Photographs of people without their permission

joescrivens

Suspended / Banned
Messages
15,052
Name
Joe
Edit My Images
Yes
So whats the law regarding taking someones photograph and using it in a product without their consent. I understand that in a public place nobody can stop you taking their photograph legally, but what are you allowed to do with said photograph?

Anything? Nothing?

I know there was a court case about a guy in NY who tried to sue an artist but it was thrown out under the constitution of artistic merit, but the guy was still making money from his art right?

I think I heard that you cannot use the likeness for advertising but what about education. Would I legally be able to take a photograph of someone and use it in an education product if there were no advertising?
 
If it's a recognisable image of someone (an individual or couple), then I'd still be uncomfortable with what you describe and the reason that most companies and education authorities use models (often unpaid) for this kind of thing...unless it's something obviously unreproducable, like a street-scene or crowd shot, for example.

Imagine you took a photo of a seemingly-loving couple and it turned out to be one or both of them were married to someone else - even though the situation may have been totally innocent, the appearance of intimacy in your (fictious in this case) image, might mean they could possibly sue you for causing any future problems by having published that image without consent and out of context.

If you think your image is going to be used for anything other than purley artistic purposes, then just ask permission.
 
From what I understand you cannot use an image commercially (for payment) without the persons permission but you can use it to promote your talant i.e. sample image.

I'm just waiting in the corner for someone to shout me down now.:gag:
 
Broadly speaking for editorial use you are fine, advertising then you may need a model release.
 
You are allowed to sell the image as a print.. (for example to the person in the picture or family member or stalker) which some people get confused as a commercial usage...
 
Hi. That's my understanding too. If there's someone in a picture, but not a closeup, then its fine for editorial use. If they're clearly identifyable, the main subject, then you need a model release to use 'commercially' - i.e. in advertising etc.
 
Hi. That's my understanding too. If there's someone in a picture, but not a closeup, then its fine for editorial use. .

eeerm sorry but no.. you can use a close up for editorial use without a model release
 
If it's a recognisable image of someone (an individual or couple), then I'd still be uncomfortable with what you describe and the reason that most companies and education authorities use models (often unpaid) for this kind of thing...unless it's something obviously unreproducable, like a street-scene or crowd shot, for example.

Imagine you took a photo of a seemingly-loving couple and it turned out to be one or both of them were married to someone else - even though the situation may have been totally innocent, the appearance of intimacy in your (fictious in this case) image, might mean they could possibly sue you for causing any future problems by having published that image without consent and out of context.

If you think your image is going to be used for anything other than purley artistic purposes, then just ask permission.

yeah i can see instances like this being a problem, but what about like you say a crowd.

for example lets say I took a photo of a game of football and two players in a tackle where you could see their faces.

The content wouldn't be for sale but it would be considered value added to a product. So you buy a piece of hardware and then there is a website with free content to use on said hardware
 
There are no legal requirements for model releases in the UK.

You can use any photo of anyone (broadly speaking) for any use. HOWEVER, if you do this, depending on the product/usage of it, you could end up getting sued for slander/defamation of character, libel and all those kind of laws.

None of the major stock agencies will take any photos of people without a model release, unless it's purely for editorial purposes.

I would strongly recommend not using any image for commercial use that contains a single (i.e. main) subject without a model release that says what you can and cannot do with that image.

The whole field of photography gets quite murky when it comes to using people in commercial / editorial images, and I would definatly get a model release wherever possible, before considering using anything for anything commercial (editorial content is slightly different)

That's my understanding of the subject, anyway. It's not gospel, it might not even be right! I'm happy to be told I'm wrong, because I don't want to get sued either :D
 
can someone explain to me where editorial starts and stops. Does editorial just mean news?
 
can someone explain to me where editorial starts and stops. Does editorial just mean news?

No.. But editorial doesnt mean used in an advert to sell something.. thats commercail.. Mattyh post above would ahve been good if he kept to commercial and not used editorial as well ...IMHO :)
 
There are no legal requirements for model releases in the UK.

You can use any photo of anyone (broadly speaking) for any use. HOWEVER, if you do this, depending on the product/usage of it, you could end up getting sued for slander/defamation of character, libel and all those kind of laws.

None of the major stock agencies will take any photos of people without a model release, unless it's purely for editorial purposes.

I would strongly recommend not using any image for commercial use that contains a single (i.e. main) subject without a model release that says what you can and cannot do with that image.

The whole field of photography gets quite murky when it comes to using people in commercial / editorial images, and I would definatly get a model release wherever possible, before considering using anything for anything commercial (editorial content is slightly different)

That's my understanding of the subject, anyway. It's not gospel, it might not even be right! I'm happy to be told I'm wrong, because I don't want to get sued either :D

Pretty much my understanding also...
UK and Europe do not require a model release by law as there is no legal framework for enforcing them - International Copyright legislation as it applies to the intellectual copyright holder overrules them anyway.
In the USA they are a legal requirement, hence the insistance by many stock agencies for their use.

Joe: a football match is a slightly different scenario to the one I mentioned as an example - I was assuming a 'candid' shot with the subject(s) unaware of having been photographed.
A public sporting event is slightly more open as there is a reasonable expectation that it might be recorded by spectators.
 
No.. But editorial doesnt mean used in an advert to sell something.. thats commercail.. Mattyh post above would ahve been good if he kept to commercial and not used editorial as well ...IMHO :)

ok, so I assume educational content for sale is considered commercial.

How about education content given for free.

For example, lets say a teacher took a photograph of a person used it in a lesson and then posted it on the web to share as part of said lesson - editorial? commercial? neither?
 
Like I said. Murky, at best.

I'd get an image with a model release and call it a day at that, personally

murky eh.

Just trying to fathom how a teacher would go about getting a model release, it's not like they have access to a legal department to draw one up for them
 
ok, so I assume educational content for sale is considered commercial.

How about education content given for free.

For example, lets say a teacher took a photograph of a person used it in a lesson and then posted it on the web to share as part of said lesson - editorial? commercial? neither?

free or paid for doesnt matter.. again thats not the commerciaol bit.. if its used to advertise somehting a product or a education course anything commercial then its being used commercialy... wether its gained freely or sold for the purpose means nothing... its the usage..

As for educational content.. no idea :)
 
For example, lets say a teacher took a photograph of a person used it in a lesson and then posted it on the web to share as part of said lesson - editorial? commercial? neither?

I've got a suspicion you have a very deifinite set of circumstances in mind..

Who is the person? a member of the class, someone else posing, a street candid?

What is the lesson being taught and what is the purpose for using the photograph?

How is the lesson to be shared? open access internet or a closed acces intranet/portal?


I think from the legal point of view it's been fairly clearlt stated there should be no issue around model release whatever the circumstance (unless you later tried to sell the teaching materials).. but is there something we don't know?

Your biggest risk is if the photograph is being used in a way that mis-represents the subject.. for instance using a generic street candid of a young person in a hoodie to illustrate the perils of crack addiction..
 
Hi. I do some volunteer photographic work for a charity and they use the images in their publications and publicity. Before any event, the charity has cleared with the participants that there will be a photographer and gets their permission (or otherwise) to be included. That means I don't have to worry about model releases.
 
free or paid for doesnt matter.. again thats not the commerciaol bit.. if its used to advertise somehting a product or a education course anything commercial then its being used commercialy... wether its gained freely or sold for the purpose means nothing... its the usage..

As for educational content.. no idea :)

No advertising at all on any of the content, does that help?
 
No advertising at all on any of the content, does that help?

i would be guessing... what i have replied i know for sure.. I am simply not sure with the whole education bit.. education isnt free (someone gets paid) so is it commercial...dunno mate :)
 
I've got a suspicion you have a very deifinite set of circumstances in mind..

Who is the person? a member of the class, someone else posing, a street candid?

What is the lesson being taught and what is the purpose for using the photograph?

How is the lesson to be shared? open access internet or a closed acces intranet/portal?


I think from the legal point of view it's been fairly clearlt stated there should be no issue around model release whatever the circumstance (unless you later tried to sell the teaching materials).. but is there something we don't know?

Your biggest risk is if the photograph is being used in a way that mis-represents the subject.. for instance using a generic street candid of a young person in a hoodie to illustrate the perils of crack addiction..

Actually the opposite, a very generic set of circumstances. There's two scenarios:

scenario 1 : I need to make content for the company I work for and I'll be taking photos to build that content. I don't yet know what the subject matter will be but some may include images of people - like playing sports for example. The content is offered for free to download separate from anything (i.e. it isn't packaged with a product) but it is used on a product. The teacher downloads said content and uses it on their hardware.

Scenario 2 : The same website allows teachers to upload their own content to share with other teachers. Teachers could be out taking photographs and using them in their content and I don't know what photographs they would be taking, could contain people. These would be available for free for other teachers to download and use.

No advertising on any of the content and no fee on any of the content or the service
 
Actually the opposite, a very generic set of circumstances. There's two scenarios:

scenario 1 : I need to make content for the company I work for and I'll be taking photos to build that content. I don't yet know what the subject matter will be but some may include images of people - like playing sports for example. The content is offered for free to download separate from anything (i.e. it isn't packaged with a product) but it is used on a product. The teacher downloads said content and uses it on their hardware.

Scenario 2 : The same website allows teachers to upload their own content to share with other teachers. Teachers could be out taking photographs and using them in their content and I don't know what photographs they would be taking, could contain people. These would be available for free for other teachers to download and use.

No advertising on any of the content and no fee on any of the content or the service

scenario 1: I'd call it commercial usage, there's no relevance to whether any advertising is attached or even whether the product is free or paid for. If I were shooting this I'd ensure a release was in place.

Scenario2: Also commercial usage, But - it's common for schools to have parents sign a waiver that says photographs may be taken of them during school activities and used to promote the school -i.e. a 'model release' is already in place.

I love the mish-mash that the law has created here. Most people that actually know the law start with 'Model Releases aren't required in the UK as they have no actual legal standing'. Then end with 'under such and such circumstances you need to get a signed release'. It's absolutely ludicrous - but it's how it is.

You'd think that whilst the UK government were rewriting copyright legislation and trying to tidy stuff up, they'd be sorting this out. However, between existing UK laws, EU laws and trying to ensure free trade with the likes of the US, UK legislature has no chance of simplifying anything. It's the nature of the shrinking planet.:bonk:
 
I guess I'm talking about teachers taking photos not in school of kids, I wonder how said teachers are in a position to get model releases in this case
 
can someone explain to me where editorial starts and stops. Does editorial just mean news?

There is no formal distinction between editorial and commercial, even though it's often cited (editorial is commercial use anyway :shrug: ).

The thing is mis-representation, as mentioned above. While there is a lot of freedom in the use of pictures of people in public places, you cannot try and falsely associate them with a product. And if there is money involved, that's unfair exploitation. You could get hit with a variety of civil actions.

A model release (download one) is not a legal document, just good evidence that the subject knew what might happen to the images and was agreeable to that.

There is a million miles between what you can do legally (eg what the paparazzi get away with) and what you can do morally. The basic rule is don't upset anybody (though some folks are very easily upset).
 
I guess I'm talking about teachers taking photos not in school of kids, I wonder how said teachers are in a position to get model releases in this case

That'd only be counter to my point if:
A photographer who happened to be a teacher took photo's of children completely out of the context of their education. If the kids are completely outside of school then it's irrelevant whether the photographer happens to be a teacher and therefore I'd fall back on the other guidelines regarding releases.

However if the teacher is photographing children on a school trip or during a sporting event connected to the school then surely my original response covers it?
 
That'd only be counter to my point if:
A photographer who happened to be a teacher took photo's of children completely out of the context of their education. If the kids are completely outside of school then it's irrelevant whether the photographer happens to be a teacher and therefore I'd fall back on the other guidelines regarding releases.

However if the teacher is photographing children on a school trip or during a sporting event connected to the school then surely my original response covers it?

Sorry, I guess I wasn't being clear, I meant not of children at all. I'm trying to find out what due diligence we as a company might need to do if a teacher submits a file that contains a photo of anyone, children , adult, teenager, anything in a setting not in a school. Like if they took a photograph of a sporting event and used it as part of their lesson. It would be so hard for them to get model releases from members of a football team for example
 
Back
Top