me Canon is the one to go for.

In my opinion the 1000d was the best entry level camera to get at the time but a lot of good kit has come out lately. I have upgraded the 550d in the last few weeks and am chuffed to bits with the difference/ improvement in picture quality and features. I would recommend you spend a little more and get the 550d as you will feel the need to upgrade a lot sooner than you planned if you go for the 1000d. Either way i recommend you go for the canon :thumbs:
 
To further prove my complete ignorance, it has been pointed out to me (on another forum) that my logic in buying the fast prime (low f/stop value for DOF work) was fundamentally flawed. Having now read up a bit on DOF, I reckon a f/3.5 kit lens will do well enough for me to play with for the time being, thus saving on the prime and leaving more cash for the body.

Assuming I plump for the D5000, I then have the quandary of whether to take the 18-55 kit lens (£638) or body-only and get the 18-105 (total £678). Will I sacrifice much IQ for that increased reach?


That depends on what DOF effect you wanted, if you wanted shallow DOF ie the background blurred with the foreground/subject sharp then they are quite wrong the fast prime is the way to go over the kit lens. theres a fair bit of difference between shooting at 50mm F2-2.8 on the prime and F4-5.6 on the zoom, remember most lenses, especially budget lenses are rarely at their sharpest wide open, always bank on stopping down a little.

If however you want everything in focus including the background, then you would need a small aperture ie F11-16 so it wouldn't matter so much.

Another thing to bear in mind is that the autofocus will work better with a larger aperture in low light, your maximum 50mm aperture with the two lenses mentioned will be F4, whereas with the prime it will be F1.8.

PS prime lenses don't have to be expensive, you know the price of the canon, cheap as chips, the nikon is around the same area at just over £100.

Please note on the lenses you mention though F3.5 is quoted as the lower figure, this will only apply at the wide end of the zoom, by the time your at 50mm it will be F4 in general.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, I should have been clearer! Yes, I'm particuallry interested in playing around with shallow DOF to defocus background/foreground in shots.

Thanks for all your help – it is really appreciated.

Ian - your post, whilst informative, leaves me in a bit of a quandary; I think I’m going to go for the D5000. Cameraworld have the body and 18-55m f/3.5-5.6 IS for a very reasonable £500 (new). But they also have a refurb body-only for £350 and a refurb Sigma 18-50mm f/2.8-4.5 OS for £160. Should I sacrifice the extra 5mm reach and perhaps a bit of IQ (apparently that 18-55 is very good for a kit lens) for the wider aperture?
Has anyone tried both?

(Another option is the Nikon 18-105 f/3.5-5.6 ED VR DX at £200 (new). Pretty convenient, given the range, but only the same aperture as the kit lens...)

Aaargh! Too many choices! Where's that lottery win when you need it? :)
 
Sorry, I should have been clearer! Yes, I'm particuallry interested in playing around with shallow DOF to defocus background/foreground in shots.

Thanks for all your help – it is really appreciated.

Ian - your post, whilst informative, leaves me in a bit of a quandary; I think I’m going to go for the D5000. Cameraworld have the body and 18-55m f/3.5-5.6 IS for a very reasonable £500 (new). But they also have a refurb body-only for £350 and a refurb Sigma 18-50mm f/2.8-4.5 OS for £160. Should I sacrifice the extra 5mm reach and perhaps a bit of IQ (apparently that 18-55 is very good for a kit lens) for the wider aperture?
Has anyone tried both?

(Another option is the Nikon 18-105 f/3.5-5.6 ED VR DX at £200 (new). Pretty convenient, given the range, but only the same aperture as the kit lens...)

Aaargh! Too many choices! Where's that lottery win when you need it? :)

Remember the 2.8 aperature will only be at the wide end on the zoom range i.e. 18mm it will get narrower until u get to 50mm. If you are want to get a zoom lens I would try for the 17-50mm f2.8 (fixed throughout the zoom range) as it gets great reviews, I am actually lookig for one myself.

If I were you I would try for a second hand 40D (350-375) or 50D (around 500) with the Tamron lens (200-250 second hand), that is if video doesnt intrest you.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, I should have been clearer! Yes, I'm particuallry interested in playing around with shallow DOF to defocus background/foreground in shots.

Thanks for all your help – it is really appreciated.

Ian - your post, whilst informative, leaves me in a bit of a quandary; I think I’m going to go for the D5000. Cameraworld have the body and 18-55m f/3.5-5.6 IS for a very reasonable £500 (new). But they also have a refurb body-only for £350 and a refurb Sigma 18-50mm f/2.8-4.5 OS for £160. Should I sacrifice the extra 5mm reach and perhaps a bit of IQ (apparently that 18-55 is very good for a kit lens) for the wider aperture?
Has anyone tried both?

(Another option is the Nikon 18-105 f/3.5-5.6 ED VR DX at £200 (new). Pretty convenient, given the range, but only the same aperture as the kit lens...)

Aaargh! Too many choices! Where's that lottery win when you need it? :)

With the Nikons coming with a 2 yr warranty on new DSLR bodies I think its worth the extra to buy the new one over the refurbished one as the refurbished one only has 6 months warranty.
Lens wise if you can go a little further for the Tamron it would be great, if not going for the 18-105 would be a good move over the kit lens.

In short with what your saying I would be going for the new D5000 + either the Tamron 17-50 F2.8 or Nikkor 18-105.
Just remember to register the D5000 body within 30 days of purchase to get the free extra years warranty.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for all the advice guys.

In the end, I'm going to go for the dual kit (18-55 VR and 55-200 VR) - it's marginally cheaper than getting the just 18-105 VR and obviously offers greater range (albeit at the expense of an extra lens!) and I get a free bag thrown in :)

The last thing is memory card - Nikon say it can support Sandisk SDHC cards upto 16Gb - should I be going for the Extreme III variant (20Mb/s or 30Mb/s depending on whether you get old or new stock, it seems), or will the Ultra (15Mb/s) be able to keep up?

Once again, thanks for all the help - you've been much more helpful than the other two forums I've posted on (no replies at all on one of them...)
 
I've got the exact same kit as that (D5000 with 18-55 and 55-200mm) and am more than happy with it. The only downside is obviously having to swap lenses if I want to go over the 55mm, but it's rare that I'll be snapping things that would require both lenses at the same time.

As for SDHC cards, I've got several of the Sandisk Extreme (or old style Extreme III) cards. The ones I've got are the 20mb/s kind and are more than adequate, so I'd go for them. Also, don't bother getting one big card, better to have 4 x 4GB cards than one 16GB card as if it goes belly up you've only lost 4GB of pics rather than 16GB's!
 
Back
Top