I'd have thought one lens is better than two, but what do I know?
i took the 2 lens route, and now i find i want a bit more reach when im on the 18-55 and when i put the 55-200 on sometimes i feel i cant get out far enough for the odd shot.
Interesting thread.
I've just gone the other route, albeit slightly different, from the other posters here.
I've purchased a 18-55mm VR and a 70-300mm VR to replace the 18-200mm VR.
I love the 18-55 as a walk around - I just find the 18-200 too heavy on my D80. The 70-300 obviously gives me an extra 100mm over the 18-200 too. I don't mind changing lenses as I find I don't do it that often anyway. The IQ of both the 18-55 and 70-300 are a lot better than my copy of the 18-200. From what I've heard the 55-200 has better IQ than the 18-200.
Just my humble opinion.
Edit -I did intend to have 18-70 and 70-300 but the 18-55 VR came up and I'm very impressed with it.
do you really really need to go buy more lens especially when the 18-200 vr is nearly double the amount of the 18-55 and 55-200 (i think )
18-200 ain`t a heavy lens mate. Try lugging a 600 about.........
pahhh 600mm, what about the new 300-800 youve just got, bet that hurts when its on as a walkabout......
Sorry, no, with 800mm you can just lean out of the bedroom window and photograph anything
its not quote as bad as double.
The 18-55 is £139.99, the 55-200 is £179.00 -- Total £319.98
and the 18-200 is £429.99
Remember these are the more expensive VR versions.
The 18-200 is VR II, the 55-200 the older VR, the 18-200 has a metal mount, the 55-200 has a plastic one.
on the metal mounts?
Both combos have their merits, if I had to choose though I'd probably go for the 18-200, for the metal mount/VRII and convenience. I think you'd forget the £100 or so difference in price pretty quickly
No because I use the 70-200 for motorsport and the 50mm/18-50 for things near me. The 18-200 was used for everything until I bought the others.
The 50mm is by far the best, nothing will beat that!
As for the others; they're all the same. The main/only difference is the aperture.