Philip Schofield victim of copyright theft

Marcel

Kim Jong Bod
Admin
Messages
29,411
Name
Marcel
Edit My Images
Yes
LOL

OK, a very sensationalist thread title, but it does highlight a growing concern that we as a nation of photographers are familiar with......copyright theft.

Not just any copyright theft, but particularly that of newspapers using someone's photos without their permission.

Well, Philip Schofield took his brother out to The Fat Duck the other night and twittered about it.
The Daily Scum, sorry Mail, picked up on it and wrote this article

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbi...ont-really-want-Tweets-Fat-Duck-130-meal.html

Apart from being sensationalist hand wringing scum (yes I see the irony with my thread title ;)), theyve had the cheek to use his photos, and credit them to the image hosting website they stole them from.

So it just goes to show, that either they employ really stupid people who have no idea that you can't just copy images from anywhere for free, or they think they're above copyright laws.
 
Nothing to do with the pics Marcel - but Tim did my wedding disco as a present for us when I retired from Dj- ing, smashing lad :thumbs::thumbs:
 
Apart from being sensationalist hand wringing scum (yes I see the irony with my thread title ;)), .

Funniest & most exciting part of the whole post including the linked IMO :D
 
What are twitpics T&Cs for uploading?

I can pretty much guarantee that they don't claim copyright on your content. They might reserve the right to use it elsewhere but they can't claim copyright over the images.

Taken from their T&Cs

By uploading your photos to Twitpic you give Twitpic permission to use or distribute your photos on Twitpic.com or affiliated sites

All images uploaded are copyright © their respective owners
 
Without checking, that's the answer I assumed KayJay. If they had claimed copyright, then as a fervent twitter user I would have heard about it by now tbh.
 
Without checking, that's the answer I assumed KayJay. If they had claimed copyright, then as a fervent twitter user I would have heard about it by now tbh.

Same here, quoted the T&C for the benefit of JL.

Most social networking sites adopt the same line.
 
Is it theft when you are taking something of no value that nobody cares about?

Being more serious, chances are that when you photocopy something, you are breaching copyright. But we all do it. So where do your draw the line?
 
I have mixed feelings on Copyright laws. Those who need their support most generally do not get it as they can't afford the costs to bring it to court. Whereas huge corporations representing artists who are already rolling in it can afford to pursue even the most minor infringements.

I have had the dubious "pleasure" of dealing with media/copyright lawyers - I can't elaborate for legal reasons :D
 
If I went out for a meal with someone and they sat there, listening to an iPOD and twittering, I would leave. How rude!
 
Dave, the ipod was part of the meal ;)
It was a Heston Blumenthal meal. You listen to sounds of the ocean while eating it :p

Something like that anyway.

Hoppy, there's a difference between personal use and commercial use.
For example, I wouldn't give two hoots if someone nicked a websized shot of mine to use as a wallpaper on their computer.
But use it in a professional capacity and I'll be not best pleased.


More serious - Marcel reads the Daily Mail :eek:

Dear god no. Saw the link on twitter.
The only time I read the tabloids now is looking at the jubblies while I wait in the chinese takeaway.
 
I don't get it

what was the point of the article??? Schofield went out for dinner...treated his brother for a birthday celebration...
the daily mail writer really took offense to philip schofield spending MONEY ON FOOD! HAVING DINNER OUT!!! OMG.

what a tool
 
Hoppy, there's a difference between personal use and commercial use.

For example, I wouldn't give two hoots if someone nicked a websized shot of mine to use as a wallpaper on their computer.

But use it in a professional capacity and I'll be not best pleased.

I know what you mean, but that is a very subjective judgement, and extremely difficult to legislate for. Personally, I don't give a stuff about what the Daily Mail has done, even if they do not in fact have any permission. And I don't suppose anyone directly concerned does either. Clearly, you do, and that's equally fine by me, but if you adopt that level of sensitivity then life must be frequently uncomfortble on the net.

And on the personal/professional/commercial thing, how about I photocopy something from a book or magazine at work, and put it into a meeting report for business? Most people have done that sometime. Definite breach of copyright. Does it matter? What should be done about it?

I just think that legislation is so difficult, and actually unnecessary. Sure, a few people get upset from time to time, but, as with innocently photocopying stuff, there's usually no harm done. Usually some misplaced indignation.

It is only when money is invloved somewhere along the line that the law needs to be invoked, and in those instances it is usually quite clear whose Rights are what, and who is liable.

BTW, I attended a commercial seminar once and was handed a set of papers including a magazine article I'd written. I was well chuffed :D
 
If I went out for a meal with someone and they sat there, listening to an iPOD and twittering, I would leave. How rude!

I was just thinking that :lol:
 
Dave, the ipod was part of the meal ;)
It was a Heston Blumenthal meal. You listen to sounds of the ocean while eating it :p

Something like that anyway.

Hoppy, there's a difference between personal use and commercial use.
For example, I wouldn't give two hoots if someone nicked a websized shot of mine to use as a wallpaper on their computer.
But use it in a professional capacity and I'll be not best pleased.




Dear god no. Saw the link on twitter.
The only time I read the tabloids now is looking at the jubblies while I wait in the chinese takeaway.

Ah I see now

But still twittering while having a meal should be a no-no too
 
Back
Top