Shootout: Nokia N8 v Canon 550D DSLR

Looks to me like all the canon shots where taken wide open where as the N8 ones will probably be around F8 or more, thus accounting for the difference in apparent detail.
 
Yeah, they really need to do a like for like test using the exactly the same settings.
 
Nothing like a nice biased review :D

Both great looking pictures, but I love the deeper blues on the N8.

While totally ignoring the building and trees are underexposed on the N8 :D
 
"Personally speaking, I’d like to give this round to the N8. The Canon has over-exposed it for my taste."

No....the guy holding the camera overexposed it...jesus!

The fact that those 100% crops look sharper on the Nokia is also suspicious.

But in all fairness the quality of the N8 is remarkable considering its a camera phone.
 
How many MP is is the N8 supposed to be? I'd be interested to see a low light comparrison test.
 
Make believe. I convinced myself a G12 would work as well as my 40d. Went and bought one, used it for a day, decided it wasn't close to as good and back to the 40d. G12 sits in its box, I'll sell/give it someone for xmas! Don't fool yourself!
 
I'd like to see a nice long exposure test while tripod mounted personally...




think about it...
 
If you look at the exif of the pictures (they're all intact) you can see what settings were used.

A mobile phone wont ever compare to a DSLR in terms of image quality, however at the end of the day the best camera in the world is no good unless you have it with you!

i.jpg


11072009334a.jpg


These are 2 pictures taken on my old Nokia N95 and N85, sure they're not brilliant (though the dog shot does look good on the large canvas I have on my wall!) These pictures are better than my DSLR simply because I didnt have it with me!

IMO these 'comparison' gimmicks dont make me think that I dont need my DSLR, though they do put my off buying a point and shoot!

Regards

Neil
 
Last edited:
These pictures are better than my DSLR simply because I didnt have it with me!

IMO these 'comparison' gimmicks dont make me think that I dont need my DSLR, though they do put my off buying a point and shoot!
Both very good points, Neil.

I'm increasingly finding that my camera phone is useful for snapshots in situations where I don't have my DSLR (which is most of the time). The main issue I find is that because the lens is so small and so vulnerable, it is VERY easy for it to get dirty, which causes a significant drop in contrast. I think that's happened to your dog photo.
 
Both very good points, Neil.

I'm increasingly finding that my camera phone is useful for snapshots in situations where I don't have my DSLR (which is most of the time). The main issue I find is that because the lens is so small and so vulnerable, it is VERY easy for it to get dirty, which causes a significant drop in contrast. I think that's happened to your dog photo.

I agree, the lens is very vulnerable, of course this is not helped by getting your phone in and out of your pocket all the time!

As I said before it really does put my off buying a new point and shoot camera to stash in the car for those 'snapshot' moments - only advantage is that the point and shoots flash is a hundred times better!

Regards

Neil
 
To my eyes, camera phones are fine for spur of the moment photography when you have no other camera on you, or if you are doing a camera phone project, say. I really don't think that at the moment, they can be seriously considered as a replacement for your compact, let alone an SLR, down to the limited control, image / lens quality, and lens flexibility. However, they are highly portable, and if they're the only camera you have on you, then they suddenly become the best available!!
 
Make believe. I convinced myself a G12 would work as well as my 40d. Went and bought one, used it for a day, decided it wasn't close to as good and back to the 40d. G12 sits in its box, I'll sell/give it someone for xmas! Don't fool yourself!

Completely different cameras.

You might as well compare the 40D to a Hasselblad.

(Which incidentally also covers my opinion of the original review!)
 
Back
Top