Pro's and Con's of shooting in RAW

Messages
364
Name
Kevin
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi,

Not sure if this is one of those subjects that's been well covered in the past, but done a quick search and can't find anything, so I thought I'd ask.

I had a DSLR for a good few years (D100) but recently due to getting back more into photography and upgrading my equipment; and spending a while on here, I get the impression that for most semi pro/pro occasions most people appear to shoot in RAW.

Now up to recently I've just used JPEG and was wondering if other would share there expereince and opinions on shoot in RAW; memory, quality, post processing etc; etc; etc.

Would be grateful for all view and tips.

Cheers

Kevin
 
I had a D100 too. The I upgraded to film so I don't have to worry about all this JPG, RAW and TIFF nonesense!


Steve.
 
I shoot in jpeg, and I have done weddings.

Jpeg makes you think more to get the shot right.

I can see the temptation for RAW but I would rather be taking pics than spending time post processing things that I have done wrong.

Each to their own though.
 
If there are settings on the camera that produce a jpeg you like the look of, in terms of colour, contrast, sharpness etc, then shoot jpeg. It's far less hassle and space conmsuming.

You can rescue a shot more if it's shot in RAW but really with a preview and a histogram, there is little excuse to get things very wrong.

If however you are a bit of a control freak and need to have ultimate control over imperceptable changes to the file, shoot RAW. I do. :D
 
Personally I shoot in RAW all of the time for the greater control it gives you.

Takes up more room though unfortunately.
 
I shoot in jpeg, and I have done weddings.

Jpeg makes you think more to get the shot right.

I can see the temptation for RAW but I would rather be taking pics than spending time post processing things that I have done wrong.

Each to their own though.

I've never understood that arguement - the way I look at it is PP isn't a way of fixing issues, but of developing the photo to the best it can be. RAW gives better options to do this, at a trade off for file space and additional processing effort. - Although my workflow is the same for jpeg and RAW, RAW has to be processed, JPEG doesn't

Hugh
 
I shoot RAW all the time... the upside is you have greater control because you have more information from the camera... the downside is you have to PP every photo to some degree (sharpen, maybe white balance etc) and you'll need a plug in to view the images as thumbnails in windows explorer (several free ones available).
 
Shooting in jpeg instead of raw is a bit like buying a 5 speed sportscar and deciding to never use 1st or 5th gear - a bit daft :cuckoo: - as you are missing out on your camera's full potential, and yes too, if you make a booboo it's more flexible for corrections, but that's only a bonus not the point of raw

Those that suggest it's better for storage to shoot jpeg are also missing the point that now 1tb external harddrives are under £80 that's an awful lot of space for a 10th or less of what you've just spent on a camera

And I guarantee that as you get better at photography, and especially in PP, you will look back to some of your early work, realise how much better it could be now with your PP skills and go - "Why the fk did I shoot in jpeg" :bang::bang::bang:

If nothing else the simplest benefit you'll see is in White Balance - where the WB is set at the time of shooting with a jpeg but not with a raw shot; so in jpeg you could be struggling to correct whereas the raw file it's all just a slider or click of a picker tool - it's easier to get good colour with raw images

As you get better, you'll also appreciate the wider dynamic range raw gives you too

In summary for me - if you want to shoot images and go straight to Boots/Asda for a print, shoot jpeg & sell your DSLR for a handy point & shoot; for ALL other uses shoot raw :)

DD
 
I always shoot RAW. It gives me more control and more oprions in PP - and it takes seconds to process each picture if you get it right in camera. However - you have that safety margin with RAW you don't have shooting jpeg. If your pictures matter - shoot RAW. Space is cheap nowadays!

If you have a D3x as your user name suggests it would be madness not to shoot in RAW - why wouldn't you want to get the best out of each image?
 
Just to add to the two comments that jumped in before my reply ;)

The workflow is almost he same once you have a proven workflow in such as ACR or Lightroom - and most PP is done via presets, actions or simple batch processing - I certainly don't treat every shot individually any more than I would a jpeg - but when I do it's easier and more flexible to shoot raw

DD
 
And to add to the Above, with Nikon, you can apply any of the camera controls using NX2 to a RAW file. With JPEG you are stuck with the settings as shot in the camera (noise, sharpening etc).

Having said that, for shooting events JPEG is probably best as you want to be able to sell what you shoot immediately, rather than having to process the file first.
 
I shoot raw and jpeg, I have the jpeg set to how I like to PP my images so when I see the preview on camera this is how it looks. The raw gives me a backup if I need to tweak slightly for colour casts etc
 
My camera allows me to shoot in both formats at the same time. :clap:

But default for me is raw, this allows me to get the best out of my images due to my dubious camera technique.

Nikon Capture NX2 is my friend.
 
as someone who owns and uses a d100 it takes excellent pictures and has a unique look i think

however it's slow as so i'd stick with jpg unless you're happy to shoot at 1 frame per hour :)
benefits of raw are mainly the ability to **** around with exposure if you've naffed things up

that said, if you've got a d3x shoot raw and jpg, the compression in camera is great and saves pratting around if you want to just dish them out quickly and you've still got the raws if anything needs doing
 
Shooting in jpeg instead of raw is a bit like buying a 5 speed sportscar and deciding to never use 1st or 5th gear - a bit daft :cuckoo: - as you are missing out on your camera's full potential, and yes too, if you make a booboo it's more flexible for corrections, but that's only a bonus not the point of raw

DD pretty much said it all, I just wanted to add a point for those shooting jpegs only. When you shoot jpegs only, then your camera is in control of your images (you can tweak some settings but that is it - majority is controlled by the camera). When, on the other hand, you shoot raw, then you are in control of your images not the camera.
 
i'll add to even though the above is right, having the camera styles applied to your jpg can act as a reference if you're using lightroom which won't read the embedded nikon styles (even though it comes with some like for likes available)
 
as someone who owns and uses a d100 it takes excellent pictures and has a unique look i think

however it's slow as so i'd stick with jpg unless you're happy to shoot at 1 frame per hour :)

Believe it or not, I used to shoot in TIFF mode with mine!


Steve.
 
I always shoot in RAW and then do the work myself, I back all my RAW files up onto HDD and DVD after I have sorted the keepers which mean that I can always go back and play with the image as my PP skills improve.
 
Edit: alexkidd, this was not meant as a personal reply to you - just a generic rant :) to all such comments so please don't take it personally

benefits of raw are mainly the ability to **** around with exposure if you've naffed things up

It's statements like this that usually contribute to confusion and make people think "I don't need that". Whilst raw gives you ability to fix exposure errors to some degree in PP - it is not it's main and greatest benefit. Saying that to me indicates that people do not fully understand what raw is and what it is for.

Raw is intended to give photographer full control over "development" of his/hers photos (as in darkroom style development) to get the highest possible quality out of the camera. Of course if some photographers are happy with polaroids right out of the camera (as in film equivalent), then jpegs will be suitable for them just fine.

If, like Ansel Adams, you want to create something that you visualised first, then undoubtedly any jpeg out of the camera won't do simply because camera will never be able to respond to individual's vision of the scene, portrait etc. You don't have to tweak an exposure, but you may need to selectively dodge/burn parts of the photos (or do other development edits) to achieve your vision and JPEGs will effectively degrade image quality when you do that. Raw won't degrade image quality and to me this is their greatest advantage. They are there simply to empower photographer and make him/her in control of their images.
 
RAW gives you much more creative freedom and forces you to be more involved in the whole process between composing your subject and displaying the result. Photography can be quite a mechanical process (which some people like) and with RAW that process doesnt finish once you press the shutter. JPG is great if you dont have the confidence to adjust your results manually but i also get the impression that some people would rather have the ability to get it right it right first time rather than having to rethink the shot later on.
 
And I guarantee that as you get better at photography, and especially in PP, you will look back to some of your early work, realise how much better it could be now with your PP skills and go - "Why the fk did I shoot in jpeg" :bang::bang::bang:

That's a sound guarantee DD! I was asked to reprocess a stack of old property shots for a new website last month and thought EXACTLY that!!

Property interiors are so much easier in RAW... being able to both lift shadows and recover overexposed windows all in the same shot, without any bracketing, is a real time saver.
 
There are no cons to shooting in RAW now that the prices of memory cards are so low. With an 8Gb card you can fit a few hundred RAW shots on there. Shooting in RAW doesn't mean you can't still take the time to get the shot right in camera but with batch processing you can make sure all your shots look their best with minimal PP time. I'd never go back to JPG.
 
i'm not going to take offence but i shoot both jpeg and raw and understand the benefits of both

however you'll find numerous posts of "why doesn't it look like when i took the photo" on the internet after someone has opened it in LR to go back in and tweak their raw file (hence my ref to having it as a reference)

raw definately has it's uses but if you've got a high quality jpeg that is as you like (viewed in the vf/lcd when you've taken the shot) you've still got a lot of room for editing, the concept that a jpeg is almost impossible to edit is just ridiculous

honestly out of the majority of people who change things in photos you're looking at probably altering some colours and burning/dodging some areas which is more than do-able in jpeg the fact that the raw gives you more flexibility is a major reason why people do use raw as has been documented well throughout all these types of thread on tp

"benefits of raw are mainly the ability to **** around with exposure if you've naffed things up"

the use of the term mainly and not solely would imply that there is more scope that just the aforementioned but realisticaly and imho i'd say it's probably one of the primary benefits of using raw.

the basics of it being that raw is more flexible but at the end of the day whatever suits you/what you're shooting/your circumstances is the right choice

i'd even stray as far as to notice that people rarely consider the specification of someones computer when advising to use raw...editing say a 15-30mb raw rather than a 1-2mb jpeg can make a massive difference on a systems resources

that said even though I'm not taking offence, you could have easily made your point without quoting me as it would infer that you're referring to me when you say usually

:/
 
but i also get the impression that some people would rather have the ability to get it right it right first time rather than having to rethink the shot later on

Rob really said it here:

Shooting in RAW doesn't mean you can't still take the time to get the shot right in camera

RAW is no substitute of getting the shot right in camera.
 
There are no cons to shooting in RAW now that the prices of memory cards are so low. With an 8Gb card you can fit a few hundred RAW shots on there. Shooting in RAW doesn't mean you can't still take the time to get the shot right in camera but with batch processing you can make sure all your shots look their best with minimal PP time. I'd never go back to JPG.

Surely, if you're batch processing, you're just making a guess at the levels of adjustment that each raw file might need rather than letting the camera make its (normally pretty accurate) mind up? I can see that for ultimate quality, raw is probaby better than JPEG, as long as each individual file is adjusted according to its own needs; applying a batch correction cannot do the best for all the images. There will be occasions where the light stays the same throughout but setting an accurate custom WB and shooting JPEG will cover that too.

I'm pretty sure that I could count on two hands the number of JPEGs I've shot that have been beyond PSE's capabilities for correction and 2 or 3 of those were shot under street lights which are next to impossible to set a WB for due to their very narrow spectrum.

If you want to shoot raw, please go ahead and do so but treat each shot as a seperate entity rather than batch processing them. I shall continue shooting JPEGs and spending less time in PP.
 
i'm not going to take offence but i shoot both jpeg and raw and understand the benefits of both

I will disagree with this - to me Jpeg has absolutely no benefits whatsoever. It is inferior in every way, and is constrained by the camera - so my question is if you are serious about the image quality of your final result, what is the point of using it?

however you'll find numerous posts of "why doesn't it look like when i took the photo" on the internet after someone has opened it in LR to go back in and tweak their raw file (hence my ref to having it as a reference)

This has nothing to do with RAW - to replicate the camera produced look and feel you'd have to use camera manufacturer's software. In the film equivalent, you would not expect the same looking image from Kodak UltraMax and Fuji Velvia for example so what is the point to do this with RAW processed by different RAW convertors?

raw definately has it's uses but if you've got a high quality jpeg that is as you like (viewed in the vf/lcd when you've taken the shot)

Can you seriously judge the quality and other properties of the image just by looking at the 3 inches large LCD at the back of the camera?? I can only ever do a quick assessment but it is nowhere near accurate enough. Your cameras LCDs are not calibrated either so you can potentially discover colour shifts later by looking at your JPEG in a controlled environment by at that time it may be too late.

you've still got a lot of room for editing, the concept that a jpeg is almost impossible to edit is just ridiculous

It is not impossible to edit - it is impractical for achieving highest possible quality output of your edits. Each of three colour channels only has 256 levels so think what happens with every simple operation that involves shifting colours or levels. Now think of all the data that in-camera processing engine threw away when it was converted to JPEG and lossy compression applied and you will have hardly any left for anything other than quality compromising image tweaks.

honestly out of the majority of people who change things in photos you're looking at probably altering some colours and burning/dodging some areas which is more than do-able in jpeg

I never said you could not - but what happens to underlying image data at that time is what important. Of course it may not matter to anybody and that's why I am saying that RAW is for those who are serious about their image quality or want to be in control of it. Monitors and printers are getting better every day now so when you did you dodging and burning on 8bit JPEGs that caused some ugly shifts in shadows which you would not notice on monitor calibrated for dark viewing environments and on bog standard inkjet photo print, who knows what you may see in a future on 16-bit capable monitors and printers? This is partially what DiddyDave said about looking back at your older shots.

i'd even stray as far as to notice that people rarely consider the specification of someones computer when advising to use raw...editing say a 15-30mb raw rather than a 1-2mb jpeg can make a massive difference on a systems resources

That is a misconception again. Do you really think that editors like photoshop will keep jpeg compressed when you edit it? In that respect there is no benefit of compressed format over non compressed because when you load it up, any format is expanded to bitmaps when loaded into editor so your jpegs will take as much as their resolution multiplied by 3 or 4 to get the number of bytes (same 15-30 megs as raw file when opened up in editor).


that said even though I'm not taking offence, you could have easily made your point without quoting me as it would infer that you're referring to me when you say usually

I did use the comment as an example since you were the first to state it. Next time I'll just post in general so point taken.
 
I shoot in jpeg & RAW. This is principally because, after a hard day's snapping, there are always photos which are going to look average whether they're in jpeg or RAW format regardless of how you alter them.

When I'm quickly scanning through the jpegs, I'll note which ones that I took as 'standout shots' or that I'm not happy with, or feel as if they've got more potential, and then go and mess about with them in RAW.

It's not perfect, I admit, but I simply don't have the time to go through hundreds of RAWS, and batch processing is a bit of a false economy - you may as well just shoot in jpeg!
 
Surely, if you're batch processing, you're just making a guess at the levels of adjustment that each raw file might need rather than letting the camera make its (normally pretty accurate) mind up?
It all depends on the way you batch process your shots. What I mean by batch processing is that if I do a shoot of say 500 images I don't want to go through them all 1 by 1 adjusting the WB, levels, sharpness, contrast etc etc so I'll pick out a batch of a few images that look very similar, adjust the setting of 1 of them then batch process the rest of them the same. I can then makes tweeks to each if I'm not happy.

If you are getting the shot right in camera then you may not need a lot of PP work so batch processing could be as simple as a resize, sharpen and watermarking for uploading to the web.

Whether you shoot JPG or RAW you should always have a look at each and every shot to see what PP should be done. The benefit of RAW is that there is so much more margin for error and correction.
 
I shoot in jpeg & RAW. This is principally because, after a hard day's snapping, there are always photos which are going to look average whether they're in jpeg or RAW format regardless of how you alter them.

When I'm quickly scanning through the jpegs, I'll note which ones that I took as 'standout shots' or that I'm not happy with, or feel as if they've got more potential, and then go and mess about with them in RAW.

It's not perfect, I admit, but I simply don't have the time to go through hundreds of RAWS, and batch processing is a bit of a false economy - you may as well just shoot in jpeg!
why not just look at the RAW one like this, that’s what I do why waste space with jpeg’s
 
why not just look at the RAW one like this, that’s what I do why waste space with jpeg’s

Well it's funny you should mention that. My PC was having trouble with the Zoombrowser software, but literally 10 minutes ago I've just found Faststone which seems to be a lot faster - lends itself to choosing the pics for batch processing a bit easier I guess.

HmmMmMmm.. got me thinking now! ;)
 
I shoot raw always perio
My reason... for many of the reasons posted by awp and delex:)
 
Could I just say thanks to all, some things to think about and it's bee helpful, and raised more questions - which I suppose with gaining additional knowledge, I am sure I'll be search the forum for answer and post lots more questions?

And as a few people pointed out, I in the position where I can shoot both RAW and JPEG, so I've just order a couple of extra memory cards and plan to do just that, I like the suggestion to shoot both, which suits me at the moment, as I need to get a few shots out really quickly, with little PP; cropping, contrast etc, and some I'll like to do more with - wehn time allows.

Cheers to all - any more points please feel free.
 
I shoot RAW all the time... the upside is you have greater control because you have more information from the camera... the downside is you have to PP every photo to some degree (sharpen, maybe white balance etc) and you'll need a plug in to view the images as thumbnails in windows explorer (several free ones available).
I have just started getting to grips with RAW and take both RAW and JPEG now. I only use DPP for my processing (with a bit of piant.net after), and I find that in DPP, the RAW shots take the settings that the camera has for the JPEGS. Therefore, could I assume that if I did a straight conversion from RAW with those settings automatically applied, they would be exactly the same as the camera JPEG?
 
And as a few people pointed out, I in the position where I can shoot both RAW and JPEG, so I've just order a couple of extra memory cards and plan to do just that, I like the suggestion to shoot both, which suits me at the moment, as I need to get a few shots out really quickly, with little PP; cropping, contrast etc, and some I'll like to do more with - wehn time allows.

Cheers to all - any more points please feel free.

Good decision. If anything, keep raw just for future possibilities. Technologies do not stand still, new demosaicing methods with better quality of raw conversion may appear, new quality image processing programs and algorithms. This may make you wanting to revisit your shots one day in attempt to get more from them so it's a good reason have raws.
 
Shooting in jpeg instead of raw is a bit like buying a 5 speed sportscar and deciding to never use 1st or 5th gear - a bit daft :cuckoo: - as you are missing out on your camera's full potential, and yes too, if you make a booboo it's more flexible for corrections, but that's only a bonus not the point of raw

Those that suggest it's better for storage to shoot jpeg are also missing the point that now 1tb external harddrives are under £80 that's an awful lot of space for a 10th or less of what you've just spent on a camera

And I guarantee that as you get better at photography, and especially in PP, you will look back to some of your early work, realise how much better it could be now with your PP skills and go - "Why the fk did I shoot in jpeg" :bang::bang::bang:

If nothing else the simplest benefit you'll see is in White Balance - where the WB is set at the time of shooting with a jpeg but not with a raw shot; so in jpeg you could be struggling to correct whereas the raw file it's all just a slider or click of a picker tool - it's easier to get good colour with raw images

As you get better, you'll also appreciate the wider dynamic range raw gives you too

In summary for me - if you want to shoot images and go straight to Boots/Asda for a print, shoot jpeg & sell your DSLR for a handy point & shoot; for ALL other uses shoot raw :)

DD

You've had a bit of a transformation :p

I know what you're getting at but there's a lot I don't agree with in there :p Before I say anything else I'll say I use both RAW and jpeg.

The first bit doesn't seem to make sense. The camera manufacturers include jpeg options for people who need them. To use your analogy not using jpeg is a bit like buying a 5 speed sportscar and not using 1st or 5th. You're not using the tools the manufacturer has provided at the appropriate times.

The space argument is still valid. Yes, space is cheaper, but files are larger. If you're doing big shoots it doesn't take long to fill a 1Tb drive. I've got about 4TB of storage in my PC just now and am about to archive and replace two 1TB drives.

As far as processing is concerned I think there is a case for RAW, but it does depend on the type of photography you're doing. For me, there's hardly any processing, if it's a bad photo in terms of exposure, it's binned, I've got plenty more to choose from (events).

The last comment really did make me laugh though. Presumably we'll be seeing all the newspaper and sports agency togs chucking their D3 and MkIII's because they're not shooting RAW :lol:

As a general point I don't mind if people want to use RAW all the time, it's got it's place, as has Jpeg and it's their choice. What does grip my **** is the attitude that because someone doesn't use RAW all the time somehow they don't care about their photography. Frankly that's rubbish. Jpegs are capable of providing extremely high quality in print or on the web. Arguably it may not be "best" but how often has anyone looked at an image on here or in print and thought, "Wow, that must have been shot in RAW".
 
Back
Top