Permission for photos in someones house?

Messages
163
Name
Neil
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi I cannot go into too much detail but the company I work for took some pictures of the works completed as the customer was not happy with the standard. He is now claiming he never gave permission for these to be taken and we have broken the law is this correct?
 
Don't quote me on this, but I wouldn't have thought the client has a leg to stand on really. Considering the company was invited onto the premises to carry out work it can't really be trespassing. What is the client complaining about? Are you using them to prove the work was carried out properly, or for another reason? I know you want to be discreet, but it's hard to give advice without knowing more about the situation!
 
no we only used the photographs as the office is 300 miles from the job and they needed to know how it looked, he is only complaining that we did not ask permission first.....
 
It seems like he must be quite unhappy and in terms of customer service it may be your choice to agree to whatever it is he's asking for.

On a legal basis though, I can't see that you've done anything wrong. An image is being used to rectify issues with work that was carried out. Quite normal.

Where is he going to go with this complaint anyway? The Police are the only real option of he feels you've broken the law as there are no commercial rights involved. Can you imagine him at the police desk saying "these people came to fix a problem in my house at my request and have made a record image of the problem."
 
I don't think they're worried about it morally as they're in dispute with the customer anyway.


Steve.
 
I've been down this road.

Same idea, customer was in Scotland and the HQ was Sunderland.

I took pics for a company that had a complaint about quality of work they had carried out for this customer. The guys wife was present, she even put the lights on for me, and never said a thing about me taking pics and she understood I was working independently.

Guy comes home from work and blows a fuse. To cut a long story short he took the company to small claims, against the advice of his lawyer, and lost. Cost him £1400 in fees/costs etc. The whole saga went on for 2 years.
 
Guy comes home from work and blows a fuse.

Dodgy wiring, obviously.

More seriously, the OP's scenario is preposterous. No laws have been broken and no harm has been done. Furthermore, even if there was some transgression, what can be done about it at this stage? Sounds pretty daft to me.
 
You got the right to record your work without permission. You do not have the right to take photos outside your work without permission. You also do not have the right to use the photos for any commercial purpose without permission.

When I worked as an architect, I can take photos for the interior reconstruction or decoration without any problem. But I cann't take pictures of the landlady's bra or underwear without her permission. If I want to show how good her bra can be displayed in her bedroom, I need her permission to do so.

But if I want to use her case as an example to show to other customers as our profile, I need the agreement from the landlord.

It is hardly to say that is illegal if you took some private photos without permission while you were working in a private house. It is a moral issue, and definitely you lose your bussiness reputation. But it is not a crime. You do not have to pay any compensation.

In other hand, no matter whether the owner agree you to take photos, you need the permission to use them for commerical purposes. And the owner can stand for the claim.

So after the work of an interior design, may I take the photos of the completed work? Surely I can do so. But that always happens with the owner's aggreement.

How small was he claiming for?
 
An apology? :)

It would be nice if it was that easy. I think apologies go a long way, but when it comes to litigation conceding any fault just blows your case to bits.

You got the right to record your work without permission. You do not have the right to take photos outside your work without permission. You also do not have the right to use the photos for any commercial purpose without permission.
When I worked as an architect, I can take photos for the interior reconstruction or decoration without any problem. But I cann't take pictures of the landlady's bra or underwear without her permission. If I want to show how good her bra can be displayed in her bedroom, I need her permission to do so.

But if I want to use her case as an example to show to other customers as our profile, I need the agreement from the landlord.

It is hardly to say that is illegal if you took some private photos without permission while you were working in a private house. It is a moral issue, and definitely you lose your bussiness reputation. But it is not a crime. You do not have to pay any compensation.

In other hand, no matter whether the owner agree you to take photos, you need the permission to use them for commerical purposes. And the owner can stand for the claim.

So after the work of an interior design, may I take the photos of the completed work? Surely I can do so. But that always happens with the owner's aggreement.

How small was he claiming for?

The actual taking of photographs is rarely an illegal act. It's what you do with them that causes trouble. There is nothing specifically illegal about commercial use, it's just potentially more troublesome as there's money invloved. It's (almost) always about money at the end of the day.
 
In my opinion, recording the condition of the works to establish whether it met the standard required and what remedial works if any were needed to rectify was exactly what was required to reach a resolution.

If the photos were used for this purpose and this purpose alone, I cannot see how it can be considered anything but good practice. Clearly if they were used for promotional material to the general public, that might be considered deformation of character (assuming it was used to illustrate a 'bad' client in some way).

I guess now the photos have been taken, a decision can be made regarding the works and either remedial work is required or a personal inspection is necessary.

Perhaps moving on to the next stage quickly and assuring the client that the photos will be deleted/destroyed once the client is satisfied may shift the focus.

Good luck.
Graham
 
Hi I cannot go into too much detail but the company I work for took some pictures of the works completed as the customer was not happy with the standard. He is now claiming he never gave permission for these to be taken and we have broken the law is this correct?

No short - no.
No laws have been broken by taking those photographs.
 
Back
Top