I can tell you what I like which is as far as I can go. You're using a different printer, which might give significantly different results to mine. When I was using a Canon printer, I used Canon paper which was supplied with it. My normal Epson printer uses Hahnemuelhe Photo Rag, Somerset Enhanced Velvet (similar papers, but a striking difference in mid tone contrast with my B&W prints) and Canon Infinity gloss.
There's a wide variety in base colour which can make a significant difference to the mood of a print, not to mention the many different surface textures. I've tried many different papers (via sample packs) and the three above are the ones I mainly use.
Different printers (meaning people who print rather than machines that squirt ink) have different tastes, and, dare I say it, different kinds of photographs to print, both of which should influence paper choice.