Nikon and Cannon strategic alliance - Coffee break discussion

Messages
6,400
Edit My Images
No
In 1933 The first Cannon Camera (Hansa) had the optically superior Nippon Kogaku Nikon lens fitted. Ipso facto.

Just got me thinking, if Cannon and Nikon collaborated today and produced a new DSLR I wonder what it would be like ?

Would it be the ultimate DSLR ?

What would be the issues ? - main one on my list would be the interchangeability of lenses.

Do you think a strategic alliance would never happen ?
 
Do you think a strategic alliance would never happen ?

Probably only if both were in economic difficulty or have declining market share. It's not beyond the realms of possibility that a newcomer (or current smaller player) could come to market with something revolutionary, putting pressure on the major players.

One factor that will slow things is the money photographers have invested in their particular brand, meaning significant changes in the market may happen slower than in products where consumers have little investment.
 
I don't think it would really be any different. Both camera makers create almost identical cameras in terms of quality. They are both at the forefront of technology, so I can't see how combined expertise would change the game in any meaningful way.
 
i bet there are still under the table dealings.each know what the other is doing and work to the opposites.
last gen most would say the d700 was a better lowlight cam and the 5d the high mp studio.
this gen going by the specs the coin has flipped. its abit strange this happening dont u think. i would have thought they may have been very similar this time. both with similar mp and iso preformance.
not a trade of places
 
Do you think a strategic alliance would never happen ?

Not for a DSLR, which was your specific example. There's too much invested in seperate product lines and customer bases. They're just too alike and too big. They are fairly evenly matched and there isn't an obvious situation where one could benefit from a unique strength of the other (Sony/Zeiss). As the two market leaders there's no "win" in it unless it was something so completely new and so big an investment that neither was capable of bringing to market on their own (Olympus/Panasonic). Neither are particularly struggling for capacity of volume to need to work together to subsidise development and manufacturing costs (Panasonic/Leica).
 
I would suggest that an alliance would be bad. If you consider that it is the competition between the two striving to maintain / increase market share that keeps the R&D money flowing. In a monopoly (effectively would be if they joined forces) the focus would be extracting money from the consumer with small improvements (think apple and the differences in iPhone 4 to 4s and the iPad 2 to 3) rather than having to keep one step ahead of the competition.
 
Well, it will use Canon sensor for a start, since Nikon don't make it's own.

As for the design, construction, I really doubt it would change much.

What I would be intrigue to find out is which way does the lens mount turn! It confused the crap out of me when I picked up my first Nikon to find that it twist anti clockwise to screw the lens on. Which is counter intuitive to everything thing else out there.
 
A co-operative product would be worth it just to see thousands of keyboard heroes on either side implode just trying to get their head around the fact 'their' superior product had been dirtied.
 
A co-operative product would be worth it just to see thousands of keyboard heroes on either side implode just trying to get their head around the fact 'their' superior product had been dirtied.

YES! Finally put an end to the fan boy worship and childish snide comments about the other brand and their users.
 
YES! Finally put an end to the fan boy worship and childish snide comments about the other brand and their users.

They'd just spend their time arguing about which part of the camera was best :)
 
Canon and Nikon are in business to make money, just like every other company. I've no doubt they would collaborate, or even merge their photographic divisions, if they thought it was in their best interests. Their customers' interests would come a long way down on their list of priorities. Whether this is ever likely to happen is another matter.
 
An interesting thought.

Perhaps combining certain elements from both Nikon & Canon could create an amazing piece of kit but which? I always wished Canon's cameras had as many AF points as the Nikon's range but they've met that need in the new 5D MKIII ~ shame I can't afford one!
 
Back
Top