Pro Landscape Tog Uses 35mm And Non L Zoom

Messages
5,161
Name
Nigel Cliff
Edit My Images
Yes
I am a great fan of the work of Dave Newbould a fabulous photographer who works in Snowdonia and turns out some stunning work examples of which can be found on his website here

http://www.davenewbould.co.uk/

Anyhow he was on Songs Of Praise tonight and I was gobsmacked to see him using an EOS 3 and a Canon 24-85 rather than say an EOS 1D or a Hassy as you expect from ladfscape photographers.The point I want to make is that with a 10 year old camera non L zooms (althoiugh I am also a great fan of the 24-85) the guy turns out work of the highest quality,I have a poster of hiis on my wall that is pin sharp,for heaven sake reading his site he also uses a Canon 70-300 that gets a regular pasing here.

So kust because you dont have or cant afford thje latest body or the L lenses and equivalents does not mean that a successful career in photography is way beyond you
 
Yep, that's right. It's not all about the gear it's about how you use it! Any old Joe can take a good photo with a £XXXX camera but it takes a great photographer to take a good photo with a cheaper/older alternative :)
 
Snip
Any old Joe can take a good photo with a £XXXX camera

Sorry, got to disagree with that! All a good camera can do for a crap photographer is get the exposure correct. That CAN be the difference between a good photo and a happy, crappy snapshot but as I'm sure most photographers with decent kit will agree, that kit doesn't ensure that all our photos are good.

Looking back over 30 odd years, I still think that one of my favourite shots is one that was a complete grab and was taken with a fairly crappy Kodak instamatic on Gold 200 print film, using a cheap pair of shades as an ND filter to stop it being completely blown out. Unfortunately I don't seem to be able to find the negative to scan and post (and, indeed, do a reprint) - I've moved a few times in the intervening years and, along with a lot of other detritus from my youth, it's probably under a playing field by now. By no means would I count myself as a great photographer, just an amateur with a 1/2 decent eye for a photograph.
 
Surely a good landscape pic is 50% achieved by being in the right place at the right time with the right view and light, and 50% by getting the composition right?

It's not like motorsport or wildlife where you need expensive lenses and bodies with fast AF and huge apertures to get the best results.
 
I love the comment on the opening page of his site:

"I have had no photographic training and still have very little technical knowledge, but have a love of the wild places and hopefully an 'eye' for a good picture."

I agree, all the most up to date, expensive gear doesn't count for anything if you don't have a great eye.
 
As per the comment from his website, Dave is completely self taught. It's partly seeing Dave's images that inspired me to get into landscape photography when I moved over to North Wales a few years ago.

Equipment certainly isn't everything, I think this probably applies even more so to landscape photography...being in the right place at the right time & having the "eye" to capture nature at it's best is much more important. I've seen a couple of Pros who often use a Canon G10 with stunning results.

Simon
 
I gather Dave Newbould is still using film and will continue doing so "until the quality of digital catches up...."

Discuss!

How would he know unless he'd tried them out personally?

For my work, the quality of digital caught up with film over five years ago, because all we needed were images capable of enlargement to A3.
The D1x could do that with care and the D2x could do it easily.

With the D3x we have a camera capable of true medium-format (on 100iso transparency film) quality, so what's his problem?

If he buys a Hasselblad and the latest digital back, he'd be getting image-quality approaching 5x4...
 
But what is the point of him changing if he gets the quality he (and his purchasers) get from whatever the technology it is that he uses?
Just to stay in fashion?

Matt
 
Just had a look at his website (Dave Newbould, that is) and in my humble opinion his images really aren't that special, frankly very average, contrasty with colours that make eyes hurt!
 
At the core of my life is my Christian faith - I am excited by the creative work that has gone into what I see around me, and I have a desire to communicate God's handiwork to a wider audience.

Well if he wants to do that surely he'd be better off documenting the effects of the Catholic Church's cover up and protection of paedophilia and child abuse or perhaps the scale of the HIV and AIDS problem in the third world, something the Church's attitude to safe sex is a significant contributing factor.

Either that or take a geology degree to find out where Snowdonia really came from.
coffee.gif
 
No, I think he all he's said is that film is better.

Which it is. Obviously.

Obviously it is, that's why you don't see pro labs shutting down everywhere, film producers no longer producing once hugely popular film emulsions, camera manufacturers cease to make film cameras at all and the price of film equipment plummet on the second hand market.

Oh, wait a minute ...
 
Obviously it is, that's why you don't see pro labs shutting down everywhere, film producers no longer producing once hugely popular film emulsions, camera manufacturers cease to make film cameras at all and the price of film equipment plummet on the second hand market.

Oh, wait a minute ...

I refer the poster to "The Sun sells lots of newspapers ..."
 
I refer the poster to "The Sun sells lots of newspapers ..."

The Sun does sell a lot of newspapers but not as many as they once did. Like film, newspapers are on the way out, most people get their news from other. mostly digital, sources now.

If film were 'better' then pros and amateurs alike would still be using it. The fact is, that for too many photographers their definition of 'better' means digital. Film might be 'better' for you, but that's like saying beef is 'better' than pork, which perhaps it is if you are Jewish or you just prefer the taste, but it's either a qualification based on your own situation or simply a subjective assessment. Either way, for you to make a blanket statement that film is better than digital is quite clearly not true.
 
I refer the poster to "The Sun sells lots of newspapers ..."

I think my point was lost....

I said - I didn't think his images were that good anyway,

you said - He sells a **** of a lot of postcards.......

I said - the Sun sells lots of newspapers

My point was that just because you sell lots of something, it doesn't mean it's any good :)

Unless of course you think The Sun is good, in which case I give up!
 
I like some of the photo's on his website, but not many made me go wow really.

Also that website is really horrible to navigate.
 
No, I think he all he's said is that film is better.

Which it is. Obviously.

Quality isn't measured in pixels or other geek terms - just as 'the best' doesn't always equal the most popular.

Best for whom? And for what?
Not for me otherwise I'd still be using it...along with about 99.99% of professional Press and PR photographers...

As I mentioned earlier, film was surpassed for my kind of work five or more years ago.

He might like using it, as the effect that film gives is more to his liking and his workflow allows the time spent in processing and he doesn't mind the additional cost, but that doesn't make it better - just different.

I have a promotional shoot scheduled for next week: 10+ subjects; four or five set-ups per subject and about 8 hours to shoot them in. Creative director, stylist and MUA in attendance.
I could do it on film, meaning Fuji transparency and medium format - Pentax 6x7 and Hasselblad...12 shots per roll, call it eight or ten rolls per subject.
Plus I'd need an assistant to re-load the cameras and backs to ensure a nicely-flowing shoot.
To be sure of things going right and give the client enough choices for her final selections, maybe 150 rolls of film at 8€ per roll and 10€ per roll to process it. Then all the faff of scanning the images, as the art director will want to view them on his MacBook immediately - oh wait - he can't as they haven't been processed for another week...

Or I might just shoot it on a D3x and have it all right there for the client to approve on the day.

Film still has its place, but it's not better...just suited to different subjects...and digital can also cover those equally well...
 
But they're not.

Fraid they are.

Especially ones about 'quality'.

And especially ones about quality that equate quality with pixels, sharpness and other meaningless diversions.

(Ease of use I completely understand - and arkady's post is a good example of why. I took 700 photos this weekend, all but 695 on some kind of digital gizmo and of course I have them to hand now and have already edited the ones I want. Two will be in the weekly paper on Thursday. Naturally that wouldn't be possible or affordable with film.)
 
Ah okay, so when someone talks about an exposure of 1/60th at f:8 and ISO 200 that's subjective is it? My mistake then.

It depends what you want though doesn't it?

Obviously the fact that something was taken at such a such speed etc is not subjective but saying that it should have been or that it would have been better had it been is subjective.
 
It depends what you want though doesn't it?

Obviously the fact that something was taken at such a such speed etc is not subjective but saying that it should have been or that it would have been better had it been is subjective.

Look, I guess I can get "medium-format" quality now from a 35mm-sized system. Much as I regret the way that digital came in and made meaningless many of the skills I learned with film, and how much I hate being tied to a computer, you can't deny the quality argument any more.

Dave Newbould is another kettle of fish altogether......
 
Fraid they are.

Especially ones about 'quality'.

And especially ones about quality that equate quality with pixels, sharpness and other meaningless diversions.

(Ease of use I completely understand - and arkady's post is a good example of why. I took 700 photos this weekend, all but 695 on some kind of digital gizmo and of course I have them to hand now and have already edited the ones I want. Two will be in the weekly paper on Thursday. Naturally that wouldn't be possible or affordable with film.)

Jon, with film, you wouldn't have taken 700 shots, and thrown away 695 of them. You'd probably have used - what, maybe three rolls? - and if you were lucky got 2 or 3 keepers. You'd still have got them in the paper.
 
Back
Top