Not pleased with my prints. My fault or not?

Messages
4,234
Edit My Images
No
I've just received several prints back from a well known printer. It's the first time I have used this company.

Now, I'm not looking to blame - it could all be down to me!! I'm looking for advice from the more experienced.

Background. Prints are colour images with white backgrounds. I PP'd the images as normal but the prints have come back and are not perfect.

It looks like the printer has failed to deal with graduations of white and produced a subtle (but obviously visible) pinkish halo in places. I've never seen this effect on prints from my normal print shop.

So, from my point of view, I have not produced an image where the background is not 100% white in all places - but pretty damn close.

So, is it my pp'ing or should the print have dealt with graduations in a better way.

Advice please?
 
I've just had a second look at the jpegs. It's me - but seems to be exagerated in the prints.

Here's (roughly) my PP process.

1. Take original image
2. Duplicate layer
3. Up the levels on the duplicate layer
4. Delete the areas of the image other than the background

As I'm deleting the top layer (to expose the subject), I'm 'nicking' into the pure white background. I couldn't see this on my normal screen, but bizarrely it's evident if I look at the image on a laptop and tilt the screen.

So, has anyone got a better way of making sure a background is pure white before print. This is a major set back for me :-(

In all fairness the Mrs spent ages studying the images and couldn't find fault - but I now they are wrong - and therefore only good for scrap!! :-(
 
snip...
Advice please?

It really depends on the printer. We use a couple of Roland VP540's for large format wall vinyl and it struggles with fine gradations. It especially struggles with whites. Same for the Epson 7900. I would suggest using a color chart and match the white you want to that. Embed the profile and away you go. Alternatively get hold of an icc profile from the printers you used to calibrate with.

Using 3rd party printers can be a royal pain the backside as you never know what inks they use, printers or printing settings.
 
A way of checking is to open a levels adjustment layer, hold down alt and move the r. h. slider in. You'll quickly see if you haven't got a good clean outline against the white background
 
I would duplicate layer, choose select and colour range, pick out the white background with the colour picker tool, adjust fuzziness so it gets it all, layer selection via copy, set colour to pure white, and use the paintbucket tool to fill it, merge the layers making sure that one is on top and your done.
 
I would duplicate layer, choose select and colour range, pick out the white background with the colour picker tool, adjust fuzziness so it gets it all, layer selection via copy, set colour to pure white, and use the paintbucket tool to fill it, merge the layers making sure that one is on top and your done.


Good way indeed but surely you should be getting the lighting correct in the first place.

If you want to just up the white levels, open a levels adjustment layer, select the white point pipette and click on a whiteish area of the background, hey presto, the background becomes white but some other parts of the image will have changed too. Use a mask to bring back the original where it doesn't need boost in levels.
 
Good way indeed but surely you should be getting the lighting correct in the first place.

If you want to just up the white levels, open a levels adjustment layer, select the white point pipette and click on a whiteish area of the background, hey presto, the background becomes white but some other parts of the image will have changed too. Use a mask to bring back the original where it doesn't need boost in levels.

Thanks for the tips. Trouble is that I've not got CS but only PSE :(

With regards to getting the lighting right in the first place - in an ideal world yes. In reality lighting everything white (head to toe) is virtually impossible.
 
If you look at the info panel, the white areas should read 255 in the R, G & B channels. To get white it has to be 255 in each channel - not "nearly". You should be able to just run the cursor over the white areas.

Although you have PSE you can easily edit that - Instead of a mask, use a layer and the erase key.

THere are many ways to change the background towhite very easily. I use the magic selection tool to select anything that needs to be white. Feather it a bit and then use the layers pallet to move the white slider. Pressing ALT while you move the slider will show what is turning white.

Easy in Lightroom too using the Auto Mask (if you have that).

I use a Hilite and my floor is a muddy grey. Approx 20 secs and I can turn it white without affecting the rest of the image.
Cheers
JD
 
Back
Top