Question about catchlights when shooting with off camera flash

[ndwgolf]

Guys
I have a question about catchlights when shooting a model with sunglasses on........is it good or bad to have the catchlights is her glasses??
Below are two examples of what I am talking about.........Note in the final picture I removed the catchlights with PS because that is what I thought I needed to do and not because I didn't like them.
1/.
View attachment 30867
2/.

View attachment 30868

 

[mike weeks]

Sometimes you can use reflections in glasses to dramatic effect and it can look great, there is no right or wrong but for me these do not have it.

Mike

 

[blakester]

I agree with Mike, using the reflections in glasses can have a dramatic effect.
Perhaps in your examples above, if the reflection of the light was on both lenses of the sunglasses it would balance the image better.