Photography guidance for the police

Good News indeed :)
Now all we need to do is convince the general public that we are not all paedophiles and terrorists :eek:
 

Sadly that isn't for the police, but for the Met.

Even more sadly, the Met aren't very good at following their own guidelines when it comes to other things so don't hold out too much hope.

After all, the MPS code requires uniformed officers to wear collar numbers at all times, but as can be seen from the G20 policing they don't.

this is also going around today, though this is kent police,

http://monaxle.com/2009/07/08/section-44-in-chatham-high-street/
 
That is only his own interpretation of the police statement.
If you read the source it is less clear. and contains nothing new.

http://www.met.police.uk/about/photography.htm

:thinking:
The chap was handcuffed and put inside a police van for taking a few snaps in public.

Did you see the statement issued to him by the officers?

It reads:

Grounds: 'Prevention Of Terrorism'.

EDIT, Sorry Terry, your referring to the first link. My mistake.
 
:thinking:
The chap was handcuffed and put inside a police van for taking a few snaps in public.

Did you see the statement issued to him by the officers?

It reads:

Grounds: 'Prevention Of Terrorism'.

I was answering the op... not the later post that crossed mine.
 
Sadly that isn't for the police, but for the Met.

Even more sadly, the Met aren't very good at following their own guidelines when it comes to other things so don't hold out too much hope.

After all, the MPS code requires uniformed officers to wear collar numbers at all times, but as can be seen from the G20 policing they don't.

this is also going around today, though this is kent police,

http://monaxle.com/2009/07/08/section-44-in-chatham-high-street/

My first thought, why would anyone want to take pictures in Chatham High Street, not that interesting a place really but then I read it and saw that he wants to get photos of the flyover going
My second thought, how the hell did he get close enough, takes me ages to get near Chatham for work :lol: because the flyover is being demolished!
 
To think there are people out there who still massively over exegerate a problem that has effect hardly anyone!

By the time it affects everyone it will be too late.

if you watch video footage of the G20 you will see that the press were instructed to leave an area while the police dealt with a situation. The situation was dealing with the demonstrators, and they didn't want their actions recorded.

MPS later apologised for incorrectly instructing the press in this way, but by then whatever they did had gone unrecorded.
 
By the time it affects everyone it will be too late.

if you watch video footage of the G20 you will see that the press were instructed to leave an area while the police dealt with a situation. The situation was dealing with the demonstrators, and they didn't want their actions recorded.

MPS later apologised for incorrectly instructing the press in this way, but by then whatever they did had gone unrecorded.

Again your talking about a statistically insignificant incident thousands and thousands of people take pictures in London every day, if you look at incidents outside London they are practically non-existent. I'm just getting a bit sick of people passing off the idea than everyone who takes pictures on the local highstreet will be harrassed by the police, it's just not true.
 
Again your talking about a statistically insignificant incident thousands and thousands of people take pictures in London every day, if you look at incidents outside London they are practically non-existent. I'm just getting a bit sick of people passing off the idea than everyone who takes pictures on the local highstreet will be harrassed by the police, it's just not true.

You obviously don't get out enough ;)
 
Again your talking about a statistically insignificant incident thousands and thousands of people take pictures in London every day, if you look at incidents outside London they are practically non-existent. I'm just getting a bit sick of people passing off the idea than everyone who takes pictures on the local highstreet will be harrassed by the police, it's just not true.

Just because the problem hasn’t affected you yet, doesn’t mean the problem isn’t there.

I’ve been stopped a fair few times in London.
 
To think there are people out there who still massively over exegerate a problem that has effect hardly anyone!

:lol: Massively over exaggerate? Hardly anyone?

Flash has it bang on. Or at least maybe you should read more.

I'm just getting a bit sick of people passing off the idea than everyone who takes pictures on the local highstreet will be harrassed by the police, it's just not true.

If you live in the ass end of nowhere then the chances are slim.

I get sick of people who don't read much and still argue the toss.

http://monaxle.com/2009/07/08/section-44-in-chatham-high-street/

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/7351252.stm

http://www.photographyblog.com/news/pblog_editor_stopped_and_searched/

http://www.thisislocallondon.co.uk/news/topstories/4025552.CROYDON__MP_stopped_by_cops_for_taking_pictures_of_cycle_path/

There's a truck load more, I really can't be arsed posting them all.

Simply read a little more, there's a monumental Government benefit to controlling or restricting photography in public places, cities are the more relevant target.

Just look at all the G20 photo's and video footage.
 
i live in the ass end of no where and have been stopped. but then Cattrick is not the place to trying to take pictures. but where i am now it's just silly....have stoped now trying, after i got stopped in our local nature park. but hay ho
 
I'm quite fortunate i haven't seen a copper on the streets round here since 1978:lol: they all seem to be sat in laybys with speed cameras.
Seriously though i do think judging by what i read that all police forces should be re educated concerning the law on photography, i understand the need for vigilance in this day and age but things are getting out of hand.
Perhaps a lot of officers are actually more concerned about you having pictures of them doing something they shouldnt be rather you being involved with terrorism.( like the one i saw fly tipping in widnes last year, god i wish had my camera with me then).
 
In view of the above, I'm buggered. I've a 10 am meet and walkabout Friday with a community safety officer and local plod. Need to take pics (& notes) of several locations, as by the time everyone involved agrees to go ahead I'll have forgotten all the mundane details. May leave the p&s in the office and take a proper camera and big fo lens just to see what if any reaction it gets. Just too possibly make matters worse, I'll also be kitted out in leathers as I'm taking the bike weather permitting. But like as not nothing will happen.
 
:lol: Massively over exaggerate? Hardly anyone?

-snip-

I can't be bothered spending to long on this so my figures are a bit slapdash.

In 2007 canon sold 146,000 400D's so that means for there to be a statistically relevant figure of say 1% of users being obstructed by the police you would need to find 1460 reported incidents. Now that would cover one model of camera 2 years ago, DSLR sales have rocketed since then so the number of incidents required for a statistically relevant figure to be reached is huge and thats just looking at new DSLR's ignoring compacts and people shooting 50 year old film cameras.

I know and accept that there is an issue particularly in London, but the majority of photographers go about there daily business without ever being approached by a police officer. I don't live in the back end of nowhere I live in Britains fourth biggest city and have never been approached in a negative way by anyone.

Alot of people on this and other websites have no perspective on this issue what so ever.
 
That's the only part of you post that makes any sense :shrug:



Right.

No, what he says is correct, in a country with 60M odd inhabitants the number being stopped by Police for taking photos is statistically insignificant.

However that isn't the best way to establish the importance of any misuse of legislation by the police.

After all, the number of people killed by the police isn't making much of a dent in the population, but it is still important.
 
No, what he says is correct, in a country with 60M odd inhabitants the number being stopped by Police for taking photos is statistically insignificant.

However that isn't the best way to establish the importance of any misuse of legislation by the police.

After all, the number of people killed by the police isn't making much of a dent in the population, but it is still important.

Which is why comparing the amount of camera's sold (or the amount of inhabitants) to the reports of incidents is an irrelevant statistic in respect of the issue. :D

Denial of a problem that continues to re-occur more frequently as time goes by or failure to recognize a problem until the 'statistics' are significant enough in comparison with the amount of inhabitants, is quite typical of the UK (before anyone starts, I am British).

They just can't see that somethings cannot be fixed once broken.

It's not over exaggeration or hysteria. Photography and videography in public places will become more restricted and the incidents we see much more of these days will spread to smaller cities.

Regardless of the comparisons with camera sales or ownership, there have been extremely unacceptable incidents and they continue to occur.

We need the police, but it's not the police themselves that are the source of the problem but the code that they must follow.

Wait until the new bill of 'Equality' is passed and we'll see about these figures and 'statistics' that folk like a1ex2001 put their faith and trust in so blindly.
 
I think on the whole the police (and the Met) are cool with photographers. I've been stopped several times and it's always been by the Hobby Bobbies!
 
I think on the whole the police (and the Met) are cool with photographers. I've been stopped several times and it's always been by the Hobby Bobbies!

Hobby Bobbies or PCSOs?

I think it more likely to be PCSOs, the traffic version, the aptly named HATOs are just as bad at overstepping the mark.
 
^^ Yes, that's what I meant, PCSOs.

I've had my tripod up in the middle of Bishopsgate road at 6pm before with police passing me and they do not bat an eyelid. Any passing PCSO will always stop if they actually see me photographing something.
 
I think on the whole the police (and the Met) are cool with photographers. I've been stopped several times and it's always been by the Hobby Bobbies!

Hobby Bobbies, thats classic lol.

Now I know it's ok to get pictures of cops, I'm gonna start snapping them again, I'll wait to be stopped then show them those MET guidlines.....muhahahahahaha.
 
^^ Yes, that's what I meant, PCSOs.

That's what I thought, please don't tar the Specials with the same brush. They have been providing a very useful service for years, long before this Government invented Policing on the cheap, and that's really where the rot has set in.
 
Whenever I've had occasion to be photographing in a public place (in civilian clothes, I might add), I've never had any dramas. If entering a public or privately-owned public bulding, I identify myself to the security staff at the outset and explain what I'm doing - if special permissions are needed then I seek to obtain them in advance.

For a laugh (?!!) I went to a couple of the anti-war protests in London a while back to hone my street-skills - first order of business was to identify myself (NOT using my Military ID, but using my driver's licence) to a senior officer (pips on shoulders, scrambled egg on hat-peak), explaining my intentions and the use to which the images would be put. After that, no dramas - they all have radios and do talk to one another. A simple nod and a smile serves to reassure most officers that you're not up to no-good.

It all comes down to preparation - photography isn't just about the image-taking - planning and preparation play as big, if not a bigger part too...
 
We need the police, but it's not the police themselves that are the source of the problem but the code that they must follow.

I agree.
Although to me its the implication of the need for the code thats the re-herring.


----

I hope its a good documentary from Channel 4 next week.

The litte just about sums up the problem for me.

From True Stories.
'Taking Liberties' tues 14th 10pm ...more on more4.

:thumbs::thumbs::thumbs:
 
That's what I thought, please don't tar the Specials with the same brush. They have been providing a very useful service for years, long before this Government invented Policing on the cheap, and that's really where the rot has set in.

Specials = Massive respect, doing the job as a Volunteer
PSCO's = Cost the same as a proper bobby on the beat but are completely powerless, waste of money.
 
Unfortunately the police are now just an arm of the state and are as distant from the public they serve as the planet Mars. The ‘radicalisation’ of the Police started under the premiership of Margret Thatcher who used them to break the unions and governments of all persuasions since then have used policing by ‘force’ instead of consent .
If some brave soul within the Police themselves does not put a stop to this erosion of trust and challenge their political masters, then it will matter not a jot how much body armour, batons or CS spray they have the public massively outnumber them ,and we are getting angrier and angrier.
Whether it is photographers being arrested on trumped up charges, Innocent people being shot or killed, or police officers driving like maniacs and getting away with it , the public perception is now one law for us one law for them.
 
I agree.
Although to me its the implication of the need for the code thats the re-herring.

Good point.

I hope its a good documentary from Channel 4 next week.

The litte just about sums up the problem for me.

From True Stories.
'Taking Liberties' tues 14th 10pm ...more on more4.

That looks very interesting, Channel 4's docs are just about the only thing I miss about TV over here. Let me know what you think :thumbs:
 
Back
Top