Police destroy Welwyn sledge pictures

Matblack,

whilst I agree that it is not feasible to know every aspect of the law and that the job of a police officer often involves mediating & finding a middle-way. A member of the public should never be put in the position of being threatened with arrest unless the officer is prepared to arrest someone. Whether that officer truly believed she had enough powers to arrest the newspaper reporter for an offence of voyeurism or not we will never know, but I would suggest that there were lots of people out taking photographs of revellers in the snow and she did not consider approaching them all and asking them to delete their photos or suffer being arrested, indeed, a friend of mine has had some of her shots published on the front page of that very newspaper & on its website. (This is bearing in mind that we are taking the reporter's side of things as true, of course)

An arrest or threat of arrest must be backed up by a) enough suspicion to warrant it and b) it must be proportionate to the circumstances. It can't be used in order to get a 'result' so that paperwork is saved.
 
Photographers rights are understandably way down on the list of legislation a copper should be expected to be conversant with. Having said that they have a 2 way radio at their disposal and advice is that easy to get without wading in and bluffing their way through the situation.

Agree with the second part, not so much with the first. The Met and other big forces have engaged on a campaign of asking the public to report suspicious photography, you'd have thought they'd have trained their staff in the implications of this considering they put posters up all ver the place asking us to report suspicious activity mentioning specifically photography, and ACPO (Association of Chief Police Officers) have publicised their undertaking to train all officers in the rights of photographers. I've not seen any evidence to suggest this has been done.
 
Matblack,

whilst I agree that it is not feasible to know every aspect of the law and that the job of a police officer often involves mediating & finding a middle-way. A member of the public should never be put in the position of being threatened with arrest unless the officer is prepared to arrest someone. Whether that officer truly believed she had enough powers to arrest the newspaper reporter for an offence of voyeurism or not we will never know, but I would suggest that there were lots of people out taking photographs of revellers in the snow and she did not consider approaching them all and asking them to delete their photos or suffer being arrested, indeed, a friend of mine has had some of her shots published on the front page of that very newspaper & on its website. (This is bearing in mind that we are taking the reporter's side of things as true, of course)

An arrest or threat of arrest must be backed up by a) enough suspicion to warrant it and b) it must be proportionate to the circumstances. It can't be used in order to get a 'result' so that paperwork is saved.
We don't know that there was anyone else there at all taking photos, or that they were ignored by the officer if they were, and simply can't make that assumption.

A reporter taking pics on his mobile phone couldn't have added much credibilty to his motives in the eyes of the officer. ;)
 
Agree with the second part, not so much with the first. The Met and other big forces have engaged on a campaign of asking the public to report suspicious photography, you'd have thought they'd have trained their staff in the implications of this considering they put posters up all ver the place asking us to report suspicious activity mentioning specifically photography, and ACPO (Association of Chief Police Officers) have publicised their undertaking to train all officers in the rights of photographers. I've not seen any evidence to suggest this has been done.

I can't argue with that, but ACPO issue guidlelines to forces on varioius matters which those forces aren't bound by, and even within forces which adopt them, individual officers aren't bound by them either.

Taking speeding as an example, they say the threshold for knocking off speeders should be the prevailing limit plus 10% plus 2 mph - 35 mph in a 30 limit, but that doesn't stop people getting nicked for speeding below that , or some speed cameras being set below it.
 
We don't know that there was anyone else there at all taking photos, or that they were ignored by the officer if they were, and simply can't make that assumption.

A reporter taking pics on his mobile phone couldn't have added much credibilty to his motives in the eyes of the officer. ;)


True on the second possibly but then that's immaterial really.

On the first, no in fairness, I wasn't there, but I do know the area very well since I grew up in the town and have worked opposite the lakes for over 7 years. And judging by the photos which appeared in the local newspapers, on the regional TV and on the local press websites & the photographers I meet when in that park, I'm pretty sure there is a high liklihood that others would be taking pictures - have you been out to a park this week with a large number of people & not seen anyone with a camera?, whether they were in eyeshot at the very moment the officer was there I obvioulsy don't know. So yes, I am making an assumption

But, since I highly doubt that the police were on a fishing expedition, the reporter in question seems - from the info provided so far - to have been specifically targeted by the complainant, so there is no real reason to speak with any other photographers, especially when you know they're not really breaking the law (if they were then the officer should have taken action & not simpy asked the reporter to delete his snaps in order simply to appease the man who complained)
 
Taking speeding as an example, they say the threshold for knocking off speeders should be the prevailing limit plus 10% plus 2 mph - 35 mph in a 30 limit, but that doesn't stop people getting nicked for speeding below that , or some speed cameras being set below it.

Ah, but the difference is that all police officers know that, whether individual forces choose to ignore it, this is a matter of force policy which officers will be aware of, they're not aware of photography guidelines.
 
I've just found the cached version of the article is still available on Google:

POLICE prevented the Review from publishing pictures of people sledging in Welwyn Garden City yesterday by destroying them to stop them being used for sexual gratification.

Reporter Alex Lewis took several photos on his mobile phone near the North car park of Stanborugh Park yesterday afternoon, but called police when threatened by a man who apparently thought he was photographing his children for sexual purposes.

An officer who gave her name as Police Constable Martin told him she would confiscate the phone as evidence for a charge of "voyeurism" unless he agreed to let her delete the photographs.

According to Home Office guidelines, the offence of voyeurism, introduced by the Sexual Offences Act 2003, "covers cases where someone who has a reasonable expectation of privacy is secretly observed (or photographed or recorded).

"In all cases the observation, or intended observation, must be for the purpose of obtaining sexual gratification and must take place, or be intended to take place, without the consent of the person observed.

"The act defines a ‘private act’, in the context of this offence, as an act carried out in a place which, in the circumstances, would reasonably be expected to provide privacy, and where the victim’s genitals, buttocks or breasts are exposed or covered only in underwear; or the victim is using a lavatory; or the person is doing a sexual act that is not of a kind ordinarily done in public."

The Review has asked Hertfordshire Constabulary how photographs of fully clothed people sledging in a public park are covered by this legislation, but no response had yet been received.
 
True on the second possibly but then that's immaterial really.

On the first, no in fairness, I wasn't there, but I do know the area very well since I grew up in the town and have worked opposite the lakes for over 7 years. And judging by the photos which appeared in the local newspapers, on the regional TV and on the local press websites & the photographers I meet when in that park, I'm pretty sure there is a high liklihood that others would be taking pictures - have you been out to a park this week with a large number of people & not seen anyone with a camera?, whether they were in eyeshot at the very moment the officer was there I obvioulsy don't know. So yes, I am making an assumption

But, since I highly doubt that the police were on a fishing expedition, the reporter in question seems - from the info provided so far - to have been specifically targeted by the complainant, so there is no real reason to speak with any other photographers, especially when you know they're not really breaking the law (if they were then the officer should have taken action & not simpy asked the reporter to delete his snaps in order simply to appease the man who complained)

I'm really not defending the officer, the whole situation was sadly mishandled judging by the facts we have. and we really don't know enough about it.

Did the complainant speak to the reporter before calling the police?

Could the whole situation have been defused by a little communication if he did?

We're only getting one side of this story.
 
Ah, but the difference is that all police officers know that, whether individual forces choose to ignore it, this is a matter of force policy which officers will be aware of, they're not aware of photography guidelines.
The point I was making is that ACPO can promise the earth collectively, but in-job training and seeing officers are kept abreast of legislation is the responsibility of individual forces.
 
One of these days someone has to get lucky and run into PC Smith FRPS.
 
I think it the example situation the copper should have known the law very well as it all came under PACE and had nothing to do wth obscure guidelines on photography, child abuse, etc, etc.
 
I've just found the cached version of the article is still available on Google:
So according to that then, the complainant was actually the reporter and there had been some dialogue between himself and Mr Angry previously.
 
The point I was making is that ACPO can promise the earth collectively, but in-job training and seeing officers are kept abreast of legislation is the responsibility of individual forces.

agreed, but the problem is that the police often don't receive the training or receive it after the relevant legislation is enacted. This is the case with some pretty important legislation not just guidelines for photography.

In days gone by officers would receive classroom training on legislation before it came in, these days they get self-training computer training and then don't have the time to do it.
 
But as I said above, the incident and actions of the PC were more to do with PACE than anything else, any copper should know that stuff inside out and back to front.
 
sorry pxl8, I was answering CT

But on the subject of PACE, it is so complicated, there are quite thick books dedicated solely to it, I doubt most police officers know PACE "inside out & back to front"
 
People seem to have expectation of PC Plod as the purvayer of all knowledge in matters of civil and criminal law,

Well actually, yes I do. If police officers have the power of arrest, then I would expect them to know what law I had broken, not just make it up!! :rules:
 
sorry pxl8, I was answering CT

But on the subject of PACE, it is so complicated, there are quite thick books dedicated solely to it, I doubt most police officers know PACE "inside out & back to front"

True, but in terms of this incident the issues are basically arrest and evidence - not exactly unusual situations for a PC are they?

I bet the PC knew exactly what they were saying when they told the reporter they could either be arrested or have the images deleted. It had nothing to do with their knowledge (or lack) of obscure laws/guidelines. Had the reporter been arrested for any offence in relation to the images on the phone the PC would have known exactly how to deal with the "evidence" - that's the inside out and back to front knowledge I was referring to.
 
Back
Top