Pro's and Con's of shooting in RAW

Yeah, I know. What I don’t understand is if I don’t tweak the images in PCR first and load them straight into PS (all be it via PCR) is PS just as effective or does PCR have a better way of dealing with the RAW file first.

What will happen is any camera settings you have will be applied to the RAW file and open in PS so bypassing the adjustment you could make like WB Exposure and so on.
You RAW file is saved with the settings as a tagged file so it like all that the camera would have done to it if you had shot in JPG but with out changing it to a 8bit when you open it like this its like opening the JPG version, I not know if you have it open in 16 or 8bit not knowing the Panasonic
 
Yeah, I know. What I don’t understand is if I don’t tweak the images in PCR first and load them straight into PS (all be it via PCR) is PS just as effective or does PCR have a better way of dealing with the RAW file first.

You would restrict yourself if you did that as you are losing controls you would have in the raw converter. Of course, if you don't feel the need to tweak anything at that stage then it is a mootpoint
 
You would restrict yourself if you did that as you are losing controls you would have in the raw converter. Of course, if you don't feel the need to tweak anything at that stage then it is a mootpoint

When I load RAW files into PS, you get the RAW conversion controls before it converts to a PS file. In what way are these inferior to a separate RAW converter program... as that's what I normally do at the moment.
 
Mainly Raw, sometimes Jpeg,sometimes both,depends what the job or situation requires.
 
When I load RAW files into PS, you get the RAW conversion controls before it converts to a PS file. In what way are these inferior to a separate RAW converter program... as that's what I normally do at the moment.

What you are getting is Adobe Camera Raw which is the raw converter that comes with PS. Don't see this as inferior to other raw converters myself.
 
honestly the nikon raw converters are ahead of the others for rendering NEFs but frankly their gui is pants so back to LR we go and no in camera styles

as dod and a few others keep saying (inc moi) and people seem to keep arguing about is that raw is superior in quality but not definitively the best tool for all jobs.
 
honestly the nikon raw converters are ahead of the others for rendering NEFs but frankly their gui is pants so back to LR we go and no in camera styles

as dod and a few others keep saying (inc moi) and people seem to keep arguing about is that raw is superior in quality but not definitively the best tool for all jobs.

I'll give you that, I've done some stuff that gets ouputted straight to screens which needs jpeg
 
honestly the nikon raw converters are ahead of the others for rendering NEFs but frankly their gui is pants so back to LR we go and no in camera styles

as dod and a few others keep saying (inc moi) and people seem to keep arguing about is that raw is superior in quality but not definitively the best tool for all jobs.

This I can totally agree with (both parts) :D

Just wanted to add that those seeking ultimate quality of RAW conversion itself may want to have a look at RawMagick - it's demosaicing using floating point operations and does seem to get the best out of raw files. It is incredibly slow though ...
 
What will happen is any camera settings you have will be applied to the RAW file and open in PS so bypassing the adjustment you could make like WB Exposure and so on.
You RAW file is saved with the settings as a tagged file so it like all that the camera would have done to it if you had shot in JPG but with out changing it to a 8bit when you open it like this its like opening the JPG version, I not know if you have it open in 16 or 8bit not knowing the Panasonic

Wow, well thats a lot of messing ive done that could have been better, thanks. I'll make sure my initial tweaks are in the RAW convertor first.

Does that also mean that any alterations done in PS are applied to an inferior copy ? It does say RAW on the PS task bar (rather than jpg or tiff) until i save it, so i always presumed it was still the original i was working on.

Thats only about 1000 images to re-do then !
 
You would restrict yourself if you did that as you are losing controls you would have in the raw converter. Of course, if you don't feel the need to tweak anything at that stage then it is a mootpoint

Think i'm getting it now, and i feel a bit daft.......but thats good. Learning curves and all that.
 
I usually do though, sharpening in particular, a bit of curves (which is kinda my way of adjusting the white point as my 'theory' was that the fewer programs/steps i used to process an image, the more info would be preserved).

Just having a play in PCR now.
 
Wow, well thats a lot of messing ive done that could have been better, thanks. I'll make sure my initial tweaks are in the RAW convertor first.

Does that also mean that any alterations done in PS are applied to an inferior copy ? It does say RAW on the PS task bar (rather than jpg or tiff) until i save it, so i always presumed it was still the original i was working on.

Thats only about 1000 images to re-do then !

NO it will be what ever you set ACR to open it in PS with so you can open it as a 16 bit Or a 8bit to keep max info you need this set at 16bit its in blue at the bottom of ACR click on the text and it opens up a settings box.
When it’s open in PS it is a PS file PSD and will have max info.
You can run batch file if you just need to set WB or small adjustments to all of them open the first one to set your WB and any other setting you wish to apply to all and then save setting you can now apply the same setting to all of your photos in one go
 
Shooting in jpeg instead of raw is a bit like buying a 5 speed sportscar and deciding to never use 1st or 5th gear - a bit daft :cuckoo: - as you are missing out on your camera's full potential...

Not picking on you in particular DD but I think there's more to it than that; I agree that raw will ultimately give you more flexibility when processing, and as some has mentioned, getting it right in the first place is more help than any software, but JPEG is very useful when you're shooting high volumes of work, like I do, where very little in the way of processing is the preferred way because it would only slow the whole process down.

I shoot both by the way, JPEG as preferred by the repro people at work, but with a raw back-up 'just in case' and when we need shots for use on mag covers. :)
 
I agree that raw will ultimately give you more flexibility

And more things to go wrong.

I don't want to get into arguing, this subject has certainly taken over from the old " Film is better than Digital". But the option to shoot both is surely the right way to go? Memory is so cheap, in fact I have started using digital exactly as I would in the past have used slide film. Those old enough will remember having to " nail" every shot, none of your lets keep the button pressed and hope, slide film made you think, a strange concept to many.

So get it right at the taking stage, shooting in large Jpeg AND Raw, then view the jpegs as a slide show and keep the RAW in reserve. File the memory cards and there you go. All you are doing is using memory cards as film with a bonus ........at less cost. Then if viewing the show you experience the creative urge fine, you still have the original untouched files.

I started digital with a D100, then a D70s followed by a D200 which rapidly was swapped for a D300. Each camera became more and more capable, work in PS became less and less. Now the lumbering old D300 has been relegated to the back of the wardrobe replaced by a diminutive GF1. B/W " Slides" taken on this and viewed with a 37" Panasonic HD TV are amazing....and yes for those who know me my standards are quite high.


Incidentally for colour workers, statistically colour can only be seen accurately if you are 12 years old..........and female.. Just a thought.;)

Incidentally on the memory thing. To replace film with cards I would like to use roughly the same capacity,say 256Mb but at the moment decent cards this small seem to be pretty rare.............any ideas?

Brian
 
I don't want to get into arguing, this subject has certainly taken over from the old " Film is better than Digital". But the option to shoot both is surely the right way to go? Memory is so cheap, in fact I have started using digital exactly as I would in the past have used slide film. Those old enough will remember having to " nail" every shot, none of your lets keep the button pressed and hope, slide film made you think, a strange concept to many.

Well said.

Incidentally on the memory thing. To replace film with cards I would like to use roughly the same capacity,say 256Mb but at the moment decent cards this small seem to be pretty rare.............any ideas?

When I had a D100, I too used to use 512MB cards. Just enough space for 76 JPG files or 26 RAW files. Certainly enough for me.

I went back to film though so now I am happy with a couple of rolls of 120 or one roll of 35mm for a day.


Steve.
 
Steve I reckon we might be on the same wavelength.;)

But people or rather males usually do love to complicate thing. Standing in ***** the other day having nothing better to do I counted the knobs and slider things on a mini sort of pseudo hi fi stacky thing, 58!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and there was me thinking the perfect amplifier was the shortest piece of wire....with gain.

Love the Panoramic, can you make mine Rosewood with a Boxwood and Satinwood inlay?

Brian.
 
Raw = greatest potential for your image

Why compromise? Use your gear to it's maximum potential every time :)
 
Don't bother with a quote, just give an address to send the blank cheque. :)
 
DB 247

Why compromise? Use your gear to it's maximum potential every time

I used to use DSCL a lot, thinking of going back as they're cheaper than loxley. Will be googling Sams photolabs now.

Isn't that a compromise? Use RAW to get the perfect file then send it to a " cheaper" printer.

Brian
 
ALL CAMERAS SHOOT RAW FOR EVERY IMAGE
If you choose JPEG, the camera is processing the RAW image for you. Hence if you can process the RAW image better then your camera, and you care about quality, shoot RAW

If you are happy with your cameras processing, and you don't care or have the time to process the RAW files, shoot JPEGS
 
If you are happy with your cameras processing, and you don't care or have the time to process the RAW files, shoot JPEGS

If you changed your and to or I would say spot on. Nikon R&D certainly know more then little old me.............................but there again most people do.;)

Brian.
 
If you changed your and to or I would say spot on. Nikon R&D certainly know more then little old me.............................but there again most people do.;)

Brian.

my bad - that's what i meant
 
Back
Top