Photo retouching and Ralph Lauren

KayJay

Give us a Tena
Messages
5,783
Edit My Images
Yes
Take a look at this.

Last month, Xeni blogged about the photoshop disaster that is this Ralph Lauren advertisement, in which a model's proportions appear to have been altered to give her an impossibly skinny body ("Dude, her head's bigger than her pelvis"). Naturally, Xeni reproduced the ad in question. This is classic fair use: a reproduction "for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting," etc.

Respect to the blog for fighting the legal battle. That image is shocking and the fact that RL want it down proves it.
 
What a spectacular own goal on the part of RL, classic fail.
 
Photoshop Disasters posted the Ralph Lauren statement.

"For over 42 years we have built a brand based on quality and integrity. After further investigation, we have learned that we are responsible for the poor imaging and retouching that resulted in a very distorted image of a woman's body. We have addressed the problem and going forward will take every precaution to ensure that the caliber of our artwork represents our brand appropriately."

I particularly like the reference to the Streisand effect which I hadn't heard of before.

Interesting and amusing read. Thanks for the heads-up!

-H
 
They've accepted responsibility and 'sort of' apologised for the weird processing... :eek: ...apparently... :naughty:


But what about that poor model... :shrug: ...does she not deserve any compensation for being made to look that ridiculous... :suspect:


Sad world we live in... :thinking:





:p
 
Oh boy, that's so much worse than the Armani - Posh Spice incident. What the flippin flip were they thinking :lol:
 
it works..we are talking about it...
 
Good grief. To think some idiot got paid to do that. Aside from the moralities, it's a shockingly bad bit of editing.
 
For over 42 years we have built a brand based on quality and integrity. After further investigation, we have learned that we are responsible for the poor imaging and retouching that resulted in a very distorted image of a woman's body. We have addressed the problem and going forward will take every precaution to ensure that the caliber of our artwork represents our brand appropriately."

If RL had any integrity they would have a complete and total ban on photoshoping models and show us how they really look in the clothes they are trying to sell.
 
Good grief. To think some idiot got paid to do that. Aside from the moralities, it's a shockingly bad bit of editing.

I have a sneaking suspicion he/she may not be paid much longer, I doubt the ad company or whoevers very popular.
 
it works..we are talking about it...

Of course it works. I'm not going to ignore it just because I don't want it to work...

This is something that needs discussed. Young women, and boys for that matter, grow up looking at things like this thinking that they way these models look is normal and that they should look like that too. It's time these fashion houses were confronted with how they distort reality to sell clothes and magazines. The photographer who took those shots needs to look at themselves too. Allowing your work to be used like that is questionable, in my opinion.
 
Of course it works. I'm not going to ignore it just because I don't want it to work...

This is something that needs discussed. Young women, and boys for that matter, grow up looking at things like this thinking that they way these models look is normal and that they should look like that too. It's time these fashion houses were confronted with how they distort reality to sell clothes and magazines. The photographer who took those shots needs to look at themselves too. Allowing your work to be used like that is questionable, in my opinion.


:agree:
 
Of course it works. I'm not going to ignore it just because I don't want it to work...

This is something that needs discussed. Young women, and boys for that matter, grow up looking at things like this thinking that they way these models look is normal and that they should look like that too. It's time these fashion houses were confronted with how they distort reality to sell clothes and magazines. The photographer who took those shots needs to look at themselves too. Allowing your work to be used like that is questionable, in my opinion.

2 of my nieces are in their teens. Love them to bits but they both have very negative body images for themselves. One os overweight and very tall, so she hides her weight well, but is fairly self concious about it. Despite helping her understand what clothes suit her shape, obviously as a typical teen, she wants to wear the latest fashions like her friends, regardless of whether or not she looks good in them, which makes her feel more self concious.

Her sister struggles to fill a size 6. She is painfully thin and from the side, well, there's not much there TBH, a 2-3 inch line and a head ontop, yet she worries that she will look fat in clothes.

They, IMHO, are the real victims of the fashion industry, the influenced young people who strive to be like models or think they're not pretty enough because they'e not models. Both girls are incredibly pretty, but don't realise it and it's incredibly sad.
 
Back
Top