Paper wins landmark web photos copyright battle

Messages
231
Name
Fred Dawson LRPS
Edit My Images
Yes
holdthefrontpage reports

Paper wins landmark web photos copyright battle

A landmark copyright battle has been won by a South East newspaper which lifted photos from a website for a police appeal story.

Following a routine briefing with officers last August, the Reading Post used seven pictures from the 'Urban Explorers' website which features images of people inside abandoned and derelict buildings.

Reading Police were keen to trace the trespassers as they believed they might have committed criminal damage to enter the town's buildings and be linked to a spate of graffiti.

Officers did not give the Post the pictures directly, instead explaining where they could be found online, but after the Post carried the appeal one of the photographers took the title to the small claims court.

He claimed his copyright had been breach and demanded £495 payment for use of the shots.

However the Post defended its use of the pics on the grounds of public interest as they had been used as part of a police appeal – believed to be the first time a newspaper has won such a case.


report continues
 
Not so much copyright theft as enticing out a potential criminal. Quotes here from the article are interesting


John Murphy (29/01/2010 09:48)
Bravo to the Post, copyright is so often used to bully the media and restrain public interest journalism. The law of copyright only protects work which is considered worthy of that protection, it would clearly be an abuse of power to protect those engaged in unlawful activity from being detected by the police. All you angry snappers out there should read page 454 of McNae's.


Claire (29/01/2010 10:22)
Chris, You don't seem to understand the distinction between a photograph which is not associated with a crime and one that is. This person was, as the judge says, flaunting his criminal behaviour. Alas, he came unstuck. Just deserts, I'd say! Good on the Post for doing this.
 
Trespass is a civil matter, not criminal. Without proof this should not have gone against the photographer IMHO. Suspicion is not proof. There is no proven link he committed anything other than trespass.

I have no link or association with any aspect of this incident or case, but it alarms me because it seems to set a precedent... :(

Edit: And since when has Reading been in the South East? :thinking:
 
Pure and simple - that is theft. Ridiculous that should go against the photographer.
 
Where did you think it was?

About 20 miles west of Maidenhead, which is west of London. I always figured the South East to be the bottom right hand corner of England, as viewed on a map. London/slightly West of london was the South, and Newbury/Swindon way was West... :thinking:

I'd have said Reading was in the South personally.
 
I'd have said Reading was in the South personally.
Strangely enough the South East is in the South too. Reading is in the Eastern half of the south which puts it in the South East of England.

Oh and yes, I would class this as copyright theft.
 
The law of copyright only protects work which is considered worthy of that protection

That is what they are using (i.e. the photos are not worthy of copyright due to the trespass and possible criminal matters) and trespass may be a civil matter but if any property was deliberately damaged to gain access, that is not.

Note there is precedent as this refers to case law

The Post, working with the Newspaper Society's political, editorial and regulatory affairs department, used case law from 2001.

That judgement said a court would be entitled to refuse to enforce copyright of work if the work is immoral, scandalous or contrary to family life, incites or encourages others to act in such a way, or injurious to public life, public health and safety and administration of justice
 
As someone who occasionally likes a bit of dereliction I find this somewhat alarming.
Presumably my images could incriminate me for trespass if the location is recognisable.

I'm sitting on a stash of images I rather like and would love to publish; but I've never done anything with them as while I was on the site I found out it was being actively patrolled. I later found out they have a local reputation for being heavy handed and abusive.

Googling this location is like it no longer exists, so I suspect it may be old news to the Urban Exploration communities.
But if taken to extremes then a lot of dereliction shots would fall into this category.
 
Note there is precedent as this refers to case law: The Post, working with the Newspaper Society's political, editorial and regulatory affairs department, used case law from 2001.

That judgement said a court would be entitled to refuse to enforce copyright of work if the work is immoral, scandalous or contrary to family life, incites or encourages others to act in such a way, or injurious to public life, public health and safety and administration of justice

I am bemused the judge found trespass to be covered by any of those items listed.

If I were to take a semi-nude photo of a pregnant and single mother-to-be would that preclude my having copyright too? :thinking:

I don't wish to turn this thread into a right or wrong discussion. I am just alarmed this case went against the photographer, and the implications for other photographers. :(
 
Presumably my images could incriminate me for trespass if the location is recognisable.

No. You can not be incriminated for trespass as it is not a criminal offence. They could be used as evidence in a civil action for damages though. But even then it is debatable you were present. You might have loaned your equipment, bought the images, or even bought the camera or memory card with the images already on them. And that brings us into the scope of the so called "orphan" law... A right minefield if you ask me.

The only real evidence of trespass is either being found in-situ or photographed in-situ by a 3rd party who was beyond reproach.
 
I guess it's "incites or encourages others to act in such a way" and because a lot of the locations can be dangerous it gets mixed in with a heavy dose of "public health and safety".

There is a lot of inspirational stuff on the Urban Exploration websites.
 
This is the most interesting line:

Whatever view may be taken by individuals on the rules which govern our society...you can't flaunt them.

That says a lot more about the case than what many would interpret. Think about it.
 
Trespass is a civil matter. All they can do is ask you to leave. Taking photos of non-criminal trespass, and then posting them online after you've already left the premises is a non-matter. You wouldn't incriminate yourself for anything.

CRIMINAL trespass is different story, and assumes you've broken something or used forced entry to gain access to the property. Basically, it's trespass + vandalism. Or, civil trespass can escalate to criminal trespass if you are asked to leave by the landowner and then you refuse, at which point he can call the police, and they can ask you to leave. If you still refuse they can arrest you.
 
What made you think we lived in a free country anyway? :)

Relatively speaking we do. But I'd be interested in hearing examples of societies which have significantly greater freedoms than our own.
 
Hepburn - I'll feel a lot happier if you can justify why their images are not attributable to individuals or do not represent evidence of trespass....

I didn't say they do not represent evidence of trespass, quite the opposite in fact. I've quoted what I posted a little while ago in this thread:

They could be used as evidence in a civil action for damages though.

The reason they can not be attributable to an individual is because there is no proof the individual took the photo unless he features recognisably in the photo itself (or admits he took it).

Even in a claim for copyright payment there is no evidence the person took the photo. They might just have bought the copyright and want it enforced. Think about it. You buy a secondhand camera from a legit source, say a High St pawnbroker type shop. It turns out the camera is stolen. The police become aware of this and charge you with theft - because you have the goods even though they can't place you at the crime scene. Judge says guilty, take him/her down. Is that fair?
 
Kaouthia, Hepburn - thanks, good info. I'm feeling a lot better now :)

Hepburn - something I can't get straight in my mind...
If you make a claim for a copyright payment, how are you going to claim copyright except by admitting you are the author? I assume having a carmera/card with somebody elses images on it wouldn't give you copyright over them as there is no agreement to transfer copyright, hence claiming copyright could be fraudulant?
 
Kaouthia, Hepburn - thanks, good info. I'm feeling a lot better now :)

There was a big article (in fact, it was the "theme" of the whole issue) in one of the photography mags a few months ago. I've got it somewhere, but no idea where atm.

If I can find it, and thus remember the name of the magazine, I'll check their website to see if they had any of the articles online (a couple of them dealt with the trespass/criminal damage laws).
 
Hepburn - something I can't get straight in my mind...
If you make a claim for a copyright payment, how are you going to claim copyright except by admitting you are the author? I assume having a carmera/card with somebody elses images on it wouldn't give you copyright over them as there is no agreement to transfer copyright, hence claiming copyright could be fraudulant?

You could have bought all publishing rights without a transfer of copyright, plus is it not the case after death all copyright royalties continue to accrue and are passed on to the estate of the deceased?

My point was not to focus on the issue of copyright per se, but that of proving the photograph was taken by the litigant who brought the case. ownership is not proof of involvement in a crime.

I suspect in the case mentioned it was probable the guy did the damage and he was lucky to escape some kind of criminal charge. But, getting off doesn't mean the photo shouldn't have been paid for. The press were quite capable of reporting the facts without a photo, or sending along their own tog. Clearly the police avoided any copyright issues because they weren't prepared to send the actual photo, just a link.

Given the increasing number of occassions the press simply take and print a photo they haven't paid for, to have that action seemingly endorsed by a court is troubling.
 
Kaouthia, hepburn - thanks so much so you considered responses
It is worrying - and I'm glad you two have been able to put you finger on the problem far more succinctly than I have.
Looking forward to seeing where this thread goes
 
Interestingly, Radio 4 News tonight had an interview with the new head of the Crown Prosecution Service. When questioned about their work with Women in The Sex Industry his response was that just because someone breaks a law does not mean that they do not receive the protection from the law in other matters.

Perhaps someone ought to be telling the judge in this case.
 
Back
Top