Should a lens hood work at all focal lengths?

The Canon 24-70 f/2.8 uses it's hood effectively at all focal lengths due to a clever design.
 
Best with the correct hood for the lens to get optimum benefit.
Hoods for zooms are likely to be a compromise.
 
it all depends on the A O V of the lens and what it is zoomed to,if it is a zoom lens. Petal hoods are a compromise, as hoods are for a super wide angle. I don`t like these new fangled hoods, they put a strain on the front of the lens when you lock it in position.
 
Depends if you're using the right lens hood for your lens.

The lens that came supplied with my Sigma 10-20mm is great at all focal lengths. If I tried to use a hood designed for something like a 70-200mm on it, then I'd probably have issues. :)
 
Depends if you're using the right lens hood for your lens.

The lens that came supplied with my Sigma 10-20mm is great at all focal lengths. If I tried to use a hood designed for something like a 70-200mm on it, then I'd probably have issues. :)

It`s the one that came with it.
 
Just fitting a filter under the hood can cause vignetting too - something to be aware of.
 
Is it the lens hood made for that lens?

If the lens hood is a Canon hood designed for that lens, then I would think there shouldn't be a problem. You never know though. ;)

I bought a 'Nikon compatible' lens hood for one of my lenses, and comparing it side by side with the broken original, it was a slightly different design. I didn't get a chance to try it out before my lens was stolen though to see if it performed the same way. :shrug:

I've seen some people just using a generic lens hood which covers a range, normally 70-300mm, and have vignetting problems. Getting at least a copy specific to the lens is not usually more expensive than a generic hood.

edit Took too long writing my reply, as I see it is the correct hood.
 
I did say it can cause vignetting and it often does - it all depends how much clearance the lens hood gives you - some have virtually none to start with and a filter can then cause vignetting.
 
If the hood screws on the end of the filter (like on a 50mm f/1.8D, for example), then the filter can play a big issue.

When the hood attaches to the end of the lens itself and doesn't screw onto a filter, the filter or hood *usually* shouldn't cause any issues.
 
An ideal lens hood shades right to the edge of the image area and is completely black inside. Velvet flocking is about as close as you can get to that.

A hood can only ever be optimum at one focal length on the sensor format for which it was designed, so EF lenses used on crop format cameras can never be optimum. There is only one lens that I know of where the hood is optimum at all focal lengths, and that's the Canon 24-70L mentioned above (only on full frame). This lens is unusual in that it extends as focal length is reduced and the lens moves within it, so it is effectively a zooming lens hood; most zooms go the other way. Nikon 24-70 2.8 is somewhat similar.

In the case of the OP's 24-105L hood, that is only optimum at 24mm on full frame. If you use it on a crop format camera, ideally it should be longer. Frankly, it's so short it is only any use for physical protection. I shoot portraits with that lens on full frame and, because I'm usually at the long end, use a hood from a 100-400L which is 9cm deep - almost as long as the lens itself. It doesn't vignette from 80mm-plus and reduces flare a lot when shooting bright white backgrounds.

The best lens hoods are rectangular, as they follow the shape of the image. Petal hoods are in fact rectangular when viewed from the lens position (hold one to your eye to see) although with the 24-105L's hood the long edges are cut off flat so you can stand the lens down on it and it won't fall over. Petal hoods are cheaper to make than rectangular, are stronger and can be reversed over the lens for storage.
 
Back
Top