One of them police vs 'togs questions

Messages
247
Name
Adam
Edit My Images
Yes
Im just really wondering who on the forum has been accosted by the police at any point in time whilst out with their camera.

Reason im asking is because i have been stopped 3 times now and it's really starting to cheese me off how i am made to look like a criminal.

First time i was out with a fellow 'tog from here and we were out at night down by a river, just simply trying to get some star trails above the river. Nothing wrong with that you would assume, but after an hour we heard a car pull up next to where mine was parked. We went back to the car as we saw some torch lights, where we were greated by two officers who checked all of my details, d.o.b, where i worked, where i lived, checked my photo's etc. When i asked what they were doing, they said well we got to check for these things now days, you know, what with terrorism. :o

The other times we were just asked what we were doing, how long we were going to be here, and why we were taking photos. Whilst on top of a hill overlooking Salisbury at nighttime.

I just feel that they are getting a wee bit over careful nowdays.

I appologise if this type of thread has been up many times before hand.
 
As far as I am aware you shouldn't need to provide your name or details unless stopped driving, you don't have to provide them if on foot.

Also, when the stop and question you they should give you a form saying they have done so. Keep them in your camera bag and tell the next lot that stop you just show them and explain you are a little cheesed off with it.
 
I've been approached three times on one night before by different pairs of officers.. but only for a general nosy and a chat on a cold night. Never been asked for details when night-shooting.

Have you checked the local papers? that type of attention suggests there was something happening somewhere that night and you had the misfortune to be nearby.
 
Often been told to b****r off by security, but never stopped by the rozzers....seem to remember having a chat with one in Manchester a few years back, but he was just interested in photography iirc.
 
Never had a problem - ever but then I'm not called Slothmeister!
 
Me and another member on here where told to leave the quarry we where in. but we had walked past big signs telling us not to enter.

He was very polite.

Was once challanged by some busy body woman on the street who said "why are you taking photographs" so told her I was an assocate of the royal photography soctiey, It didn't answer her question but she didn't really know what to do with this pice of information so just walked off! :D

Stuart
 
People out at night attract police attention. Fact of life. It's not just photographers tbf, although the fact we go out with a legitimate motive makes it frustrating.

They should approach you reasonably and in turn you should respond co-operatively. You don't have to give your name or details but if you choose to exercise that right (aka invite trouble) the police have processes at their disposal to determine whether or not you are wanted/ up to no good/ an innocent photographer.

For a routine "who are you, what you up to" type chat you won't get any record. For a stop and search under Section 44(2) you would have got a receipt but since July this year Section 44(2) has been discontinued at the instruction of the Home Office following a European ruling. Section 44(1) remains available but applies to motorists and their passengers. Section 43 is also available but demands "reasonable suspicion of terrorism" Photography alone does not constitute reasonable suspicion; photography and an un-cooperative attitude might...

From the Met guidelines: "Officers do not have the power to delete digital images or destroy film at any point during a search. Deletion or destruction may only take place following seizure if there is a lawful power (such as a court order) that permits such deletion or destruction." Furthermore, there are limited circumstances where they can view the images you've already captured. You'll have to decide if it's worth potential aggravation not to comply with a polite request.

My advice (as a photographer, not lawyer/ police official):
Carry a copy of the bust card from PhotographerNotATerrorist.com
Stay calm
Carry a small portfolio of your own images as prints. If you're in the middle of a long exposure this may get around their desire to view your camera images.
Ask for collar number/ warrant card if the officers don't freely identify themselves
Keep your own records so you have reliable information if you do decide to submit a complaint.
Keep shooting, don't let it get to you.
 
People out at night attract police attention. Fact of life. It's not just photographers tbf, although the fact we go out with a legitimate motive makes it frustrating.

Was about to mention your "incident" as mentioned on the pan thread.

Thanks for the info. Have headed over to the suggested site and downloaded the card, will be very helpful me thinks.
 
Give them a business card and tell you do family portrait discounts for the Emergency services. Easy way to get less hassle..................Simples!!!!

Why waste an opportunity...............:lol:
 
Give them a business card and tell you do family portrait discounts for the Emergency services. Easy way to get less hassle..................Simples!!!!

Class response! That's the attitude of a true pro - everything is a potential business opportunity! :D
 
They should approach you reasonably and in turn you should respond co-operatively. You don't have to give your name or details but if you choose to exercise that right (aka invite trouble) the police have processes at their disposal to determine whether or not you are wanted/ up to no good/ an innocent photographer.
.

I don't like the circular logic that police sometimes seem to apply in these cases though - 'you don't have to give your details, but if you don't then we'll decide you are a troublemaker'.
 
Was about to mention your "incident" as mentioned on the pan thread.

Thanks for the info. Have headed over to the suggested site and downloaded the card, will be very helpful me thinks.

Yeah, as far as I know I'm still the only person to have been subjected to S44(2) *after* it was discontinued. 28 days since I put in my official complaint, the IPCC Guidelines say you should hear progress updates at least every 28 days. ****'s about to get even more interesting.
 
When i asked what they were doing, they said well we got to check for these things now days, you know, what with terrorism. :o

The Police can't, stop/search you under section 44 of the Terrorism Act any more, it was deemed to be illegal by the Eurpoean Court of Human Rights.

They can only use section 43 and for that they need reasonable suspicion that you are a terrorist.....
 
Whats the problem? isnt it nice to know they are about at night checking on people... give them your details..why not? there not going to think hmm camera gear and rob yer house now they know where you live..

Personaly I would be happy to know they are out and about and happy to provide my details.. yes even three times :)
 
Whats the problem? isnt it nice to know they are about at night checking on people... give them your details..why not? there not going to think hmm camera gear and rob yer house now they know where you live..

Personaly I would be happy to know they are out and about and happy to provide my details.. yes even three times :)

:thumbs:
 
The Police can't, stop/search you under section 44 of the Terrorism Act any more, it was deemed to be illegal by the Eurpoean Court of Human Rights.

They can only use section 43 and for that they need reasonable suspicion that you are a terrorist.....

See my comment immediately above yours.

I was stopped on 17th October 2010 - the C12A they gave me clearly states S44(2) and, as alluded to above, I'm presently awaiting their response to my official complaint.

They don't seem to be treating my claims of unlawful detention with any priority, wondering whether they'll sharpen up if I add common assault: that's right, isn't it - when someone goes through your pockets in public without your consent :thinking:
 
I don't like the circular logic that police sometimes seem to apply in these cases though - 'you don't have to give your details, but if you don't then we'll decide you are a troublemaker'.

The way I always look at it is that firstly they are human and are curious, and these days assume everybody is upto no good, so I generally just chat to them very friendly. They have the power to make my life awkward so why let it get that far.

If they continue asking questions I find if you get really nerdy with them they soon get bored.
"Oh yes officer, well first I thought I'd try a long exposure of ISO 100, F10 for about 25 secs but that didn't come out quite correct so I make a very minor tweak to the settings..."
 
I wouldn't worry about this any more, the way this government are cutting the police force you wont see much more of them on the streets!!!
 
See my comment immediately above yours.

I was stopped on 17th October 2010 - the C12A they gave me clearly states S44(2) and, as alluded to above, I'm presently awaiting their response to my official complaint.

They don't seem to be treating my claims of unlawful detention with any priority, wondering whether they'll sharpen up if I add common assault: that's right, isn't it - when someone goes through your pockets in public without your consent :thinking:


According to this article S44 can now only be used to search a vehicle

The Home Secretary

"Officers will no longer be able to search individuals using section 44 powers. Instead, they will have to rely on section 43 powers – which require officers to reasonably suspect the person to be a terrorist. And officers will only be able to use section 44 in relation to the searches of vehicles. I will only confirm these authorisations where they are considered to be necessary, and officers will only be able to use them when they have ‘reasonable suspicion’. "
​

​
 
The way I always look at it is that firstly they are human and are curious, and these days assume everybody is upto no good, so I generally just chat to them very friendly. They have the power to make my life awkward so why let it get that far.

If they continue asking questions I find if you get really nerdy with them they soon get bored.
"Oh yes officer, well first I thought I'd try a long exposure of ISO 100, F10 for about 25 secs but that didn't come out quite correct so I make a very minor tweak to the settings..."

I'd agree with this. Sometimes you just have to play their game.
 
I wouldn't worry about this any more, the way this government are cutting the police force you wont see much more of them on the streets!!!

And that's not always a bad thing. First casualty for us was the Wiltshire 'safety' camera partnership :clap:
 
I've been lucky so far - a couple of run ins with security guards, one in a shopping centre who wanted to "confiscate" my camera despite the fact it was in my bag and not being used. I informed him that the didn't have the authority to take my property and if he tried to take the bag I would regard it as theft and be forced to defend myself. He still demanded I hand it over, so I suggested he call his manager or I would call the police.

He backed down and stomped off in the huff.

The only time I was stopped by the police was when a very nice WPC approached me when I was out taking pics. It turns out she was doing a photography course and wanted to have a chat about photography.
 
I got stopped last week by a security guard, who then got the police involved.

He insisted that the car park I was photographing was private property (correct) and that I couldn't take pictures of it (incorrect.)
I pointed out I was on public land (pavement) and could take pictures of the multi storey car park.

He wasn't having any of it and called me a "security threat" (5x4 camera on tripod???)
The police office was a bit lost for words and didn't say much as I explained to him what I was within my rights to do.

Just be polite and accept it's part of life....
 
The only time I was stopped by the police was when a very nice WPC approached me when I was out taking pics. It turns out she was doing a photography course and wanted to have a chat about photography.

Ooh, did you get her phone number? :cool:

Uniforms and all that position of power stuff :woot:

:D
 
According to this article S44 can now only be used to search a vehicle

Yup, precisely.

Long story short. Was out taking long exposures in city centre on the 17th. CCTV officers called me in. 10 mins later police arrived and gave me a load of Section 44. I told them they had their facts wrong which they didn't like and got even more arsey including personal search.

My detainment was unlawful and that makes the personal search a matter of common assault. Submitted a formal complaint on the 19th. It's now 29 days later and they still haven't responded other than to acknowledge receipt of my complaint.
 
Thanks for all the replies, glad its not just me and them im being picked on cause i have a beard :)

Useful to hear peoples opinions on it, i will check out a few of the things people have suggested. I Guess the thing im worried about mostly is leaving my car in random places very late at night like car parks in the forest and then for the police to turn up and snoop around the car whilst im now way near. I guess i could always put a sign in the car with a mobile number in it for them to contact me if needs be.
 
I Guess the thing im worried about mostly is leaving my car in random places very late at night like car parks in the forest and then for the police to turn up and snoop around the car whilst im now way near. .


I am sorry but I find the above to be the wierdest thing I have read in this thread...... seriously I dont understand why you would be worried about police snooping about your car.. i would ahve thought the opposite... keep the thieves away..

Or am I missing something too obvious?
 
I am sorry but I find the above to be the wierdest thing I have read in this thread...... seriously I dont understand why you would be worried about police snooping about your car.. i would ahve thought the opposite... keep the thieves away..

Or am I missing something too obvious?

Does seem pretty weird :thinking:
 
I am sorry but I find the above to be the wierdest thing I have read in this thread...... seriously I dont understand why you would be worried about police snooping about your car.. i would ahve thought the opposite... keep the thieves away..

Or am I missing something too obvious?


Indeed you are!

Maybe he has a cracked tail-light or a dirty number plate or any of the 1001 things the polis can do you for?
 
Indeed you are!

Maybe he has a cracked tail-light or a dirty number plate or any of the 1001 things the polis can do you for?


Like that time you got stopped for drunk driving and when you tried to walk over to the police car the polis said "you're staggering!" and you replied "cheers, yer no bad yersel' " ?*














































*this is a joke ;)
 
Okay the way i worded it might have been wrong.

What i mean is that if you saw the car in a car park in the middle of the forest at 11-12pm at night, you would assume that the owners would possibly be up to no good, unfortunatly a lot of these car parks are used by kids for doing drugs etc. I don't want someone, be it police or public to see my car and just assume that i am doing the same. When it couldn't be further from the truth.

Any better?
 
if i was out at 11-12 at night in a secluded wooded area and saw torches flashing around my car... i would be relieved that it was a copper.
if you've got nothing to hide and everyone's polite and reasonable then it's no biggy is it.

oh sorry, yeh... i forgot.. you've got a beard :D
 
Yup, precisely.

Long story short. Was out taking long exposures in city centre on the 17th. CCTV officers called me in. 10 mins later police arrived and gave me a load of Section 44. I told them they had their facts wrong which they didn't like and got even more arsey including personal search.

My detainment was unlawful and that makes the personal search a matter of common assault. Submitted a formal complaint on the 19th. It's now 29 days later and they still haven't responded other than to acknowledge receipt of my complaint.

were you handcuffed?



Certainly did, it's 999 :D

Dun dun dunnnn!
 
Hmmm, what a refreshing subject, I dont recall this ever being discussed before :bang:

But sec 44 isnt strictly 'unlawful' under UK law - its simply a ruling from the ECHR and my understanding is that UK law doesnt always have to adhere to ECHR rulings if it conflicts with UK law, as the European Convention was never fully enacted into UK law (just a heads up before people spout of about s44 being illegal if questioned). If s44 has been suspended by a UK force then its out of choice not legality, at present at least.
 
Last edited:
Hmmm, what a refreshing subject, I dont recall this ever being discussed before :bang:

But sec 44 isnt strictly 'unlawful' under UK law - its simply a ruling from the ECHR which UK law doesnt always have to adhere to as the European Convention was never fully enacted into UK law (just a heads up before people spout of about s44 being illegal if questioned). If s44 has been suspended by a UK force then its out of choice not legality, at present at least.

It was suspended "out of choice" by Hampshire (the applicable constabulary in my instance) in Jul 09 and discontinued by the Home Office earlier this year, the latter of which is detailed in these quotes from a statement made by the Home Secretary Theresa May on the 8th July 2010 to the House of Commons:

Theresa May said:
"I can tell the House that I will not allow the continued use of Section 44 in contravention of the European Court's ruling and, more importantly, in contravention of the civil liberties of every one of us."

"Officers will no longer be able to search individuals using Section 44 powers. [vehicle searches excluded]. Instead they will have to rely on Section 43 powers - which require officers to reasonably suspect the person to be a terrorist."

Or do you know something we don't?
 
Back
Top