Rustico said:Hmm, wow. I have to say, I would like the color version better except for the variation in color at the bottom right corner. But I think you are right; the b/w version works much better!
lfc1892 said:doesn't work for me i'm afraid. The stones on the floor have that upside down feeling which feels a little weird to me. Hard to make out what the reflection is too. Sorry if this is a little harsh, and it's only as it was marked for serious crit. Nice idea though.
Forbiddenbiker said:Not for me either, its just odd looking. I didn't even see the refelction at first. However I do think the idea is class, so maybe next time a full clarity reflection that dominates and demands to be viewed as the main subject, would make it work.
mrtoad said:an upside down shot which could be enhanced by rotating 180* and doing some cropping
cheers
geof
sorry i got that wrong...its the image being near the bottom which led me into that opinion
may need to do an edit just to see how wrong i was
couldnt really improve on any of the two...just cloning out the edge stuffWould love to see what you come up with
Thank you for your honesty. Any advice for next time or generally capturing reflections?
lfc1892 said:In the case of this one, I just think it would have been better a little more wet. Just to show a little more detail. It's quite abstract as it is, and that will appeal to many, but purely subjectively, i'd want a little more clarity.