Opinions please?

[GR3Z]

Should i have cropped the bank and grass out of the image


Boat by GR3Z, on Flickr?

 

[jim_j]

For me it looks better without.

 

[mick1985]

I also think it would look better without

 

[Rustico]

Yep, I think it would be better without it!

 

[MWHCVT]

I agree it would be better without the bank as it would give the image a sense of solitude, I also think a B&W conversion could work

Matt
MWHCVT

 

[GR3Z]

I agree it would be better without the bank as it would give the image a sense of solitude, I also think a B&W conversion could work

Yeah, didn't think of B&W I'll try tomorrow

 

[Dan Gleebitz]

Yeah, the bank does tend to draw the eye.

 

[flintheart]

I think the cropping will surely enhance the beauty of the picture...

 

[GR3Z]

hers some edits with the bank removed
1.
boatbw by GR3Z, on Flickr

2.
boat edit by GR3Z, on Flickr

 

[aethelstan927]

Think i prefer the colour version. . .

 

[DjLukeW]

The colour one is my fave, and much better without the bank. Good shot

 

[Rustico]

Color for sure!

 

[jim_j]

Colour for me, but maybe a more severe b&w conversion to increase the contrast might work. Still it is a very good shot.