Royal Photographic Society

Messages
28
Name
Robert
Edit My Images
No
Hi

I live in Lydd Kent, is the Royal Photographic Society worth joining for a beginner.

Ty
Rob
 
Having recognition letters after one name is find, but how many outside photography Know what RPS means? I could put A S A after mine (Association of Silly Arses) still looks great after ones name. Who would bother to check if not in photography but looking to hire a photographer
 
I have a number of photographic distinctions and, although other members of my camera club would recognise them, I did not try to achieve them other than to set a target to challenge myself. In the case of RPS, they do offer various advice and services to members; the distinctions are just one of those services. One problem with the RPS is that you have to maintain your annual membership to keep the distinction which can prove expensive in retirement. My current distinctions are for life with no ongoing fee. I did consider joining the RPS a while ago when they were considering moving from Bath to my home town where I would have been able to readily benefit from their services and events. However, they could not afford the building they were considering and moved elsewhere (Bristol) so I did not join (i.e. I would not join just for the distinctions).

Dave
 
When the RPS was based in Bath, their restaurant wasn't too bad.

I won't be drawn on the pictures hung on the walls... :exit:
 
When it was in Bath, we enjoyed the bookshop that they had on the premises. Toppings now fills that void.
 
Hi

I live in Lydd Kent, is the Royal Photographic Society worth joining for a beginner.

Ty
Rob
It depends on what you are looking for.

There is a difference between learning how to use a camera and learning about photography. I suspect the value of membership will depend on what you are expecting and how much you take advantage of being a member.

From what I have seen and heard, getting involved with the RPS seems more likely to give you a good grounding in photography than simply relying on YouTube channels or following the average photography forum, social media platform or camera club where even though there is a lot of good stuff on offer, it's difficult for a beginner, and not so beginner, to filter out the useful from the useless and misleading.

I would have a look at what they offer, as they appear to offer a fair amount of support through membership and the many specialist groups, with a lot of good photographers involved. And they do a lot of work, beyond the obvious membership benefits of representing photographers and photography in the wider world.

Paul Hill, David Hurn and Martin Parr in the last few years have all said complimentary things about the RPS

Their Youtube channel has some interesting videos. Including useful information on attaining the distinctions.


As regards getting letters after your name, and losing them unless you keep paying your membership, seems an irrelevant aspect of gaining the distinction (not that I have any). Distinctions from professional bodies work the same way, at least all that I am aware of. The point, for me, would be having my photographs assessed as coming up to a certain standard by people with recognised expertise and from the learning experience of preparing the submission.

Although they cost extra, the Specialist Interest Groups look useful, with online talks, as well as magazines and other resources, ie dedicated Facebook groups.


The quarterly journal from the Documentary group looks good (but it seems you don't need to be a member to read it)


There is also an RPS South East Group


Finally, browsing through their website, they seem to do a lot of work for photography and photographers, and for that reason alone, probably worth supporting (at least for those seriously interested in photography). It's useful to have a learned society like the RPS "rooting" for photography and photographers..

I think you probably need to sign up and give them a try. To me, It looks like a useful organisation to be a member of, if you can afford it.
 
Can you explain why? Is this just with reference to beginners?

The impression I have had in recent years, is that they are probably worth the membership (but mainly through comments about their specialist interest groups).
 
Can you explain why? Is this just with reference to beginners?
I cannot speak for Droj but my opinion is that the RPS is a fairly typical "us and them" group.

Even in the 1960s, it seemed to me that it had lost track of how the culture around photography was changing from "older man with tripod and full plate camera" to "young man or woman with 35mm single lens reflex". The style of images that the RPS considered "good" was quite different to what picture editors, art directors and even several club committee members, considered worth publishing and looking at.

Of course, this is and always will be a matter of personal taste; and so it should be.
 
Even in the 1960s, it seemed to me that it had lost track of how the culture around photography was changing from "older man with tripod and full plate camera" to "young man or woman with 35mm single lens reflex". The style of images that the RPS considered "good" was quite different to what picture editors, art directors and even several club committee members, considered worth publishing and looking at.

The RPS is trying to move with the times and is more progressive than it was. However I think it can hold people back/push them in certain directions.

As someone primarily interested in documentary photography I check out their online documentary magazine (https://rps.org/groups/documentary/...e-quarterly-journal-of-the-documentary-group/) and there looks to be an RPS style/approach to that area of photography. I was looking at someone's work online and thought to myself: "I bet they're in the RPS." Sure enough on finding their website their RPS letters were in evidence.

Speaking to a friend who was doing an RPS documentary panel my original view was reinforced that there is over emphasis on technical perfection. They had their photographs deemed unsuitable for being too noisy. Having been taking in dark situations using available light that was inevitable, but look at some heralded photos from the days of film and they are even more grainy than a high ISO digital picture.
 
I cannot speak for Droj but my opinion is that the RPS is a fairly typical "us and them" group.

Even in the 1960s, it seemed to me that it had lost track of how the culture around photography was changing from "older man with tripod and full plate camera" to "young man or woman with 35mm single lens reflex". The style of images that the RPS considered "good" was quite different to what picture editors, art directors and even several club committee members, considered worth publishing and looking at.

Of course, this is and always will be a matter of personal taste; and so it should be.
That was also my view 30 years ago, but more recent comments from photographers I respect (e.g I mention Paul Hill, David Hurn and Martin Parr) have made me think I should maybe give it a rethink.
 
The RPS is trying to move with the times and is more progressive than it was. However I think it can hold people back/push them in certain directions.

As someone primarily interested in documentary photography I check out their online documentary magazine (https://rps.org/groups/documentary/...e-quarterly-journal-of-the-documentary-group/) and there looks to be an RPS style/approach to that area of photography. I was looking at someone's work online and thought to myself: "I bet they're in the RPS." Sure enough on finding their website their RPS letters were in evidence.

Speaking to a friend who was doing an RPS documentary panel my original view was reinforced that there is over emphasis on technical perfection. They had their photographs deemed unsuitable for being too noisy. Having been taking in dark situations using available light that was inevitable, but look at some heralded photos from the days of film and they are even more grainy than a high ISO digital picture.
I haven't looked enough at work associated with the RPS to have an opinion, but I've certainly seen examples of successful ARPS/FRPS portfolios that were very grainy and not very sharp. which to me, seemed perfectly appropriate for the work being presented, as it must have done for the people assessing it.

I wonder, even though they publish guidance on what is expected, and offer pre-submission reviews, how the exact criteria will cycle and vary as the assessor's "team" changes over time.

I didn't realise they published the online documentary magazine until I published the link to it in my earlier post, and the current version has an article and interview with Colin McPherson about Catching the Tide.
 
Maybe 10-15 years ago I was a member and being close by visited their premises in Bath.
There was zero interest in me as a new member and I found the whole thing made up of fairly exclusive cliques.
No doubt there are many very good photographers enrolled but it had nothing to offer me worth the fee, and most options were optional paid extras.
Maybe its changed since my couple of years experience, good if it has.
 
Maybe 10-15 years ago I was a member and being close by visited their premises in Bath.
There was zero interest in me as a new member and I found the whole thing made up of fairly exclusive cliques.
No doubt there are many very good photographers enrolled but it had nothing to offer me worth the fee, and most options were optional paid extras.
Maybe its changed since my couple of years experience, good if it has.
Certainly, the need to pay extra for the Special Interest Groups, is still an issue for me, especially if you have interests that span across several groups, making the subscription that much more than the basic cost.

But, if these groups were all funded directly by the base subscription, it would mean that every member would pay for groups they had no interest in, and the groups appear to be one of the more interesting aspects of membership.

I'm not trying to justify it, but I've found cliques to be an issue in lots of organisations. Hopefully, in the 10-15 years that might have changed, but it may well depend on exactly what it is you want to become part of.
 
I've never held much regard for them and I've met a number of senior "staff" over the years and done some Limited activities with them.
On the other hand standard membership is £130 which isn't a King's ransom in this day and age so why not try it gor a year and see if it works for you?
 
Can you explain why? Is this just with reference to beginners?

The impression I have had in recent years, is that they are probably worth the membership (but mainly through comments about their specialist interest groups).
Because from its apparent nature I see it as a self-serving clique. As amateurs the only people that we need to satisfy are ourselves. We don't need approval from or validation by any stuffed shirts. If one wants to learn, studying the field along with practice, self-reflection and critique can be very good tutors ...
 
Because from its apparent nature I see it as a self-serving clique. As amateurs the only people that we need to satisfy are ourselves. We don't need approval from or validation by any stuffed shirts. If one wants to learn, studying the field along with practice, self-reflection and critique can be very good tutors ...
I see being a member of the RPS as providing resources that can contribute to "studying the field" and encouraging self-reflection and critique. But I have limited experience of what they have to offer, but it still seemed better than some of the stuff being offered by popular YouTubers.

I'm not sure I follow your approval/validation point.

EDIT: ah do you mean getting the RPS distinction? If you do, I don't see that as being the point of joining.
 
Last edited:
No doubt it may be for some ... ;-)
Yes, I don't disagree.

Many many years ago, getting letters after my name was a strong reason for joining what is now the BIPP and the MPA, but equally it was also being able to advertise to customers that, if unhappy with my service, they could call on either of these professional bodies to mediate their complaints.
 
Hi. I used distinctions as a development tool - I posted about my route to that end. I was also an assessor of the Licenciate from late 2022 until recently. There is a new framework for distinctions coming in January 2027 which is currently up on the website. This involves less cost at A and F because it is no longer a requirement to send in mounted prints with a presentation plan. Have a read, it might seem an interesting thing to do. I first came across the RPS Distinctions at the Photoshow about 15 years ago. I recently was accepted into a gallery with my fine art photography; it is unlikely that this would have happened without improving my work across two different genres. At F, the notion of genres has also been altered - can't remember whilst typing. The road to this point has, it would be fair to say, vexing and frustrating at times. I remain a member and want it to do well.

They sold the building as it was purchased at exactly the wrong time: Covid sent everybody to zoom /teams etc. Asit was pointed out, there is a lot more to it than distinctions. There are interest groups which run activities, many of which are not charged. I developed my interest in producing photobooks from courses with Tim Daly and others.

It is true that you can dp the courses they off without being a member... you pay more. Anyway, hope that helps. it might be up your street or it might not.
 
If you want letters after your name and have a £130 a year surplus then you may get value for money.
Note you have to keep paying to use the letters after your name.
You also have to submit a panel of images to quality for the various awards, although some students can qualify without if I remember rightly.
Personally it's not for me.
 
Out of interest, as I am struggling to understand why discussions about the RPS always seem to end up being about getting the distinctions, rather than the wider benefits of membership. I've looked a bit more deeply into this, and the only data I can find is from 2021.

Membership was only 11000 ( I expected it to be more)

about 27% had an LRPS, 18% ARPS and 5% FRPS

And it does seem that the RPS see getting distinctions as an important part of membership:

"Today, the RPS Distinctions - together with the Society’s exhibition programme, education initiatives and the RPS Journal - are perhaps some of its most important and most highly regarded assets. For many photographers, gaining a Distinction is the reason they join the Society … it was certainly the reason I joined, as a schoolboy some forty years ago, in 1981. "

The quote is from here (and includes a link to the RPS 2021 -2026 strategy)


I couldn't get the link to the strategy on this page to work, but it downloads from here, its 8 pages and an interesting read. I assume there is a more up to date version, but I couldn't find it.

 
"Today, the RPS Distinctions - together with the Society’s exhibition programme, education initiatives and the RPS Journal - are perhaps some of its most important and most highly regarded assets. For many photographers, gaining a Distinction is the reason they join the Society … it was certainly the reason I joined, as a schoolboy some forty years ago, in 1981. "
I can't help but think that's none too far from TV adverts that tell us how wonderful some gadget is, which is being offered for £50, when Amazon sells the same product for £30.

The idea that you pay to get one of these awards and then pay to keep it strikes me as somewhat peculiar.
 
The distinctions themselves describe the person’s relationship with the RPS (Fellow of, Associate of, etc.), so it makes sense that you can’t be an FRPS without being a member. But there’s nothing stopping someone from having a page on their website showing their body of work and saying it achieved an FRPS. No one can take that away.


I have an L/A. I don’t really use the letters after my name, as there’s no point unless someone is really that interested. My motivation is about having some sort of output and helping with personal development. I also think a holistic approach is best, and not putting all your eggs in one basket. YouTube is good for specific advice, but it’s not structured learning. Forums are best for answering specific questions or problem solving. Structured learning (I’m doing a BA at the moment) helps me more with the why and the what, not so much the how. Self-study and photobooks fill certain gaps. Basically, I don’t subscribe to the argument that you shouldn’t do certain things because you have YouTube, or something else.
 
I can't help but think that's none too far from TV adverts that tell us how wonderful some gadget is, which is being offered for £50, when Amazon sells the same product for £30.

The idea that you pay to get one of these awards and then pay to keep it strikes me as somewhat peculiar.
It doesn't seem peculiar to me,

The RPS spend time and money on managing, providing feedback and assessing the applications: better the costs are covered by the member wanting the distinctions, rather than shared across all the members.

And as it's a distinction associated with your membership of the RPS it seems fair enough that the RPS wouldn't want people to join just to get the distinction, and then leave.
 
It doesn't seem peculiar to me,

The RPS spend time and money on managing, providing feedback and assessing the applications: better the costs are covered by the member wanting the distinctions, rather than shared across all the members.

And as it's a distinction associated with your membership of the RPS it seems fair enough that the RPS wouldn't want people to join just to get the distinction, and then leave.
You can gain distinctions from FIAP, PAGB, PSA, BPE, GPU and several other patrons. When you submit for an assessment, you pay a one-off fee which covers the costs so there is no more to pay. As with RPS, there is no guarantee that you will be successful first time. For some of these, it is dependent on successes in international Salons for which you also have to pay a small fee to enter and the Patron receives part of this. When my club started its Salon, the RPS was one of the initial Patrons but they stopped some time ago so are less visible internationally than they were.

Dave
 
You can gain distinctions from FIAP, PAGB, PSA, BPE, GPU and several other patrons. When you submit for an assessment, you pay a one-off fee which covers the costs so there is no more to pay. As with RPS, there is no guarantee that you will be successful first time. For some of these, it is dependent on successes in international Salons for which you also have to pay a small fee to enter and the Patron receives part of this. When my club started its Salon, the RPS was one of the initial Patrons but they stopped some time ago so are less visible internationally than they were.

Dave
I'm not really familiar with any of these, but will look them up.

EDIT: Actually I am familiar with PSA :-)
 
Last edited:
I'm not really familiar with any of these, but will look them up.

EDIT: Actually I am familiar with PSA :-)
Some of these are British only and some are considered to be more valuable than RPS distinctions. For example, I attended to assessment of MPAGB some years ago and, of the 20 applicants, all were FRPS but only one succeeded in gaining MPAGB (his work was very exceptional).

Dave
 
Some of these are British only and some are considered to be more valuable than RPS distinctions. For example, I attended to assessment of MPAGB some years ago and, of the 20 applicants, all were FRPS but only one succeeded in gaining MPAGB (his work was very exceptional).

Dave
For me, I'm interested in what the different organisations give to members, rather than the distinctions they offer, and I'm not sure how easy it is to compare the relative standards adopted by the different organisations.
 
For me, I'm interested in what the different organisations give to members, rather than the distinctions they offer, and I'm not sure how easy it is to compare the relative standards adopted by the different organisations.
Club members have plenty of services and support so generally go for distinctions to:

a. Challenge themselves.
b. to try to impress others
c. if a lecturer or judge to have some credibility.

In my view a, is the most common reason.
Interestingly, FIAP issue its members with a card which is intended to show you are an amateur. Many have sneered at this but it has got me past several security barriers to take photographs which would have been otherwise impossible.

Dave
 
Club members have plenty of services and support so generally go for distinctions to:

a. Challenge themselves.
b. to try to impress others
c. if a lecturer or judge to have some credibility.

In my view a, is the most common reason.
Interestingly, FIAP issue its members with a card which is intended to show you are an amateur. Many have sneered at this but it has got me past several security barriers to take photographs which would have been otherwise impossible.

Dave
I understand the motivation for distinctions, but when it comes to me assessing whether they are worthwhile joining, I'm much more interested in the services they offer their members, and what they contribute to "photography".
 
Back
Top