- Messages
- 2,777
- Name
- Drake
- Edit My Images
- Yes
I was considering purchasing either the Nikkor 70-200 f2.8 VRII or the Nikkor 85 f 1.4G lens. I took the following two pictures, among several others, in the shop. My plan was to review them to determine if both lenses were suitable for my needs.
I was very surprised to see the severe purple fringing in the 85 mm f1.4G but understand that wide open this sort of thing can happen. (Look at the edges of the ammonite and all the white lettering.) The shot taken with the 70-200 is stopped down to 7.1, so is an unfair comparison, but I offer it up to show what the store display really looks like.
The 85 1.4G is still there, and at a fair price ($1600 US).
First, would you be put off by the purple fringing at f1.4, or is this just one of the perils of a very fast lens?
Second...since I'm not a physicist or optical engineer...could someone knowledgeable explain why purple fringing occurs and how to avoid or minimize it?
TIA
70-200 f2.8 VRII @ 112 mm and f7.1; ISO 800, 1/60 sec.
85mm f1.4G @ 85 mm and f1.4; ISO 200, 1/320 sec
I was very surprised to see the severe purple fringing in the 85 mm f1.4G but understand that wide open this sort of thing can happen. (Look at the edges of the ammonite and all the white lettering.) The shot taken with the 70-200 is stopped down to 7.1, so is an unfair comparison, but I offer it up to show what the store display really looks like.
The 85 1.4G is still there, and at a fair price ($1600 US).
First, would you be put off by the purple fringing at f1.4, or is this just one of the perils of a very fast lens?
Second...since I'm not a physicist or optical engineer...could someone knowledgeable explain why purple fringing occurs and how to avoid or minimize it?
TIA
70-200 f2.8 VRII @ 112 mm and f7.1; ISO 800, 1/60 sec.
85mm f1.4G @ 85 mm and f1.4; ISO 200, 1/320 sec