Photojournalist arrested for taking pictures gets compensation

Messages
5,864
Edit My Images
No
Jules Mattsson, a respected committee member of NUJ Photo London Branch, has received compensation and received a formal apology from the metropolitan police commission years after this incident, in which the arresting officer told him to stop "running round acting silly, being stupid and gay"

http://www.bindmans.com/index.php?id=1107

Jules recorded most of the confrontation on his phone. He was photographing a parade, and the conversation ended when the arresting officer said “You know what, I consider you a threat under the Terrorism Act young man. I’ve had enough.”

A great victory for photographer's rights.
 
Jules Mattsson, a respected committee member of NUJ Photo London Branch, has received compensation and received a formal apology from the metropolitan police commission years after this incident, in which the arresting officer told him to stop "running round acting silly, being stupid and gay"

http://www.bindmans.com/index.php?id=1107

Jules recorded most of the confrontation on his phone. He was photographing a parade, and the conversation ended when the arresting officer said “You know what, I consider you a threat under the Terrorism Act young man. I’ve had enough.”

A great victory for photographer's rights.

Is it not a victory for anybody's rights, not just a photographer?
 
Good to hear.

But... What are "photographers rights"? What legislation has been passed that gives photographers specific rights? I keep hearing his phrase...
 
Is it not a victory for anybody's rights, not just a photographer?

Despite his age, the article refers to a journalist taking photographs (I believe I saw the footage sometime back) so I'd say it is to do with photographer's rights (and good on him!)
 
We dont have "specific" rights, but the point stands that we keep getting situations crop up where photographers are threatened with the Terrorism Act. So while we dont have specific rights compared to Joe Public, we have a right to be allowed to shoot without being labelled as terrorists!
 
Had this story been about a non-NUJ member or even a non-member of the press would this have gone down any differently?

They are citing there that the police aren't allowed to supress the press, fair enough, but do they have the right to stop any member of the public taking photos of a very public parade? Surely I'd suggest not?

I'd say that there is nothing in here to be happy about if you aren't a Press card carrying journo...
 
Had this story been about a non-NUJ member or even a non-member of the press would this have gone down any differently?

They are citing there that the police aren't allowed to supress the press, fair enough, but do they have the right to stop any member of the public taking photos of a very public parade? Surely I'd suggest not?

I'd say that there is nothing in here to be happy about if you aren't a Press card carrying journo...

No, the police have no powers per se to prevent anyone taking pictures in a public place. The press have no special freedoms that are not open to others. A press card makes no legal difference as to what you can and cannot shoot.
 
Is it not a victory for anybody's rights, not just a photographer?

Good to hear.

But... What are "photographers rights"? What legislation has been passed that gives photographers specific rights? I keep hearing his phrase...

yep, my bad. You are correct, there are no 'specific' rights.

Excellent news. No mention of the inspector being disciplined?

nope.
 
Last edited:
No, the police have no powers per se to prevent anyone taking pictures in a public place. The press have no special freedoms that are not open to others. A press card makes no legal difference as to what you can and cannot shoot.

I know... which is the point I am making.

They fought and won this case on the basis of suppression of the press, not just being 'orrid to law abiding citizens.
 
I know... which is the point I am making.

They fought and won this case on the basis of suppression of the press, not just being 'orrid to law abiding citizens.

I take your point, but the case was as much about unlawful detention and the misuse of police powers as the right to report. Take the NUJ element out of the story and the case would have run in pretty much the same way.
 
Good to hear.

But... What are "photographers rights"? What legislation has been passed that gives photographers specific rights? I keep hearing his phrase...

Understand,but because this is a photographer forum,people are going to be talking about what effect them as photographers :)
 
The worst thing is the Inspector knew he was being recorded and still carried on acting stupidly. You always know in these videos when the question is asked 'under what law officer?' and there is no answer the police will be paying out compensation in a few months time.
 
The words 'precocious' and 'upstart' spring to mind, although if he's working within the law then the police should know better....

:D .......... I think our Police should be allowed to detain all precocious upstarts under the prevention of causing offence to normal people by acting like a tart act 2011... ;)
 
:D .......... I think our Police should be allowed to detain all precocious upstarts under the prevention of causing offence to normal people by acting like a tart act 2011... ;)

Especially 15-year-olds sporting top-end Nikon kit. Wonder if his mum was holding his kit bag.... :lol:
 
Considering Jules' family circumstances that comment is in rather poor taste Pat.
 
Not something I want to go into on here; it just is unfortunately! :(


Yup Jules was incredibly precocious a year ago, he's one of the first to admit that, but he was absolutely in the right and as one of the early supporters of PHNAT was standing up to a copper who was effectively bullying a young kid without any regard for the law what-so-ever, just because he thought that he could get away with it.

He may come across to you guys in many ways, but from personal experience he is a bloody good photographer and one hell of a photojournalist.

By the way - that top end Nikon kit that was referred to...

...he paid for it himself from the proceeds of his press work.
 
Last edited:
Mark - if it's not common knowledge then i wasn't to know...

I guessed by looking on his blog (there was a pic of his field kit) that this isn't just an overnight fad and that he has plowed serious cash into what he does... its just unusual to see youngsters in this position when most kids of his age are out doing more mundane things. Seeing someone so young with such a deep involvement into such adult matters isn't an everyday thing (unfortunately).

BTW, 'precocious' actually refers to an unusually advanced individual, so it's actually a compliment. I was jesting with my use of the word in that for a young lad he's certainly throwing himself into the deep end. Same with 'upstart' - more a nod to someone who's risen through the ranks quickly from humble beginnings.
 
Mark - if it's not common knowledge then i wasn't to know...

I guessed by looking on his blog (there was a pic of his field kit) that this isn't just an overnight fad and that he has plowed serious cash into what he does... its just unusual to see youngsters in this position when most kids of his age are out doing more mundane things. Seeing someone so young with such a deep involvement into such adult matters isn't an everyday thing (unfortunately).

BTW, 'precocious' actually refers to an unusually advanced individual, so it's actually a compliment. I was jesting with my use of the word in that for a young lad he's certainly throwing himself into the deep end. Same with 'upstart' - more a nod to someone who's risen through the ranks quickly from humble beginnings.

Oh Dear! :shrug:
He wants the limelight and he's got it :shrug: ...... good!
 
Last edited:
Poor taste was the wrong way of putting it - unfortunate would have been far better! :)

I completely agree with your use of precocious, and you are spot on; he is, in the proper sense of the word.

I'm probably being a bit over defensive of someone that I consider a friend, that's all! :)
 
I'm probably being a bit over defensive of someone that I consider a friend, that's all! :)

Hmmmm let me check the list... nope, can't find you... let me get a pen :lol:
 
Regardless of how precocious or not he may be or what his kit is, he fought the law and the law lost. He's set a precedent and should be applauded for that.
 
Let me look harder...

h-armstrong-roberts-hand-opening-index-card-file-box-lid-cards-filed-behind-alphabetical-tabs.jpg


Are you under "P" for photographer or "S" for subversive?.... aha! No, "T" for "Talk Photography"! :D
 
It was stated " When Mr Mattsson continued to state the lawfulness of his behaviour, the Inspector declared it was “dangerous” as he was “likely to be trampled on by soldiers” from the parade. "

If as it looks to me he was running in front of the soldiers do the police not have the right to tell him to keep out of the way?, stay on the side lines.
 
ok, "as it looks to me"

where?

I mean if you can gimme a link to a shot where I might have a remote possibility of agreeing with you then you're in for a chance, if not, then you're talking out your bum surely?

Or was this at Tienanmen square ???
 
ok, "as it looks to me"

where?

I mean if you can gimme a link to a shot where I might have a remote possibility of agreeing with you then you're in for a chance, if not, then you're talking out your bum surely?

Or was this at Tienanmen square ???

if you read the entire article (not just the parts you want to see) you would see where I got the quote from. Read all of it http://www.bindmans.com/index.php?id=1107
 
'Gay' is a favourite playground taunt of 12-13 year olds. Does Jules look young for his age and the inspector was trying to talk to him in a language he thought he would understand, trying to talk 'street'? :D
 
I can see it now.. "senior met commander in down with the kids epic fail lolz"
 
if you read the entire article (not just the parts you want to see) you would see where I got the quote from. Read all of it http://www.bindmans.com/index.php?id=1107

I have already read the article, you imply that there's some form of evidence (picture or video) where the photographer was stood in the way of the oncoming parade.

I wasn't arguing the quote, I was arguing your point that he was in fact in the way??
 
I just listened to the audio recording and I am amazed these police officers would make such idiots of themselves. I'm surprised they didn't resign due to the shame
 
I have already read the article,
you imply that there's some form of evidence (picture or video)
where the photographer was stood in the way of the oncoming parade.

I wasn't arguing the quote, I was arguing your point that he was in fact in the way??

Ok I see where we crossed wires. When I said "It looks to me" I was meaning the report was implying he was in front of the parade with this bit

Inspector declared it was “dangerous” as he was “likely to be trampled on by soldiers” from the parade.
"

I don't think one is hardly going to get trampled on standing to the side and letting a parade pass
 
Mark...its just unusual to see youngsters in this position when most kids of his age are out doing more mundane things. Seeing someone so young with such a deep involvement into such adult matters isn't an everyday thing (unfortunately)...

*cough cough* :lol:
 
Back
Top