Newspaper wants me to remove copyright logo on my image

Messages
1,176
Name
Amin
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi everyone
I wonder if anyone can shed some light on this issue I have been debating please.
I have a few pics of interest to a local newspaper and I don't mind them using them free of charge. Its a long complicated story about why I don't mind but let's just say I am not being paid for them and at this stage I am ok with it. But the thing is they say usual procedure for newspapers to publish images they have to remove the small copyright logo I have on the bottom corner. Its a tiny one but still they want it removed. Also they do not guarantee me to credit with the image in any way possible, saying that wherever possible they will put a credit below the image but not necessarily as a commitment.

So my question is this. Are they just trying to pull a fast one? Or its fair to take it that images going to press tend to not have a copyright mark on them, in which case I am happy to remove. But I definitely find it hard for them not to commit to credit any image used to me by a simple small script under the image.
Your opinions please.

Many thanks
 
No idea personally,

But if I was you I would be happy to remove the logo Aslong as I was credited below. Otherwise i would't bother as your doing it for free and its not huge hassel to have taken by...
 
As far as I know this is normal practice. You can hope to have a credit, but this can be a bit hit and miss. Make sure though that you are not transferring copyright to the newspaper. That the image is for use within that publication only, and not available for any additional use
 
Not really pulling a fast one, they are sticking to normal operating procedure which would be no watermark - have you ever seen a watermarked image in a paper? - and no commitment to a byline, things that probably wouldn't bother a paid photographer.

If you ask me, the way the paper wants to stick to how they would treat paid images/photographers suggests they might not be too used to working with photographers who are willing to give images for free and that you are might set a damaging precedent but that's a different discussion.
 
Not really pulling a fast one, they are sticking to normal operating procedure which would be no watermark - have you ever seen a watermarked image in a paper? - and no commitment to a byline, things that probably wouldn't bother a paid photographer.

If you ask me, the way the paper wants to stick to how they would treat paid images/photographers suggests they might not be too used to working with photographers who are willing to give images for free and that you are might set a damaging precedent but that's a different discussion.

I did say in my intro that I am not getting paid for it but didn't say I wasn't benefiting out of it and take my word for it, immensely. I did not want to go into details because there are commercial deals in place with other parties involved also.

The question was purely on a small single issue which I wanted to hear from the experienced ones.

Thanks
 
Which is why I didn't go into it too much either.

I've never given images for free, neither have I ever sent watermarked images but I have been published plenty of times and I think only once gotten a byline. That's all the experience I can offer.
 
Which is why I didn't go into it too much either.

I've never given images for free, neither have I ever sent watermarked images but I have been published plenty of times and I think only once gotten a byline. That's all the experience I can offer.


Thanks Brian, that is really helpful.
Like you i also think freebies is just setting a bad precedence, so do not bother. But these images are being sent to the news desks by the company with whom I have commercial deals in place. And they returned asking me to remove the logos so just wanted to make sure.

Thank you again for your very kind and helpful clarification.
 
Put your details into the file info, that way at least the paper has them 'built in'.
 
If they are going to treat you as a "paid" photographer then inform them that the image is for single use only in that publication, and that you retain all copyright.
 
swanseamale47 said:
If they are going to treat you as a "paid" photographer then inform them that the image is for single use only in that publication, and that you retain all copyright.

Definately this as most will sell the images to the public also.
 
Definately this as most will sell the images to the public also.

Wow, I really didn't know that newspapers did that. So you mean images that they can get hold of and if terms such as that are not specified (for single use only for that publication) then they are able and do go on selling the images?

I better get back to sorting out my stuff properly then. Many of the images that are going to be published involve many celebrities and big names. Got to get this really well cleared up.

Thank you so much for pointing me all these details out.

Thanks
 
Most publications I've worked with won't accept images without correct file info, and there's a section in there which allows you to clearly state that the image holds copyright and who with. As stated previously, no watermark is common practice, and credits are always hit and miss (...usually miss to be honest with you as they can fill that space with something more relevant).

I don't particularly see the issue with not being paid if you're benefitting from it in some way. People need to realise that even at a paid, professional level, "back-scratching" and favours are a crucial way of opening doors for yourself. Far worse are people who charge through the nose for distinctly average images!
 
I'm fairly sure they have a legal obligation to provide a credit to you. Certainly the case over here, and I think it's the same back at home.

As it's coming from this other company, I'm assuming it's an advertorial of some kind? Which may change things. I'd guess they wouldn't include it in their library for sales to the public either if that's the case.
 
I'm fairly sure they have a legal obligation to provide a credit to you. Certainly the case over here, and I think it's the same back at home.

As it's coming from this other company, I'm assuming it's an advertorial of some kind? Which may change things. I'd guess they wouldn't include it in their library for sales to the public either if that's the case.

Yes you are right, its for an editorial.
Here is one as an example, unfortunately no credits in the byliner.

Yesterday the organization called me to take some macro shots because the newspaper photographer who was there didn't have a macro lens to take images of some insects. I took a few and they were sent to the newspapers desk, let's see if there will be a byliner on these ones.
 
Yes you are right, its for an editorial.
Here is one as an example, unfortunately no credits in the byliner.

Yesterday the organization called me to take some macro shots because the newspaper photographer who was there didn't have a macro lens to take images of some insects. I took a few and they were sent to the newspapers desk, let's see if there will be a byliner on these ones.

There is no legal obligation for the paper to give you either a fee or a credit Some do, some don't. However, you are perfectly entitled to retain copyright of any images - make this quite clear on submission, and as above, fill out the IPTC section in File> File info for each image. Doesn't need much, usually, just name, contact info, copyright status and use restrictions. Add a title and caption. They can't sell copies to the public or anyone else without your permission, and requests for copies should be passed on to you. This is roughly the agreement I have with the local papers around here (although I get a fee for every job, but then I've been doing press work for quite a while).

This said, once they call on you to provide specific shots - like the macros you've been asked for - this then becomes a commission in my book, and while again they are under no *obligation* to pay you, you are in a pretty good position to ask for a fee. It's a matter of negotiation. Sure, give them some freebies to show what you can do, but if they are going to use you on a regular basis, ask for money.
 
Obviously you're in a position to know more about this than me, but I thought moral rights laws in England compelled them (where reasonable, or something) to credit you if you ask?

I think it's the difference between `moral` and `legal`. `Moral` isn't a very newspaper-y concept. :D
 
There is no legal obligation for the paper to give you either a fee or a credit Some do, some don't.

There is a legal obligation for them to follow the terms of the license you grant. If one of them terms is a credit then that is a condition of use and they then have a legal obligation to provide such credits.
 
Last edited:
There is a legal obligation for them to follow the terms of the license you grant. If one of them terms is a credit then that is a condition of use and they then have a legal obligation to provide such credits.

I would expect most publications to refuse to accept such conditions. Quite often, particularly with a paper, a page may be altered at the last minute (often to accommodate an advert). Changing a picture is far faster and easier than changing a written piece - you can just re-size or re-crop. So the credit may get chopped, leaving the paper in breach had they accepted those terms. It's sad, but more and more publications seem to be excluding picture credits. Possibly down to stock shots proliferating?

But, there are an awful lot of photographers looking to be published. Some pushy b****r insisting on a name-check for a mundane news shot is unlikely to hear the phone ring next week.
 
I asked one paper I shoot for regualrly to NOT credit me.. the mess they make of my pics.. cropping to knees.. leaving balls out.., turning everything orange.. yuk rather they just pay and no credit :)
 
I know that feeling! The whole process goes through an automated system now. I used to have to submit in CMYK. Now I could draw it on the back of a fag packet for some editions.
 
Back
Top