Picture recovery

Messages
9,006
Name
Bazza
Edit My Images
No
Amazed is all I can say. Even though I deleted the pictures from my Scandisk CF card and formatted it, using the Scandisk recovery Disc it still pulled back pictures I was sure I had got rid of.

Just goes to show that you may not have deleted what you thought you had. As formatting -bleaching via computer doesn't get rid of the data does anyone know what does?

Realspeed
 
Last edited:
You would have come across major problems had you used the card after deleting and prior to recovery by writing new data (i.e. Used it in your camera and put new images onto the card) Once the sectors that were populated by any existing (and now deleted) data/images are overwritten with new images then the original data/image is lost.

A good tip, if you ever accidentally delete images or format a card. DO NOTHING !! with it till you get to a PC and can use a recovery tool. All is not always lost. :'(
 
Last edited:
The point is I WANT to loose the existing old data and overwriting doesn't get rid of old data. I have tried the obvious and the old data remains. Should I ever for arguement sake (and I don't want to) sell the CF card, the last thing I would want is someone else being able to recover my old photos

Realspeed
 
Last edited:
Oh sorry I misinterpreted your post, still the answer I gave may be useful to someone else:lol:

The best software for your purpose is the Comodo Shredder app (part of the system cleaner program) it is free and comes bundled with other useful tools and is highly recommended by many top review sites CNET etc. I wouldn't be without it.

http://system-cleaner.comodo.com/

It completely deletes all data then overwrites it with 1s, 0s and random characters. Simple and secure.:thumbs:
 
Last edited:
I use Eraser, also a free download and recommended on CNet etc.
 
Formatting a disk does not wipe the data off it. A disk has what is called a File Address Table (the FAT in FAT32) This stores file names and the addresses at which they are stored on the disk. A quick format as done by cameras simply invalidates the entries in the FAT. Your recovery software simply tries to re-validate these.

Sandisk RecoverPro does have a "wipe media" function which will remove all files (but last time I used it, I had to take the card out and format it in a reader before the camera would recognise it).
 
At work, we used to run all old disk through software to completely wipe them before scrapping them. Now it's easier/quicker to destroy the disk with a hammer
 
Flash memory cards use a wear levelling algorithm to ensure that all parts of the memory are used equally as the card as a whole has a finite life defined by the number of write cycles. So, writing data to the card may not actually overwrite previously stored data.

To securely wipe a card or hard disk I recommend either Eraser or DBAN - they are both free and will do the job to a very high standard. :)
 
You can use any of these fine programs, or just shoot some new pics after deletion. The new pics will permanently replace the ones you have deleted. Unless you are selling on the memory card, there seems to be little point in doing this. If you are throwing it away, just drill through it and chuck it on a fire!
 
You can use any of these fine programs, or just shoot some new pics after deletion. The new pics will permanently replace the ones you have deleted. Unless you are selling on the memory card, there seems to be little point in doing this. If you are throwing it away, just drill through it and chuck it on a fire!

Erm, not necessarily they won't ;)

Wear levelling...
 
If you fill the card up the wear leveller should be defeated. Whether or not a forensic examination of the card would recover the old images is another matter.
 
If you fill the card up the wear leveller should be defeated. Whether or not a forensic examination of the card would recover the old images is another matter.

Agreed. The previous poster didn't specify filling the card, hence my comment. ;)
 
Military and law enforcement have a standard where they write the entire drive several times (I think it is 10) with random rubbish over and over to blank it. It is actually possible to recover data from a drive that has been formatted with a formatted that actually blanks each byte on the drive.
 
I was trying to remember and I thought 10 too. The ones I met write alternating 1s and 0s rather than a random pattern so you can guarantee that every location has changed at least 9 times.
 
Military and law enforcement have a standard where they write the entire drive several times (I think it is 10) with random rubbish over and over to blank it. It is actually possible to recover data from a drive that has been formatted with a formatted that actually blanks each byte on the drive.

Military and other high security drives are actually shredded at end of life these days. We use a gizmo at work that effectively folds the entire drive in two and we've also been known to pass them over a special degausser as well. :)
 
Military and other high security drives are actually shredded at end of life these days. We use a gizmo at work that effectively folds the entire drive in two and we've also been known to pass them over a special degausser as well. :)

There is a specification for erasing drives for military/home office. Yes it is not used that much because it is easier to destroy them but the fact that it exists shows that there must be some way of getting stuff back when it is written over!
 
Yep, HMG IA standard 5 although I'm fairly sure that only applies up to IL4.

It's theoretically possible to use a tunneling electron microscope to examine the platter surfaces for magnetic domain remnants although I've never heard of it actually being done. It would be expensive, time consuming and in the domain of three letter agencies :)
 
Yep, HMG IA standard 5 although I'm fairly sure that only applies up to IL4.

It's theoretically possible to use a tunneling electron microscope to examine the platter surfaces for magnetic domain remnants although I've never heard of it actually being done. It would be expensive, time consuming and in the domain of three letter agencies :)

I usually find that drilling a few holes through the drive and then hitting it with a lump hammer makes it quite difficult to read them again. :eek:
 
I usually find that drilling a few holes through the drive and then hitting it with a lump hammer makes it quite difficult to read them again. :eek:

The easiest ones are laptop drives - just smack them on a hard surface and listen to the remains of the glass platters rattle around :D
 
Back
Top