Nikkor 24-120mm f4 or Nikkor 16-35mm f4

Messages
6,453
Name
Joe
Edit My Images
No
Hi,

Which Is the Better buy 16-35mm f4 or 24-120mm f4 (both Nikkor) Can someone help me choose please as iam selling my 16-85mm and want to replace with some N glass and FX for future my other lens are 50mm 1.4 , 70-200mm , 70-300mm Which one is best for me any suggestions.

Joe
 
It's hard knowing what you want from a lens...

Personally, I'd go for a 16-35mm because I like that focal length on DX but once you do move to FX, that is a very, very wide lens and TBH, on FX, the 24-120mm would be the more useful lens IMO for general shooting.
 
Last edited:
Joe,

They are totally different lenses for different purposes. What's better out of a screwdriver and a hammer???

To bring up another question, why don't you sell your 70-300mm and get a teleconverter to stick on your 70-200mm?
 
It's hard knowing what you want from a lens...

Personally, I'd go for a 16-35mm because I like that focal length on DX but once you do move to FX, that is a very, very wide lens and TBH, on FX, the 24-120mm would be the more useful lens IMO for general shooting.

Personally for FX my ideal set-up would be 17-35 f2.8, 85mm f1.4 and 70-200 f2.8. I use the 12-24 f4 on DX and it is great for environmental portraiture as it force you to get right up close to your subject and therefore interact with them. However as said we need to know what you shoot. For walkabout lens/events/travel then 24-120. For landscapes, documentary/environmental/photojournalist work then 16-35. This is just my opinion though :thumbs:
 
The 16-35 will be fine for landscape and some architectural shoots, the 24-120 is an ideal 'walkabout' lens giving more options for shooting a variety of situations ... rather depends what you plan to use the lens for.
 
i would choose the 16-35mm. I would use the 16-35 as walkaround more then the 24-120. Assuming you using it on crops sensor.
 
Back
Top