Police destroy Welwyn sledge pictures

Messages
601
Name
Richard
Edit My Images
Yes
Not seen this posted here but found this:

http://www.stalbansreview.co.uk/news/4101762.Police_destroy_Welwyn_sledge_pictures/

POLICE prevented the Review from publishing pictures of people sledging in Welwyn Garden City yesterday by destroying them to stop them being used for sexual gratification.

Reporter Alex Lewis took several photos on his mobile phone near the North car park of Stanborugh Park yesterday afternoon, but called police when threatened by a man who apparently thought he was photographing his children for sexual purposes.

An officer who gave her name as Police Constable Martin told him she would confiscate the phone as evidence for a charge of "voyeurism" unless he agreed to let her delete the photographs.

Surely this is ridiculous. If the police suspect an offence then asking someone to delete evidence of that said offence is an offence in its own right?!

IF they reckon they have good cause then surely they must seize the phone intact and untouched and preserve it as evidence. Or as i suspect they know theres not a chance in hell any offence is being committed and just power hungry and rely on intimidation to get their way.
 
I suspect the copper was using their own special brand of common sense to keep the peace and commiting an offence in the process. No doubt PC Martin will receive some informal words about the matter and it will quietly disappear.
 
The plod are covering their tracks. Now the article you linked to has been destroyed :eek:

[Google finds it in its index so I believe you weren't making it up, but it's no longer on the newspaper's site]
 
It's still in the newspapers index but the article has vanished...
blank.gif





Visit St Albans

Find out what this historic city has to offer Click here »
529438

Your St Albans
Get involved: send your photos, videos, news & views by texting us ...Click Here »

Police destroy Welwyn sledge pictures

  • 5:47pm Wednesday 4th February 2009

    44992
    44992
    44992
    44992
    44992

    POLICE prevented the Review from publishing pictures of people sledging in Welwyn Garden City by destroying them as suspected pornographic material.
 
My Brother in Law is C.I.D and i have asked him about this subject.

Here is what he told me. If any policeman/woman stops you an asks you to delete the pic's tell that if they suspect you of some wrong doing by taking said pictures ask them why they wish you to destroy evidence?

He also went onto say that i should ask them to be arrested and he would get Gary ( a family friend and leagle beagle) to come and help.

In a nut shell he would not ask anyone to delete a pic as he would then have no evidence... please excuse spelling.
 
How is it a non-story?

AFAIK the Police have no power to confiscate the phone unless they placed the reporter under arrest for a specific offence. They certainly don't have a power to require to see, let alone delete the photos. ACPO guidelines suggest that constables should not even look at the pictures as it may compromise any evidence.

gnirtS makes a good point. If it was evidence of a genuine offence being committed, then it should not have been deleted. If there was no offence committed, then there was no reason to delete them.

This is putting aside question of how pictures taken of children playing in snow could be construed as indecent, which would be the requirement for a child pornography charge under the Protection of Children Act 1978.

e2a:

Birmingham police officer 'forced press photographer to delete images' [epuk.org]

Association of Chief Police Officers: Police-Media Guidelines said:
Members of the media have a duty to take photographs and film incidents and we have no legal power or moral responsibility to prevent or restrict what they record. It is a matter for their editors to control what is published or broadcast, not the police. Once images are recorded, we have no power to delete or confiscate them without a court order, even if we think they contain damaging or useful evidence.
 
Definitely wasn't making it up. Unfortunately it wasn't up long enough to make the google cache but searching for "welwyn sledge police" turns it up as the first hit (but the link itself now doesnt exist).

No idea why its been taken away, article contained nothing incriminating (other than maybe a police officers surname which is relevant to the news and doesnt need to be protected).

The ACPO guidelines posted above clearly show what the *correct* legal position is. If only their staff actually knew them themselves rather than inventing legislation on the spot. It needs someone to stand up to them, unfortunately when the police intimidate or threaten like that its hard to get someone to do it for obvious reasons.

Id have thought there are only 2 possibilities here.
(i) the officer believes an offend has been committed. Therefore they must arrest the person and seize any potential evidence
(ii) If not the above then they have no power to demand or ask for anything at all
 
Telling the Police they are wrong, even when they blatently are, is a quick was to being arrested for breach of peace, obstruction and resisting arrest.

For many people it is easier and safer to give in than stand and make a point.

The link that musicman posted has a mini-timeline at the bottom with some other incidents pointed out
 
Maybe the reporter got sent out by the editor to get pics and story, his pics were crap (mobile phone used) and made up the story to cover his a**e :lol::lol:

Or maybe not :gag:
 
As long as the photos you are taking break no laws (Indecency, Child Protection Terrorism etc) and even if you were trespassing when you took them, then you cannot be ordered to delete them, they are your property.

If you were committing a crime by taking them they should be treated as evidence and then the equipment can and should be siezed and properly recorded.

Either way, someone got it well and truly wrong.
 
As long as the photos you are taking break no laws

Very true, only problem is as the police seem to make it up as they go along, it's going to become difficult to know what you can and cannot take photos of :shrug:
 
Telling the Police they are wrong, even when they blatently are, is a quick was to being arrested for breach of peace, obstruction and resisting arrest.

Rubbish. Verbal response to any police dosen't even come close to breach of the peace, obstruction or resisting arrest. They are all physical in nature. You have every right to verbally question and protest such actions, and I would have told Ms. Martin what I was photographing, to at least allow her to make an educated decision, and then told her to arrest me.
Your police IMO use these ploys purely as intimidation, and not strictly within the legal requirements. Their knowledge that John & Jane Doe don't know the law is what usually gives them the edge in situations like this.
I've followed a few threads on similar subjects here lately, and I just cannot believe how the police get away with this sort of behaviour just to move people along without reasonable legal justification. :nono:


Phil
Det. Chief Inspector - retired
 
The problem is that despite the government's assertion that the police will be trained on the contents of the ACPO guidelines, like so much other legislation, the vast majority of officers don't even know there is ACPO guidance, much less what it actually is as they have never been trained in it.
 
Very true, only problem is as the police seem to make it up as they go along, it's going to become difficult to know what you can and cannot take photos of :shrug:

Well educate yourself!

Have you read the latest anti terror legislation and the Met's briefing on it? I have. It's all on line and easily accessed. Child Protection Act, again easy. Tresspass laws have been covered here loads of time so have a look.

If I am going to be taking photos in public places I'll find out what I need to know myself. That way if, and when, I get stopped (and it has happened a couple of times) I'm generally on very firm ground and have asked security to go and fetch a supervisor who actually knows what they are talking about before now.

Don't be passive about it, get yourself on solid ground.:thumbs:
 
Rubbish. Verbal response to any police dosen't even come close to breach of the peace, obstruction or resisting arrest. They are all physical in nature

That's interesting Phil, so are am i right in thinking what you are saying is breach of the peach is a physical action, as this is what they threatened me with some time ago, even though nothing physical happened on my part.
 
That's interesting Phil, so are am i right in thinking what you are saying is breach of the peach is a physical action, as this is what they threatened me with some time ago, even though nothing physical happened on my part.

No, breach of the peace doesn't have to be physical. Swearing in a public place is technically breach of the peace.
 
Well educate yourself!

Mmm well actually Ali i have, but my point is if the police choose to ignore you there is'nt much you can do at the time, BUT you can once you have been arrested and spent the night in a cell and made a complaint the next day,but do you really want the hassle of all that :shrug:
 
What you may well have been threatened with is 'conduct likely to cause a breach of the peace' this means that there is not any violence or threats taking place (if there was section 4 or 5 of the public order act would be the preferred arrest since a breach of the peace is not charged and once the breach is no longer possible you shold be released/ de-arrested).

If your presence at a location and possibly what you are doing is likely to lead to some disorder then you could be arrested for conduct likely to cause a breach of the peace if you refuse to leave/desist. It doesn't have to be a physical act.

This only applies to England & Wales. Scotland is different, they can arrest for a 'breach' for just about anything not covered by any other legislation. It is far more common to be arersted for a breach of the peace north of the border.
 
Anyway i will be back later to see how this thread is going, i'm just off to watch the BILL :lol:
 
That's interesting Phil, so are am i right in thinking what you are saying is breach of the peach is a physical action, as this is what they threatened me with some time ago, even though nothing physical happened on my part.

If your actions and / or words do or did not incite violence by others, then you haven't committed any offence, unless there is reasonable cause to suspect that you have or intend to commit a crime, in which case there are legal procedures and guidelines for identification and detention pending clarification or inquiry. Upon being arrested, the arresting officer must advise you on what you are suspect of.

I found the following that should clear up the legal interpretation of breach of the peace by your courts.

"We are emboldened to say that there is a breach of the peace whenever harm is actually done or is likely to be done to a person or in his presence to his property or a person is in fear of being so harmed through an assault, an affray, a riot, unlawful assembly or other disturbance. It is for this breach of the peace when done in his presence or the reasonable apprehension of it taking place that a constable, or anyone else, may arrest an offender without warrant."

The problem, of course, is that a person exercising their right of freedom of expression may, by doing so, provoke reaction in others. It may be said that the preservation of public order should be directed at stopping those who react rather than stopping the expression of views by a person who is seeking to do so. It is a very knotty problem for the law to sort out how to deal with that question. The solution that has been arrived at was summarised in the judgment of Schiemann LJ:
(1) There must be the clearest of circumstances and a sufficiently real and present threat to the peace to justify the extreme step of depriving of his liberty a citizen who is not at the time acting unlawfully -- Foulkes.
(2) The threat must be coming from the person who is to be arrested -- Redmond-Bate.
(3) The conduct must clearly interfere with the rights of others -- Redmond-Bate.
(4) The natural consequence of the conduct must be violence from a third party -- Redmond-Bate.
(5) The violence in (4) must not be wholly unreasonable -- Redmond-Bate.
(6) The conduct of the person to be arrested must be unreasonable -- Nicol."

Breach of the peace
 
Mmm well actually Ali i have, but my point is if the police choose to ignore you there is'nt much you can do at the time, BUT you can once you have been arrested and spent the night in a cell and made a complaint the next day,but do you really want the hassle of all that :shrug:

No, what you ask is to speak to a supervisor. At the end of the day I would put up with being arrested. I'd be sat in my cell (where you can only be held for a certain length of time) adding up the kit I could buy with the compensation for false arrest :) :thumbs:
 
What about a sticky thread of the relevant laws to be used as reference as this kind of thing seems to come up quite often, and it would do us all good to know where we stood with the law.
 
There seems to be a general misconception that if the police believe you've committed an offence that they have to proceed by arrest and subsequent charge. This isn't so, they can alternatively report you for process in which case you may or may not receive a summons at a later date.

If they do take action against you by arrest or by summons then they have wide powers under legislation and Common law to seize anything which they believe to be evidence (potentially an exhibit) supporting their case.

This was another complete nonsense incident which sadly is becoming all too common, the point was well made earlier that if any offence was really thought to have been committed, then being told to destroy the evidence makes a mockery of that whole argument.
 
I can certainly understand why someone might be upset at being forced to delete their pictures and (with the idiotic press in this country) understand how a parent might be concerned about someone taking (what they think are) photos of their child.

What has almost certainly happened here is that a police officer has tried to calm things down in what she feels is the best and easiest way possible.

Does the copper know all the legislation pertaining to photography in a public place? Probably not, similarly she probably doesn't have a full understanding of the intricate laws on the taking of the eggs of wild birds; she is trying to do what police officers are employed to do which is to 'keep the peace' if this means getting two members of the public to come to a compromise without the need to involve the law then thats going to be less paperwork and everyone is going to walk away happy.

However in this case whilst trying to do so she has used a bit of leverage 'I could arrest you sir' and the photographer has decided that its better to comply then get arrested and probably incur the continued wrath of some Daily Mail reading thug out exercising his children in the snow rather than stick to his guns, he has then gone on to have a moan about it afterwards.

As photographers its our responsibility to either know the law or to relent to a request by a constable of the law when asked to delete our pictures, the stand we take will I am sure, be effected by the importance of the pictures vs our wish not to get into a protracted argument or be arrested.

What I am trying to say is that I don't feel this officer should be expected to know the ins and outs of every law of our land but if your pictures are important enough to you then get yourself informed and be happy to acompany the officer to the station to sort the situation out and when there quote the letter of the law and get someone to look it up. People seem to have expectation of PC Plod as the purvayer of all knowledge in matters of civil and criminal law, if they were they would spend all their time reading books and none of it on the street trying to keep the peace.

MB
 
I can certainly understand why someone might be upset at being forced to delete their pictures and (with the idiotic press in this country) understand how a parent might be concerned about someone taking (what they think are) photos of their child.

What has almost certainly happened here is that a police officer has tried to calm things down but what she feels is the best and easiest way possible. Does the copper know all the legislation pertaining to photography in a public place? Probably not, like she probably doesn't have a full understanding of the intricate laws on the taking of the eggs of wild birds, she is trying to do what police officers are employed to do which is to 'keep the peace' if this means getting two members of the public to come to a compromise without the need to involve the law then thats going to be less paperwork and everyone is going to walk away happy. However in this case whilst trying to do so she has used a bit of leverage 'I could arrest you sir' and the photographer has decided that its better to do so then get arrested and probably incur the continued wrath of some Daily Mail reading thug out exercising his children in the snow.

As photographers its our responsibility to either know the law or to relent to a request by a constable of the law when requested to delete our pictures, the stand we take will, I am sure, be effected by the importance of the pictures vs our wish not to get into a protracted argument or be arrested.

What I am trying to say is that I don't feel this officer should be expected to know the ins and outs of every law of our land but if your pictures are important enough to you then get yourself informed and be happy to acompany the officer to the station to sort the situation out. People seem to have expectation of PC Plod as the purvayer of all knowledge in matters of civil and criminal law, if they were they would spend all their time reading books and none of it on the street.

MB

I totally agree with you :thumbs:

But that doesn't excuse police who make things up and basically intimidate people who don't know their rights into submission.
 
I totally agree with you :thumbs:

But that doesn't excuse police who make things up and basically intimidate people who don't know their rights into submission.

Agreed, I do think some officers will overstep the mark if they think a) they can get a way with it b) it will stop a problem from evolving into a crisis. I'm not saying its right though.

MB
 
It's true coppers have to carry a wealth of legislation in their heads just to deal with the stuff they can reasonably expect to encounter in their routine duties, and they have to make a decision on the spot without reference to the books everyone will have open when they tell them they got it wrong.

Ask your average town bobby what the closed season is for game shooting and you're likely to get a very blank look, whilst his country counterpart may bore you to death on the subject.

Photographers rights are understandably way down on the list of legislation a copper should be expected to be conversant with. Having said that they have a 2 way radio at their disposal and advice is that easy to get without wading in and bluffing their way through the situation.
 
It's true coppers have to carry a wealth of legislation in their heads just to deal with the stuff they can reasonably expect to encounter in their routine duties, and they have to make a decision on the spot without reference to the books everyone will have open when they tell them they got it wrong.

Ask your average town bobby what the closed season is for game shooting and you're likely to get a very blank look, whilst his country counterpart may bore you to death on the subject.

Photographers rights are understandably way down on the list of legislation a copper should be expected to be conversant with. Having said that they have a 2 way radio at their disposal and advice is that easy to get without wading in and bluffing their way through the situation.

Pheasant,Duck or deer?......;)
 
October 1st to Jan 31st........:whistling:

Ok,i`ll get my ...:coat:
 
Back
Top